4 ms·
A lot of magic is happening in your second paragraph. Inflation reduces debt and wealth at the same time. Wages at the low end rise with the cost of living. De
by pessimizer 6y ago
A lot of magic is happening in your second paragraph.
Inflation reduces debt and wealth at the same time. Wages at the low end rise with the cost of living. Debt and wealth are denominated nominally. The cost of a new car may go up, but the cost of the car you're currently driving (and haven't paid off) is going down.
Printing money doesn't steal from the poor. Printing money and giving it to the rich steals from the poor. Speculation on assets comes with low inflation, not high inflation, because with low inflation comes low interest rates. The only reason this is bad is because when this speculation crashes the economy, the rich will be saved by direct payments from the government.
Nominal asset appreciation due to a rise in the money supply isn't a rise in value, and the poor aren't competing with the rich for assets. It seems like that in housing because it is an extraordinarily safe asset to drive up in value (when interest rates are low) based of the history of the US government bailing out losses in real estate.
Wealth inequality in America is due to direct payments to the wealthy, and the government consistently stepping in as the silent guarantor of last resort behind every asset bubble. If the government were instead the asset buyer of last resort (not at par like after the mortgage crisis, but at market value), crashes of asset bubbles would be a boon for the public, not a boon for the people who participated most in the bubble.
edit: The problem with the Fed is that it focuses on a goal of holding down inflation while not considering employment in enough detail. The quality of jobs, whether jobs are in bubble (or fragile) industries, rate of rise in wages, and the quit rate are ignored in favor of a simple percentage of unemployed, and administrations even narrow that down to the proportion of people currently collecting unemployment instead of the prime-age (25-54) employment rate as would make sense.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoWhen you own things, i.e. assets, inflation is not really an issue. Of the rich, only lenders are affected by inflation. Also wages have not been rising enough to counter trends.
- lazerpants 6y agoGreat points! I disagree with you on this: Wages at the low end rise with the cost of living. I think this is really an elasticity issue and that we have far too much low skill labor available in the USA (in part because we can import it easily). This means that low end wages have no reason to rise.
- downut 6y agoYeah I agree with this more, but let's ignore the US for a moment and observe that inflation has been steady and low for decades now in most wealthy countries. And then we observe the same is true in the US. So whatever the causes of the (I certainly agree) massive transfer of relative wealth to the 1%, I don't see much evidence that it's US government financial institutions that are to blame. As for fixing the problem, in the simplest, most effective way: highly progressive real income and wealth taxation and whatever Picketty thinks the fraction the inheritance tax should be.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoThe US Government effectively made all currencies fiat by ending gold convertibility of the Bretton Woods agreement. Severing the last remaining link to gold allowed all governments to pursue the same inflationary policy for political gain. So, all governments are doing the same wealth transfer because they are run by humans with similar incentives and the US Government destroyed the leash. The fix isn't to add more bandages over the wound. It is to repair the wound by putting government spending back on a leash.
- notacoward 6y ago> Printing money and giving it to the rich steals from the poor. Exactly. The participants in our tumor-like financial sector collect a risk premium, without actual risk. They have responded accordingly. It's Moral Hazard 101. > consistently stepping in as the silent guarantor of last resort Right again. GP's claims about buying are nonsense, and they're clearly projecting about lack of education. Not counting the exceptional last year, the big issue has not been buying but paying off loans (either their own or bailout beneficiaries') with made-up money. Giving made-up money to regular people is comparatively a lot better, either in itself or as a way to avoid worse kinds of collapses, but still not something to make a habit of.