3 ms·
1) The bauxite argument is actually pretty good. Aluminum is one of the most energy intensive ores to refine. Comparing the energy use of Bitcoin to Bauxite ref
by salawat 6y ago
1) The bauxite argument is actually pretty good. Aluminum is one of the most energy intensive ores to refine. Comparing the energy use of Bitcoin to Bauxite refining clearly communicates the level of energy investment going on and negative externality going on. In Aluminum's case, we waste a ton of power, and create rather chemically nasty tailings for a small amount of a substance that we can use to build many things, and importantly, can be reused. In Bitcoin's case, we get the same nasty tailings (waste heat of billions upon billions of hashes) for one single block never to see anyother use ever again, plus the waste products of whatever generated that power. Go ahead and shove ten transactions in it. I could facilitate that with a single piece of ledger paper at far less energy investment.
2 Is spot on.
3 I don't think you give enough credit. One block of a block chain is essentially one page in a giant distributed ledger. Yes, you can make the argument that trying to do the distributed piece with non-blockchain methods is impractical, but guess what, that's how the rest of the world has been doing finance networks all along! It works just fine.
Blockchain/crypto is only a "big deal" because it allows one to trivial set up a payment network/transaction medium that is currently poorly integrated with most financial system's regulators or investigative agencies/controls.
Blockchain, and PoW in particular solves nothing except escaping national government's ability to enact monetary policy, and not even that is a permanant given.
- drdeca 6y agore. 1 I mostly just meant that comparing it not being reversible to hashing being one-way, isn't informative about anything. It may be analogous in other ways, sure. regarding 3, I still don't think the energy use rate would be substantially changed if the target block rate had been somewhat different, so I don't see a reason to connect the energy use to the individual blocks? It seems likely to me that given a fixed issuance schedule, fixed electricity prices, etc. , that probably the energy/block is a result of the energy/time combined with the block/time , rather than the energy/time being a result of energy/block and the block/time . In terms of explanations, I think the energy/time explains energy/block, not the other way around. Reasoning: miners increase their power usage as long as the marginal expected income rate per watt is greater than the cost per watt, and the expected income rate is determined by the price that bitcoin sells at, times the expected coins mined / time. We could break the "coins mined / time" into (coins per block) * (expected number of blocks), but this is I think mainly a technicality, and doesn't particularly factor into any decision making. The power use would, theoretically, increase until no one would profit by increasing how much they spend on power for mining, and so until there is nowhere that the cost of the power of mining more is less than the average rate of income of mining. This ties the power use to the issuance rate (in coins/time,not coins/block), independent of the block rate.