6 ms·
Am I the only one who thinks that this is a neutral move with some pedestrian reason like "we'd like to be able to dynamically change our Safe Browsing endpoint
by saagarjha 6y ago
Am I the only one who thinks that this is a neutral move with some pedestrian reason like "we'd like to be able to dynamically change our Safe Browsing endpoint in the future" or "let's not hardcode our API keys into Safari"?
- ComodoHacker 6y agoApple servers are whitelisted in adblocking and firewall APIs, so this move makes sure Safe Browsing works when the user or some app messes up with those.
- gruez 6y agoWhy would apple's servers be whitelisted but not google's? Considering all the google devices/software out there (eg. android, chrome), not whitelisting google is probably going to cause more issues than not whitelisting apple.
- tchalla 6y agoWhy should whitelisting depend on popularity?
- gruez 6y agoWhy wouldn't it? More popular = more users = more people complaining when stuff breaks = more political pressure to get it fixed.
- tchalla 6y agoWhy should we allow stuff just because “stuff breaks”? It’s totally fine to have “stuff break” if they don’t benefit the objective laid out. We “break” a lot of stuff in our society with our laws.
- gruez 6y ago>Why should be allow stuff just something “it breaks”? what??
- tchalla 6y agoIt is fine to break stuff even if it is popular as it doesn't achieve the overall objective. There's no compulsion to allow something just because it is popular.
- gruez 6y agoIn the context of this discussion (blocking at enterprises), I doubt any sysadmin is going to be able to convince the leadership that blocking all google services is an acceptable trade-off. If you're doing the blocking yourself on your own network then sure whatever, you don't really care whether google stuff breaks, but you probably also have safebrowsing disabled, or know how to whitelist the safebrowsing endpoint yourself if you need it, so the whitelist argument isn't relevant in that context.
- tchalla 6y ago> In the context of this discussion (blocking at enterprises), I doubt any sysadmin is going to be able to convince the leadership that blocking all google services is an acceptable trade-off. If that was the case, here was the original comment. > Apple servers are whitelisted in adblocking and firewall APIs What exactly did you disagree with?
- tialaramex 6y agoNope. Mother Nature doesn't have to care whether her rules are popular, the laws of thermodynamics are actually very unpopular, but they apply anyway. However people can disobey our laws and so if they aren't popular enough they're worthless. The UK used to have laws controlling the ownership of dogs. Each dog required a license, licenses were taxed and you could be refused a license. But that law was very unpopular, and so it was abolished - not because licensing dog ownership wasn't a good idea, but because even if it was a great idea it was too unpopular to succeed.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoBecause Google runs ad servers. Using an ad blockers would be pointless if Google domains were allowed to bypass.
- gruez 6y agoAgain, like I said previous comment google runs a bunch of other services that you can't just block the entire google ASN and not expect stuff to break. As for who's doing the blocking, there are basically two groups: enterprise sysadmins (or their vendors) and hobbyists running pi-hole at home. The former would certainly care about breakage, and likely isn't concerned about ads. Not to mention if they block safebrowsing (or google software updates) and they get hacked because of it, that'd look really bad on them. Hobbyists would care less about breakage and more about ads, but I suspect the same hobbyists don't care much for safebrowsing and probably has it disabled so whether it gets whitelisted or not is irrelevant.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> google runs a bunch of other services Trust does not compartmentalize.
- gruez 6y agoThe point isn't that you must trust google or anything, but that if you are serving users other than yourself, blocking the entirety of google isn't a viable option. In the case that you're only doing it for yourself, you likely have safeblocking disabled or know how to whitelist the safebrowsing endpoint yourself (it's a separate domain) that it's a non-issue.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> if you are serving users other than yourself, blocking the entirety of google isn't a viable option This is a fair assumption to challenge. Lots of developers co-mingling their traffic with an ad company doesn't mean everyone has to whitelist their servers. It's an impediment. But Apple has navigated those.
- ComodoHacker 6y agoBecause Apple doesn't control Google's servers.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoIt smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? I'm sure Apple pays Google for the service, and probably on a per request basis, so proxying and caching data will reduce their costs... In theory, I'm sure there's contractual obligations in place. (from personal experience, we used a service in a project once to fetch stock market data. It was a good faith agreement, we had to maintain our own tallies of how often a stock price was fetched, tell them, and we'd be charged accordingly. This made sense because from them we just got a 20 mbit inbound pipeline of stock updates, which we fed into a Gemfire (which is now apparently called "VMware Tanzu™ GemFire®") cluster and exposed to end-users via a simple REST API. (It was a bank, of course we couldn't change firewall rules to allow websockets or whatever was available at the time).
- coldtea 6y ago>It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? How is this about "data mining"? If they have built their own safe browsing service they'd be in the exact same position to do data mining!
- move-on-by 6y ago> It smells like data mining to me; instead of building their own safe browsing service, why not just defer to Google's services? I'm sure Apple doesn't need to build APIs to do data mining on their own users. It would be very un-apple to create an API like this and allow non-apple devices to use it. So where is the benefit on data mining? Privacy (in a consumer and marketing sense) is a major market advantage. I think that Apple has determined that keeping data away from 3rd parties is a good way to capitalize on that market edge vs. giving up the edge and engaging in the same consumer exploitation as their competitors.
- gpanders 6y ago> Privacy (in a consumer and marketing sense) is a major market advantage. I think that Apple has determined that keeping data away from 3rd parties is a good way to capitalize on that market edge vs. giving up the edge and engaging in the same consumer exploitation as their competitors. I agree, this seems like the simplest and most straight-forward explanation to me.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoThe head of Webkit says this is related to privacy (preventing an info leak). I think that's a pretty good confirmation that the reason is not (simply) pedestrian. https://twitter.com/othermaciej/status/1359736220809531393?s=20 https://twitter.com/othermaciej/status/1359736220809531393?s...
- jmull 6y agoDefinitely not... because there's no need to proxy all the requests just to be able to dynamically change the endpoint (or other details about how/if it accesses the safe browsing endpoint). In aggregate, that's not insignificant traffic, so you wouldn't want to use your own resources to process it without a worthwhile reason.
- arbitrage 6y agoYes. Or, google/apple have a payment structure between them, and it's just easier to aggregate usage and charge for it this way. this doesn't really pass the smell test of "is there something fishy going on around here?"