5 ms·
It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? I'm sure Apple pays Google for t
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? I'm sure Apple pays Google for the service, and probably on a per request basis, so proxying and caching data will reduce their costs... In theory, I'm sure there's contractual obligations in place.
(from personal experience, we used a service in a project once to fetch stock market data. It was a good faith agreement, we had to maintain our own tallies of how often a stock price was fetched, tell them, and we'd be charged accordingly. This made sense because from them we just got a 20 mbit inbound pipeline of stock updates, which we fed into a Gemfire (which is now apparently called "VMware Tanzu™ GemFire®") cluster and exposed to end-users via a simple REST API. (It was a bank, of course we couldn't change firewall rules to allow websockets or whatever was available at the time).
- coldtea 6y ago>It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? How is this about "data mining"? If they have built their own safe browsing service they'd be in the exact same position to do data mining!
- move-on-by 6y ago> It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? I'm sure Apple doesn't need to build APIs to do data mining on their own users. It would be very un-apple to create an API like this and allow non-apple devices to use it. So where is the benefit on data mining? Privacy (in a consumer and marketing sense) is a major market advantage. I think that Apple has determined that keeping data away from 3rd parties is a good way to capitalize on that market edge vs. giving up the edge and engaging in the same consumer exploitation as their competitors.
- gpanders 6y ago> Privacy (in a consumer and marketing sense) is a major market advantage. I think that Apple has determined that keeping data away from 3rd parties is a good way to capitalize on that market edge vs. giving up the edge and engaging in the same consumer exploitation as their competitors. I agree, this seems like the simplest and most straight-forward explanation to me.
- AshamedCaptain 6y agoYet it would be ridiculous to claim a privacy advantage by doing this move, since the only change here is sending your browsing activity to Apple instead of Google. And the Safe Browsing stuff is already kinda high in the "anonymized" scale anyway, up to the point Mozilla uses it. If they wanted to claim privacy advantage, they could offer these lists for rsyncable download, like antivirus of more civilized eras used to do.
- tchalla 6y ago> It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? How does Apple building its own service smell like "data mining"? You can build your own service and not be a data miner.
- gruez 6y ago> I'm sure Apple pays Google for the service, and probably on a per request basis, so proxying and caching data will reduce their costs... In theory, I'm sure there's contractual obligations in place. It's free. https://developers.google.com/safe-browsing/v4/pricing https://developers.google.com/safe-browsing/v4/pricing
- Androider 6y agoNo such thing. A company like Apple doesn't just click through a Google developer agreement and generate some API keys and off they go. All integrations will have explicit agreements reviewed by an army of lawyers.
- Sephr 6y agoThe cited page literally states "All use of Safe Browsing APIs is free of charge." Emphasis 'all'. There may be meetings, but it's still free.
- karmakaze 6y ago> It smells like data mining to me Whether it is or isn't (at the moment) data mining I won't debate. My concern is sending that much of my behavioural information through a point controlled by one party.
- throwanem 6y agoLike Google?