11 ms·
I wonder if the copyright owners could do something to stop the officers? What the officers are doing is probably a public performance and those generally requi
by tzs 6y ago
I wonder if the copyright owners could do something to stop the officers? What the officers are doing is probably a public performance and those generally requires permission of the copyright owner.
There are some exceptions, such as for playing a radio or TV broadcast at businesses that are under certain sizes specified in square feet. I think the officers were probably playing recording from their phones or using a streaming service, which I don't think the exception cover. And even if those exceptions do apply, the officers are doing this outside--how many square feet is outside?
There was also a 2020 Supreme Court ruling that state governments were not liable for copyright violations because they have sovereign immunity. That sovereign immunity can be taken away by Congress, and I believe there has been some talk of doing so, but for now they are immune.
According to this law firm [1] that does not apply to local governments. They might still be liable for copyright infringement.
[1] https://www.hodgsonruss.com/newsroom-publications-11717.html https://www.hodgsonruss.com/newsroom-publications-11717.html
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoI know everyone is looking for a loophole to prosecute these officers But let’s not rush to make listening to music on the job illegal. That wasn’t the intent of copyright laws that prohibit public performance.
- SilasX 6y agoAgreed, but I think it's at least a defensible case if you activate the music specifically and only when you know you're being recorded for a mass audience.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoSo the officers just claim they always listen to music? Or that they were simply trying to send a message that they were done with the conversation with someone who is following them around on the job? Which seems to be the case here, honestly. Or that they didn’t know that a random person with a phone had a massive YouTube following combined with intent to post this video online? I know everyone wants to stick it to these cops, but let’s be realistic. Normally HN is very against weaponizing copyright law, but the second it feels useful for their purposes we’re flooded with comments from people who want to misuse copyright law as a weapon.
- bmicraft 6y agoMaybe they should turn it down a bit while on the job? There is no reason the music should to be heard outside their car.
- mc32 6y agoHmmm, I’d like to see this applied to many a teenager eager to have me listen to their choice of music for free from afar.
- monocasa 6y agoI hold police to a higher professional standard than I do lackadaisical teenagers.
- mc32 6y agoBoth are playing music loudly and projecting it openly. Either it’s allowed for all or allowed for none. I’m good with either decision as long as it’s consistent.
- rootusrootus 6y agoMy employer expects me to keep my music quiet (preferably confined to my ears only) when I am at the office. At home I can play it loud enough that the neighbors can hear it, and that's okay. I'm fine with professional officers being held to different standards when they are on duty.
- gowld 6y agoThe police are being obnoxious but they are exploiting the streaming platforms and the rightsholders. That's where the problem is. It doesn't making any sense to ask the rightsholders to pressure the police to stop using a tactic that only works because the rightholders want it to work.
- RIMR 6y agoI think it's more important to focus on is the rationality of enforcing copyright law against music captured in the background of a video. Fair use should be much more broad. So long as the video isn't produced for profit, the producer isn't unfairly benefitting off the presence of the music in the video, and the quality of the audio doesn't compete with that of a commercial recording, I don't see the issue.
- 1MoreThing 6y agoThese rules were created specifically because so many people were profiting off the ad revenue of music in videos. There's not a simple way to determine if the audio just happens to be in the background or if the content producer is benefiting from the inclusion of music they don't have rights to.
- gowld 6y agoIt's trivial: demonetize the video, or extract the standard license fee from the ad revenue. YouTube already knows how to do this.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoYeah, because I know that when I am trying to speak clearly to another human being in an emotionally heightened situation, I always do it while listening to my favorite jams.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe person doing the recording operates multiple Instagram accounts where he tries to provoke reactions from cops who are trying to do their job. He sells anti-police merchandise through these accounts. It’s not correct to suggest that this was a routine interaction with police. Despite the headline, the videos are still up on his social media accounts.
- phjesusthatguy3 6y agooh stop
- woah 6y agoAre you serious? You’re telling me you think police officers should go around blasting tunes on a boom box? Seems like a serious lack of professionalism. What a straw man
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoNo, I did not say that at all. The videos in question are still online. They haven’t been removed. It’s clear that the person filming is following police around, trying to provoke a reaction for his Instagram accounts where he sells anti-cop merchandise.
