4 ms·
What bitcoin needs is a killer app. For instance on April 15 the US government shut down all of the online poker sites that were letting people play poker for
by btilly 15y ago
What bitcoin needs is a killer app.
For instance on April 15 the US government shut down all of the online poker sites that were letting people play poker for money in the USA. If you look at the charges, they pretty much all have to do with wire fraud. (The operator of the site can also be charged, but analyses that I have seen suggest that that charge may be harder to make stick in the case of poker.) If someone is willing to not travel to the USA, and is willing to set up a poker site that does transactions in bitcoin, then all of those financial issues go away. (Or are subsumed in the inevitable ones that bitcoin will face, depending on your point of view.)
There are a lot of issues to getting a poker site to work well. (People will let you charge surprisingly high fees if in return you do a lot of policing to eliminate people running bots and who are engaged in various kinds of cheating.) However there are a lot of online poker players suffering serious withdrawal in the USA. The market is there. And the online poker market in the USA until a month and a half ago was well over an order of magnitude larger than the current bitcoin economy.
So there you have a realistic company which could be built, now, using bitcoin. You can generally count me as a bitcoin skeptic, but if someone can get traction with something like this, bitcoin may indeed have a nice future.
- adrianwaj 15y agoPublic companies have their financial records available. I wonder if it'd be possible to work out how much they pay in transaction, chargeback and credit card fees. Startup: "Dear Amazon (or any Fortune 500 company,) you pay $xx in transaction fees annually, install our system to cater to the $xx-sized bitcoin economy, and save about $xx in fees." Even Square: "2.75%. [But] if you enter credit card numbers manually, Square costs 3.5% + 15¢ per transaction." https://squareup.com/pricing https://squareup.com/pricing Can that be beaten with say an android client: https://github.com/bitcoin-labs/bitcoin-mobile-android https://github.com/bitcoin-labs/bitcoin-mobile-android and a printed qr code? Philosophizing more, in the larger scheme of things, perhaps Bitcoin can remove the notion of socialized losses from society which has devastated the economy.
- btilly 15y agoUnfortunately the entire bitcoin economy isn't big enough to represent an interesting line of business for Amazon. Certainly not enough to have to keep track of exchange rates and offer pricing. But I wonder if there is a role for an affiliate that actually makes the purchases and sends them to people. That is they make the purchase on Amazon on their own account, and have it shipped where you want it shipped. They accept bitcoins from you, pay dollars to Amazon, and trade back bitcoins for money on the exchanges. Their profit margin comes because they are an Amazon affiliate, and put their affiliate code on all of their purchases, so that they get the affiliate fee. Something like this would not really need much cooperation from Amazon. Heck, you could just have a browser plugin that recognizes Amazon, and gives the user the option to make a bitcoin purchase instead of using your credit card.
- adrianwaj 15y agoThis is a good idea, but the key is in making the browsing and selection of items as transparent as possible. It's another layer. Some type of price comparison engine would work really well: browse on Amazon, buy on xxx, pay with Bitcoin. add: the other short-term use case for bitcoin and say Amazon is giving refunds in bitcoin given the reach of bitcoins is low right now. Refunds are a push to market, as opposed to a pull. Typical cc chargebacks can be expensive too, and so refunding in bitcoin avoids it.
- nowarninglabel 15y agoThe poker market was driven by ease of putting funds into an account. That is to say, the casual person looking for entertainment and willing to lose money drove the sites. As anyone who made a living off the sites will tell you, things started going south after the first bill was passed making it illegal for banks to do the transfers. Now, if all you had were bitcoin transactions to deposit, then you would end up with a pool made up mostly of sharks. Until a dead-simple and ubiquitous solution is available for making bitcoin transactions, I express much doubt that a bitcoin poker operator would appear and thrive.
- btilly 15y agoThere is no question that the online poker market was much tougher after the US laws were passed. But even after the laws were passed, after casual players were limited because payments to/from the poker sites had to wind through payment processors to get around the restrictions, the poker sites were still making something like $1.4 billion/year in revenue from the US market. Dealing with bitcoin doesn't seem to me to be much more complicated than the network of payment processors people used to use to get money to/from Full Tilt. Sure, the potential market is going to be smaller. But even if it is an order of magnitude smaller, $140 million/year in revenue is nothing to sneeze at.