4 ms·
> The taxes were already accounted for, my claim is on top of what you already contributed. Not according to you, as you view taxes as inherently illegitimate.
by Apocryphon 6y ago
> The taxes were already accounted for, my claim is on top of what you already contributed.
Not according to you, as you view taxes as inherently illegitimate. Though if you have a Patreon or GoFundMe to validate your claim then by all means.
> Its all very simple, if you don’t give them what they want, they threaten you at first and then they come take what they want.
If you don't wear clothes, you'd be arrested for public indecency.
> You get a lot for your trouble when you give up aggressive violence.
Tell it to the Iroquois, sadly.
> If your society is dependent on violence and coercion, then perhaps your society shouldn’t exist.
Then say you don't believe in society.
> You get a lot for your trouble when you give up aggressive violence.
Then why not give away property, as well? There are arguments to be made that private property violates the NAP.
> For my part, the only way to find an answer is to have the debate.
There really isn't an answer to be had in a debate, because fundamentally both sides are operating from stances so alien from one another to essentially be in different languages. "Taxation is theft" and "taxation is not theft" is not really meaningful in this context, as there is no agreed upon definition of what theft is. Despite its unanswerable nature, it is still quite enjoyable.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Not according to you, as you view taxes as inherently illegitimate. Though if you have a Patreon or GoFundMe to validate your claim then by all means. I’m responding to taxes the way you responded to my request for some of your surplus. You’re asserting you already paid taxes, you don’t get to decide how much tax you pay. > If you don't wear clothes, you'd be arrested for public indecency. I concede that laws requiring clothing are akin to taxation in that one group of people imposes their values on another group without their consent. > Then say you don't believe in society. I’m fine with society, I disagree with you that taxation is necessary for society. > Then why not give away property, as well? There are arguments to be made that private property violates the NAP. Property is a consequence of animalian territorial instincts and human tool-using instincts. If someone can articulate a coherent vision of a property-less society, others are welcome to join them. Mostly the problem is that the people who challenge notions of property rights seem to be motivated by the prospect of obtaining the property of others who would prefer to retain it. In essence, they don’t have a problem with property, but with certain people’s ownership of certain things because they would rather that other people own those same things. > Despite its unanswerable nature, it is still quite enjoyable. Glad you’re enjoying it and likewise.
- Apocryphon 6y ago> You’re asserting you already paid taxes, you don’t get to decide how much tax you pay. Neither do you, let's get this proposal to the legislature. > I concede that laws requiring clothing are akin to taxation in that one group of people imposes their values on another group without their consent. Perhaps the same can be said of all laws. > I disagree with you that taxation is necessary for society. It's voluntaryism, then. The onus is on you to advance an alternative model and light a candle, rather than just calling taxation theft and cursing the darkness. > If someone can articulate a coherent vision of a property-less society, others are welcome to join them. As with taxes. > In essence, they don’t have a problem with property, but with certain people’s ownership of certain things because they would rather that other people own those same things. Not so with Proudhon, the originator of the phrase. His take was that those who owned those properties had no right to the wealth generated by those properties if the labor was undertaken by others. That is, rentier wealth via property was theft. > I now saw that Bruenig's use of Proudhon's phrase "property is theft" made perfect sense from the perspective of an evolutionary theory of morality when "property" is defined as ownership by people who do not work yet become wealthier than the people from whom rent is collected. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/cui-bono/201902/is-property-theft https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/cui-bono/201902/is-p...
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Neither do you, let's get this proposal to the legislature. I’m representing the interests of society to you, the same as the legislature. You’re no more entitled to say “no” to me as either of us is to say “no” to them. > Perhaps the same can be said of all laws. Perhaps this idea of consent and aggression could lead us to a way of making laws that do not impose values on people without their consent. > The onus is on you to advance an alternative model and light a candle, rather than just calling taxation theft and cursing the darkness. I’m identifying the same model as we used when we abolished slavery and marital rape. The model is already here, awaiting critical feedback. So far the only criticism is that people aren’t going to be able to avail themselves of other people’s property. > As with taxes. The problem is that people impose taxes on people who have not consented. That is to say that crime exists, independent of the understanding that it is crime. Right now I’m working to show you that it is in fact crime, so that you can stop enabling the criminals. > Not so with Proudhon, the originator of the phrase. His take was that those who owned those properties had no right to the wealth generated by those properties if the labor was undertaken by others. That is, rentier wealth via property was theft. Unfortunately thats an occasion of Proudhon dictating to others what they may and may not do with their property. In essence, Proudhon wishes to exert property rights over other people’s property by forbidding certain relations. Clearly this is self-contradictory and not a basis upon which to reject rents on capital. > when "property" is defined as ownership by people who do not work yet become wealthier than the people from whom rent is collected. Thats not how property is defined; and its not surprising that people who collect rent on capital often accumulate more than people who sell their labor. Its fine for someone to think thats immoral, they are free to explain why they think it is immoral, and likwewise they are free to educate themselves and realize that restricting rent on capital because of its superior productivity impoverishes society by preventing society from accessing means of superior productivity. Capital collects higher rents than laborers receive as wages: then let laborers own capital and collect their own rents. Quite naturally the market has already commodified the ownership of capital and made it available to the meanest of laborers.