5 ms·
Even with income remaining stagnant, the prices for goods and services should have been continually going down due to technology and outsourcing. Price optimiza
by mindslight 6y ago
Even with income remaining stagnant, the prices for goods and services should have been continually going down due to technology and outsourcing. Price optimization is the fundamental mechanic of any market! For example, when most manufacturing was moving to China the promise was that it would benefit consumers via lower prices. However the Fed's overt policy is to erase these gains by printing money via low interest rates, and injecting it into the nonproductive financial sector. This made sure that the cost of living continued to march upwards, while all those manufacturing jobs still went away.
- danans 6y ago> Even with income remaining stagnant, the prices for goods and services should have been continually going down due to technology and outsourcing. The price for goods did go down. Everything from food to toys to tools got much cheaper than it was before. However, the price for cornerstone needs that govern access to opportunity - i.e. healthcare, housing, education, physical security - and the percentage of income and average net worth that these consume went up dramatically. Furthermore, these things became ever more correlated with each other, meaning that if you have bad access to one, you are likely to have bad access to the others, and if you have great access to one, you likely have great access to the others. But sure, it's never been cheaper to buy random widget X at a big box store.
- mindslight 6y ago> The price for some cornerstone needs that govern access to opportunity - i.e. healthcare, housing, education First, I wholeheartedly agree that this is the major stakes. I mentioned consumer goods prices because they're immediately tangible. The differences in the others are all too easy to handwave away as improvements. > Everything from food to toys to tools got much cheaper than it was before I don't know about toys, and they seem hard to compare. Food has gone up over the past few decades (groceries that used to cost $2 now cost $3, $3->$4, etc). From one of the first hits for historical milk price (https://www.in2013dollars.com/Milk/price-inflation https://www.in2013dollars.com/Milk/price-inflation): "Between 1997 and 2020: Milk experienced an average inflation rate of 1.73% per year". Note that I'm talking about sticker prices here, not any "but they actually went down with inflation", as the original argument was referencing stationary wages. Tools are being made much more flimsy and disposable - eg real high speed steel has been replaced by inferior foreign steel with gimmicky coatings to "prolong" its poor wear characteristics. If you look at good quality tool brands today, the prices are higher than what tools cost several decades ago. This goes for appliances as well - take a look at "commercial" offerings that are built to be maintained.
- jonnycoder 6y agoYou mention healthcare, housing, education needing governing and those have been "governed" to outrageous prices. Our governing parties have destroyed wealth for the bottom 80% unless those of us with kush tech jobs or anyone who bought a house between 2010 and 2016.
- danans 6y ago> those have been "governed" to outrageous prices. In the US. But in other societies they have been "governed" such that they are more accessible. The kind of governing makes a big difference.
- Aerroon 6y agoMaybe the reason the price of those cornerstone services is that people had more money left over, thus were willing to pay more? This effect seems to be happening with housing and education.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe price for goods is dramatically down. You can buy a 70" flat panel display for $500 today. And there's a lot of pseudo-productivity here that is mostly just rising healthcare spending (without commensurate changes in outcomes) and land value. This sort of makes sense since these sectors have massive capture problems.
- mindslight 6y ago> The price for goods is dramatically down. You can buy a 70" flat panel display for $500 today. Tech itself is the exception that proves the rule. Its progress is so strong that it's becoming less expensive in spite of inflationary policy.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoOh cool, can you eat it? How about 95% of economy: education, houses, food, heating, electricity, fuel? What about industrial goods: Bricks, steel? But oh, you can now live in poverty unable to afford cancer treatment with a TV.
- account42 6y ago> You can buy a 70" flat panel display for $500 today. For $500 + being subjected to ads.