4 ms·
An inflationist currency is great if you are deep in debt or like cheap consumer credit. Deflation (or really constant value) means that those who save, build
by tomjen3 15y ago
An inflationist currency is great if you are deep in debt or like cheap consumer credit.
Deflation (or really constant value) means that those who save, build things and invest wisely will benefit.
And no, I am not going to starve today, so that I can get marginally more bread a year from now.
- ap22213 15y agoI don't know. Maybe. It seems like it would just create aristocracy. If I inherit a large sum of money, I have incentive to ensure that my large sum of money increases (or at least doesn't decrease) in value in the easiest, least risky way possible. If my wealth was in bitcoin, I wouldn't have to do much, except ensure that more people join bitcoin and that the bitcoin didn't disappear. Otherwise, I would just play warcraft all day, procreate, and then die and split my wealth amongst my children to continue the cycle. If my wealth was in an inflationary currency, I would have much more incentive to take on risk. Perhaps through that risk taking, I end up losing my wealth, and others gain. Or, perhaps I gain more wealth. At least I have incentive to take productive action.
- njs12345 15y agoOf course, most forms of wealth people have aren't inflationary anyway - the very wealthy tend to have little in terms of actual liquid currency and more stock and property. It has been argued (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_tax) that inflation can be thought of as a regressive tax for this reason.
- ap22213 15y agoExactly. As nl stated [1], bitcoin would turn the currency into an investment. The very wealthy who would otherwise hold stock and property would instead have incentive to just hold the bitcoin currency. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2611613 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2611613
- njs12345 15y agoMy point was more of an observation about the aristocracy point. Often the rich do still take significant risks with their wealth even though the effects of inflation are negligible on them. I'm unsure about the deflationary aspect of bitcoin - in my opinion the degree to which it is problematic depends on the rate of depreciation compared to other assets. It seems more of a problem if you wanted to use bitcoin to replace a sovereign currency, rather than use it as a currency on a smaller scale intended for grey market/black market transactions. I think the appreciation of the currency over time was probably intended to ensure it originally took off by providing an incentive for early adopters; its dubious legal status probably means it's a poor long term investment choice anyway. To some extent this discussion is entirely academic anyway - bitcoin is being used as a currency right now (see the Silk Road Market), so in that sense it's already succeeded..
- thomasz 15y agoThat proves the point. They have to invest their wealth in stock, real estate etc. instead of putting it in a chest/thumb drive and burying it on a lonely island in order to keep it.
- hugh3 15y ago... which is surely a very good thing? If cash paid a better return than most investments then we wouldn't have anyone to invest in things.
- knowtheory 15y ago> And no, I am not going to starve today, so that I can get marginally more bread a year from now. That only works if a majority of your assets or earnings are in bitcoins (e.g. you have to convert them in order to live), or if bitcoins are exchangeable for necessities. If the article's author is correct (and he is imo) and it's more sensible to look at Bitcoin as a commodity, not a currency, then i think your assertion is a red herring.
- sethg 15y agoIn order for one person to be able to save (or invest), someone else has to be willing to borrow (or sell stock).