- dahart 6y ago> let’s not rush to make listening to music on the job illegal. I’m wondering if it already is illegal for police officers who wear body cams, even when their routine video is not public record. They are recordings intended for other people, and they also can become public record when use of force is involved, as I understand it.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAs far as I can tell, these recordings are from an uninvolved 3rd party who has several social media accounts dedicated to recording the police, from which he sells merchandise. This isn’t a case of victims being drowned out of rightful conversations during arrests. This is a 3rd party trying to insert themselves into police duties and provoke a response while recording. His Instagram accounts for these videos promote his anti-cop merchandise. It appears the videos haven’t actually been taken down. I’m sure he’s loving the attention, though.
- narrator 6y agoWatch the cops just pay the ASCAP fee. That's the fee the music industry makes bar owners pay if they want to play music in their bar.
- minitoar 6y agoI really don’t think this is the right approach. Plenty of motorcycles have speakers built in, and they’re blasting Creedence all the time. They should be allowed to.
- BEEdwards 6y agoNo one wants to hear your shitty music, get headphones.
- carlob 6y agoor your engine for that matter, get a bicycle!
- pbourke 6y agoEarly in the evenin' just about supper time Over by the courthouse they're starting to unwind Four kids on the corner trying to bring you up “Headphones, please” you shout at them “and kindly shut the fuck up”
- josephpmay 6y agoIn many states that is illegal
- minitoar 6y agoThat sir is illegal. I have to blast Creedence or I can't hear it over the wind noise. I think there are laws about how you shouldn't be able to hear music above a certain volume at a certain distance from a vehicle, but I haven't heard of it being applied to motorcycles.
- tzs 6y agoThe law is quite capable of distinguishing between someone listening to music for their own enjoyment that happens to be overheard by others, and someone intentionally directing music at strangers for purposes of furthering their own business interests. What the officers are doing seems more akin to a business use to me, since they are doing it to affect how they can perform their job, so I'm curious if they need to license the songs.
- spoonjim 6y agoExcept no record executives are going to sue the Beverly Hills PD because they all live in Beverly Hills and those cops can and will make their lives a living hell.
- gspr 6y ago> There was also a 2020 Supreme Court ruling that state governments were not liable for copyright violations because they have sovereign immunity. What, what? Does this mean that state governments can freely pirate software for example?
- tzs 6y agoFor now it appears so [1][2]. [1] https://itsartlaw.org/2020/05/11/case-review-allen-v-cooper-2020/ https://itsartlaw.org/2020/05/11/case-review-allen-v-cooper-... [2] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-877_dc8f.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-877_dc8f.pdf
- toast0 6y agoWhat about if you're a company doing that Nevada company town thing? Hmmm
- elil17 6y agoCities and counties don’t have sovereign immunity. Sovereign immunity is a holdover from Britain, where you couldn’t sue the ruler or any of their assets. Because states started out viewing themselves as independent countries, sovereign immunity was extended to them by courts. Smaller governments have never had sovereign immunity.
- User23 6y agoTotally incorrect. The courts didn't and can't grant the States sovereignty. They were sovereign states before entering the union and they relinquished some of their sovereign powers by signing the constitution, but certainly not all of them, or indeed any at all that aren't explicitly enumerated in the constitution.
- skissane 6y ago> Totally incorrect. The courts didn't and can't grant the States sovereignty. They were sovereign states before entering the union and they relinquished some of their sovereign powers by signing the constitution The original 13 colonies, Vermont and Texas were all independent sovereign states before joining the United States as states. However, the other 35 states were federal territories to which Congress granted statehood. Whatever sovereignty they have was given to them by the United States Congress, acting under the United States Constitution, it did not in any way pre-exist the Constitution. (Hawaii was an independent sovereign state before being annexed into a US territory after a US-backed coup; to the extent that the present state of Hawaii has "sovereignty", it is unclear what relationship that had to the sovereignty of the independent Kingdom of Hawaii.)
- ngngngng 6y agoLet's not throw a bandaid on a flesh wound. What we need is strong, fast acting civilian oversight over the police to punish any that get up to shenanigans like this.
- austincheney 6y agoPunish police from playing music? Seriously, a flesh wound? Let's call this a catastrophic decapitation that demands immediate jail time without possibility for parole like human trafficking and serial-arson.
