5 ms·
I can take it from your username that you feel that Fuchsia is a threat to your beloved Linux Desktop to the point of having complete denial that the project is
by rvz 6y ago
I can take it from your username that you feel that Fuchsia is a threat to your beloved Linux Desktop to the point of having complete denial that the project is not real. It’s OK to be scared.
But I’m afraid you have to someday accept that some of Big Tech is ‘using’ Linux as a stop gap to either create their own proprietary subsystems around it or a completely new OS compatible with Android for which they pretend ‘they care’ about Linux.
They only care if it’s only for their interests as we can evidently see for Fuchsia Android support and WSL2 GPU hardware acceleration support.
- linuxftw 6y agoJust the opposite. I don't think Fuchsia is much of anything at all, let alone a threat. As far as Big Tech, EEE is a legitimate concern. As far as Google, they've demonstrated countless times they're not to be trusted. If someone does business with them, they are being foolish. Fortunately, outside of search and chrome, they're not very competent, so they're not much of a threat.
- CleverLikeAnOx 6y agoWhat is an EEE? I am having trouble determining the meaning from context and I am having trouble searching for it.
- saghm 6y agoI believe they're referring to the phrase "embrace, extend, extinguish": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace%2C_extend%2C_and_extinguish?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace%2C_extend%2C_and_extin...
- edgyquant 6y agoI’m not sure how you can argue Fuchsia isn’t much of anything at all considering it’s mostly open source, you can see it’s development, and has came a long way since it was announced. You don’t want it to be much of anything but it is very real.
- The_rationalist 6y agoThe amount of human resources dedicated toward improving Linux is order of magnitude higher than the amount of devs working of fuschia. That + the fact that Linux is actively improved since decades. It's quite obvious it's dead on arrival to anybody that allocate a few neurons to the economics question.
- edgyquant 6y agoPeople would have said the same thing about Linux compared to proprietary Unix or even early Windows in 1993-1994. Also Linux has millions of lines of legacy that people are having to maintain and work around while Fuchsia and their team gets to start from scratch with all the knowledge learned. As to your ad hominem in the end there, perhaps you should learn to engage with a level of respect presented to you by your peers, as it is that kind of discourse does little but put on display how your harsh words are little more than a projection. A better type of conservation is expected here.
- The_rationalist 6y agoPeople would have said the same thing about Linux compared to proprietary Unix or even early Windows in 1993-1994. I don't think the comparison apply, linux had a unique value proposition at the time by being welcoming for opensource and free. Fuschia in comparison is redundant the same way BSDs are nowadays. Also Linux has millions of lines of legacy that people are having to maintain and work around This claim lacks concrete evidence. The number of lines of code that are here for legacy reasons is unknown but 1 million since like an exageration. More importantly, most of legacy code is confined (does not affect non legacy code). Of course linux because of backwards compatibility has many suboptimalities and developer productivity could be higher without it, but this argument isn't enough to outweight the order of magnitude difference in human resources (and expertise (hardware makers)) with all the knowledge learned All? I think most of the fuschia devs had no significant role in the Linux kernel codebase, it's not like they had hired Greg kroah-hartman. But essentially, fuschia has not access to useful knowledge that is only encoded as comments in the Linux kernel. And the knowledge about past mistakes is lost unless you spend years reading the linux mailing lists and commit history. Hence the economics point still stand, of course a world without my ad hominem would be better, but such an hypothetical world is precluded for as long as a community like HN is unable to see such striking NIH issues.
- est31 6y agoGoogle has been using Linux since before it was Google, since before it was cool to use Linux on the server. They pioneered it.
- pjmlp 6y agoNice history rewrite going on there.