6 ms·

The nonsensical Dyson canister vacuums are the ones that amaze me. Dyson competes based on premium coolness, so just consider at its primary coolness competito

The nonsensical Dyson canister vacuums are the ones that amaze me. Dyson competes based on premium coolness, so just consider at its primary coolness competitor: Miele. Across the board, Miele canisters are lighter, more powerful, cleaner, and much more effective than their Dyson cost equivalents. They have a far lower failure rate and last much longer. Bagless canisters have so many negatives compared to bagged vacuums, it's a wonder they're still being promoted.

kevstev 6y ago
Do you have any more info to back this? I am honestly curious- I bought a Dyson Animal about 12 years ago now, and its still going strong, and is the best vacuum I have ever used. Not having to keep bags around is nice too. Our usecase is relatively light- we have area rugs mostly, but its still head and shoulders above the previous vacuum we had, and any of the ones my parents had growing up.
- BHSPitMonkey 6y ago
  The common reason I see for vacuum enthusiasts bashing on bagless units is air hygiene; as soon as you take out the canister, you're releasing a bunch of the vacuumed matter back into the air and breathing it into your lungs. This can probably be mitigated by carefully emptying the contents outdoors, but a lot of apartment-dwellers can't really do that.
  - ooboe 6y ago
    Yes, emptying bagless units is a disgusting process. Even outdoors, it's not pleasant.
  - SeanLuke 6y ago
    Bagless is also an excellent way to shorten the life of the motor and fan subsystem.
- damontal 6y ago
  how do you dump your cannister? i empty mine after every use and it always releases dust into the air. bagged seems much better as it just keeps the dust inside.
  - kevstev 6y ago
    I just do it over the garbage can, the cannister is removable and just flips open up top. I guess some dust escapes, but its mostly contained. The cannister being clear, its also very transparent as to when its full and needs to be emptied. Its been awhile, but I remember this being problematic on my previous units- the "indicator" mechanisms didn't work very well, so you eventually ignored them, until suction was noticeably deteriorated, then you finally changed out the bag and it felt like you had a new vacuum.
ooboe 6y ago
I have to agree with this. I have a Miele bagged canister and my partner has a Dyson bagless canister. The Miele is superior (often significantly) in every measure, including price. Granted I do have to buy bags but it'll take decades of bags to negate the price difference.

kevstev 6y ago

Do you have any more info to back this? I am honestly curious- I bought a Dyson Animal about 12 years ago now, and its still going strong, and is the best vacuum I have ever used. Not having to keep bags around is nice too. Our usecase is relatively light- we have area rugs mostly, but its still head and shoulders above the previous vacuum we had, and any of the ones my parents had growing up.

BHSPitMonkey 6y ago
The common reason I see for vacuum enthusiasts bashing on bagless units is air hygiene; as soon as you take out the canister, you're releasing a bunch of the vacuumed matter back into the air and breathing it into your lungs. This can probably be mitigated by carefully emptying the contents outdoors, but a lot of apartment-dwellers can't really do that.
- ooboe 6y ago
  Yes, emptying bagless units is a disgusting process. Even outdoors, it's not pleasant.
- SeanLuke 6y ago
  Bagless is also an excellent way to shorten the life of the motor and fan subsystem.
damontal 6y ago
how do you dump your cannister? i empty mine after every use and it always releases dust into the air. bagged seems much better as it just keeps the dust inside.
- kevstev 6y ago
  I just do it over the garbage can, the cannister is removable and just flips open up top. I guess some dust escapes, but its mostly contained. The cannister being clear, its also very transparent as to when its full and needs to be emptied. Its been awhile, but I remember this being problematic on my previous units- the "indicator" mechanisms didn't work very well, so you eventually ignored them, until suction was noticeably deteriorated, then you finally changed out the bag and it felt like you had a new vacuum.

ooboe 6y ago

I have to agree with this. I have a Miele bagged canister and my partner has a Dyson bagless canister. The Miele is superior (often significantly) in every measure, including price. Granted I do have to buy bags but it'll take decades of bags to negate the price difference.