- ngngngng 6y agoThe "flesh wound" in question is complete lack of accountability and oversight of police officers, not this one instance of them playing music.
- austincheney 6y agoThe subject literally is about two police officers in Beverly Hills who played music. There is no mention of brutality, any violation, or any history of violations.
- fuzxi 6y agoTwo police officers in Beverly Hills who played music for the express purpose of masking lawful recordings of them, such that they're extremely difficult to post online unmuted. Recording an on-duty peace officer is protected by the First Amendment. Officers intentionally making it difficult to disseminate those recordings should not be taken lightly.
- austincheney 6y agoThen tell Instagram how offensive you find them.
- bonestamp2 6y agoThey should just write a law that includes diegetic music in not for profit non-fiction public servant videos in fair use. Then if your video gets flagged you can indicate it is fair use.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoNo change in the law is necessary; it's already fair use. Compare https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.mad.220892/gov.uscourts.mad.220892.30.0.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.mad.220892/... : > Monsarrat raises a copyright infringement claim against Newman involving the republication of a comment he originally posted in the Davis Square LiveJournal community in 2010 > Newman contends that Monsarrat has failed to state an actionable claim because the allegations in the FAC establish his entitlement to a fair use defense. > The Copyright Act codifies four non-exclusive factors relevant to the fair use inquiry: > (1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes; > (2) the nature of the copyrighted work; > (3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and > (4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work. > drawing all reasonable inferences in Monsarrat’s favor, the court agrees that the FAC establishes Newman’s entitlement to a fair use defense as a matter of law. > As to the first factor, it is clear from the face of the FAC [...], that Newman did not publish the copyrighted post for the same purposes for which Monsarrat initially created it. > Monsarrat submitted the original post to highlight LiveJournal’s harassment policy and demand deletion of other posts on the community website which he viewed as violative. The Dreamwidth reproduction, on the other hand, was created solely for historical and preservationist purposes. See Bill Graham Archives v. Dorling Kindersley Ltd., [...] (finding that the use of concert posters in a book on the history of the Grateful Dead served a different purpose than the original purpose of "artistic expression and promotion" because defendant used the concert posters "as historical artifacts to document and represent the actual occurrence of Grateful Dead concert events"); Stern v. Does, [...] (finding that defendants’ forwarding by email of a copyrighted post “conveyed the fact of the post rather than its underlying message” and “thus had a substantially different purpose than the post itself”) > Turning to the second factor, the “nature of the copyrighted work,” the balance again tips in Newman’s favor. The post largely repeats the LiveJournal harassment policy, a factual matter > The third factor, "the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole," "focus[es] upon whether the extent of... copying is consistent with or more than necessary to further the purpose and character of the use." > see also Haberman, [...] ("[I]t has long been recognized that a commentator may fairly reproduce as much of the original, copyrighted work as is necessary to his proper purpose."). > This factor is neutral. Newman copied Monsarrat’s post in full, but a full reproduction is consistent with historical and preservationist purposes. > Finally, the fourth factor, "the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work" – "the single most important element of fair use," Harper & Row, [...] – weighs against Monsarrat. There is no plausible market for the copyrighted post and thus no likelihood that Newman’s reproduction could have any harmful market consequences. Applying that to the case of a police officer playing copyrighted music into a livestream of police officer behavior, it is obvious that the first factor ("transformative use") favors the streamer, who is both documenting and commenting on the behavior of the police; the second factor favors the copyright owner ("music sold commercially"); the third factor may range from neutrality to favoring the streamer, depending on how much music the police officer chooses to play -- in the example here, the streamer is favored -- and the fourth factor favors the copyright owner. However, there is a compelling case that, no matter how much music the officer plays, that is the appropriate amount for the streamer to record -- first, the purpose of documenting what the police are doing is not served by censoring what they do, but additionally, the more egregious the copying, the more noteworthy the officer's behavior is. Furthermore, while it is possible that a video of police behavior in which everyone is respectfully silent while Santeria plays might substitute for other means of consuming the song, it is extremely unlikely, which trivializes the impact of the fourth factor. Here ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3ZeUL4fRyk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3ZeUL4fRyk ) is a YouTube video consisting of the song played over a background of the album art. And here ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEYN5w4T_aM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEYN5w4T_aM ) is another YouTube video, from "TheofficialSublime", of the official music video of the song. It is not plausible that consumers seeking to consume the song for enjoyment would prefer the cop video to either of those, or even that they might be more likely to find the cop video.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI would rather have police playing music and have our lawmakers cleanup the cesspooll that is current copyright law. There is no reason a poloce department could not actually purchise right to some random tune, and play it publically and ligitimately, and that would still get your videos banned.
- burkaman 6y agoIt is almost impossible to prosecute police for straightforward violent crimes, I don't think anybody is going to get them on copyright infringement.
- justaguy88 6y agoIt might be easier with copyright, since it wont rely on the local prosecutor to do anything, the artist can sue
- retrac 6y agoThe copyright holder could sue, which is rarely the artist. In this case it would be Sony.
- tzs 6y agoPaul McCartney got the Beatles catalog back from Sony in mid-2017 [1]. [1] https://liveforlivemusic.com/news/paul-mccartney-beatles-rights-win/ https://liveforlivemusic.com/news/paul-mccartney-beatles-rig...
- bogomipz 6y agoThis would actually fall under a "sync license" which requires approval by both the master rights holder as well as the composition owner which is the artist although it cold be the artist and their publishing company if they have sold shares to them. See "permissions needed" here: https://musicbusinessmadeeasy.com/understanding-the-music-synchronization-license/ https://musicbusinessmadeeasy.com/understanding-the-music-sy...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It is almost impossible to prosecute police for straightforward violent crimes, That's because criminal prosecution is limited to people who have a professional dependency on cooperation by LEOs. Civil prosecution does not, and while individual officers may have qualified immunity, state/local government agencies, including police departments, have no legal privilege to disregard copyright.
- Veserv 6y agoInvoking copyright law is unnecessary. It is far simpler and more narrow to claim that they are engaging in the willful destruction or concealment of evidence which is a violation of California Penal Code 135 PC [1][2]. How so? 1. There is a video recording. This is specifically mentioned as a protected category. 2. The video recording of officer conduct prior to and during an arrest constitutes material evidence. Recordings of officer conduct have been entered into evidence previously, so this fulfills the requirement that it be evidence. 3. Officer conduct prior to and during an arrest constitutes an inquiry or investigation. This article indicates that actions prior to an arrest constitute pre-arrest investigation [3] and thus fulfills that requirement. 4. Copyrighted music in the video recording reduces the discoverability of the evidence possibly to the degree of non-discoverability when it previously would have been discoverable. This appears to be at least concealment. 5. The accusation that the officers are deliberately playing copyrighted music resulting in the reduced discoverability. This fulfills the willfulness requirement. 1-4 establish that the specific outcomes observed constitute the hiding of evidence. It should be uncontroversial that the evidence has become less discoverable. 5 is then the only material question, which is whether it was done with the intent to cause the concealment of evidence. Based on the above logic, I think it is fairly safe to say that, if they are doing as claimed, then they are violating California Penal Code 135 PC. The only part in the above logic that seems weak is point 3 as I am not sure if it is actually an inquiry or investigation. If point 3 is invalid, then I think the best thing to do would be to amend it to include officer conduct during pre-arrest investigation with respect to the eventually arrested party. This is a far better option than invoking copyright law as it would be narrowly defined to only target the specific willful action that seems unethical which is intentionally playing copyrighted music to prevent the posting of video recordings. [1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN§ionNum=135 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio.... [2] https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/defense/penal-code/135/#:~:text=Penal%20Code%20135%20PC%20is,6%20months%20in%20county%20jail https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/defense/penal-code/135/#:~:text.... [3] https://law.lclark.edu/live/news/5498-what-are-some-common-steps-of-a-criminal#:~:text=Law%20enforcement%20investigates%20whether%20a,an%20arrest%20should%20be%20made https://law.lclark.edu/live/news/5498-what-are-some-common-s....
- mjh2539 6y agoThe police officer didn't make and distribute the recording. No dice.
- User23 6y ago> I wonder if the copyright owners could do something to stop the officers? The copyright owners probably live in Beverly Hills and are quite alright with their police keeping the riff-raff out.
- blendergeek 6y agoI believe that the state has sovereign immunity and can commit copyright infringement without any repercussions. [0] [0] https://www.copyright.gov/policy/state-sovereign-immunity/ https://www.copyright.gov/policy/state-sovereign-immunity/