3 ms·
I think the logic is reasonable but the response is too strong. A doctor driving around vaccinating whoever he can find at their house is clearly not how you w
by zamadatix 6y ago
I think the logic is reasonable but the response is too strong.
A doctor driving around vaccinating whoever he can find at their house is clearly not how you want to distribute the vaccine in early December, it's not going to get to the most at risk people as soon as it can and any issues that arise are a huge liability problem unless he can fix it with what's in his car.
At the same time not having any plan or procedure of how to use the remaining vaccines or how to decide if the last batch should be opened is only going to create bad scenarios so you can't blame the person following the instructions for having a bad outcome if that's all you gave.
What's really messed up about this (and probably why the response had to be overly strong) is it was made into a news story about how he maliciously took the vaccines for his own use when really it's a story about how the vaccine rollout procedure wasn't good enough and left him in a shitty situation.
- Grustaf 6y agoPresumably the fact that you're not allowed to drive around an give away the remaining doses like this is calculated to make doctors be more careful about when the open batches. After all, vaccination is not an emergency treatment, so it should be easy to avoid the situation in the article. If the rules were changed to allow for this, you can easily imagine that some less ethical doctors would decide to break seals just before closing the clinic, and then vaccinating their family and friends because "it would be a shame to waste it".
- valarauko 6y ago> A doctor driving around vaccinating whoever he can find at their house is clearly not how you want to distribute the vaccine in early December, it's not going to get to the most at risk people as soon as it can and any issues that arise are a huge liability problem unless he can fix it with what's in his car. This is entirely reasonable, but it comes down to - what to do when faced with this situation? True, it's not going to get to the most at risk people, but what's the alternative?
- crispyambulance 6y ago> it's a story about how the vaccine rollout procedure wasn't good enough and left him in a shitty situation. Nothing done at this scale and speed is going to be perfect. There's always going to be problems. I wish that people like the administrator who fired him and the prosecutor who charged him would have used better judgement. This logic is not "reasonable" given how extreme the outcome is. It takes a lot of steadfast effort to go after someone like that knowing that it's going to be a PR nightmare (except perhaps on HN, where people will argue that it was "logical"). This story seems completely insane to me.
- zamadatix 6y agoNothing is ever perfect doesn't mean whatever response to the situation is okay. Like I said, the response was a bit too strong though.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> A doctor driving around vaccinating whoever he can find at their house is clearly not how you want to distribute the vaccine in early December, it's not going to get to the most at risk people as soon as it can and any issues that arise are a huge liability problem unless he can fix it with what's in his car. No, but it is absolutely what I would want any doctor to do if the alternative was throwing away COVID vaccine doses. Like, I literally think this should be the standard policy. Do absolutely everything within your power to never waste a dose, ever. If that means getting in your car and driving around town, you need to go do that, no question.
- zamadatix 6y agoNot wasting a dose doesn't necessarily imply driving around and sticking the first person that says yes at the spot they happen to be though. e.g. standard policy could be to not open the next batch of 10 until certain conditions are met, call people on tomorrows list until you get 9 that can show up in the next 6 hours, or any other planned action. These are superior options because: 1) everything still happens in a controlled setting 2) fair distribution is still ensured 3) you're not making unrealistic demands of a person who has to give out doses every night to then drive around town without a plan Obviously none of these are the fault of the guy taking the fall though, it's process work that needed to be done by the people that fired him and charged him. That's why the response is a bit strong, he wasn't the one that created the problem and he seemed to try to talk to anyone he could reach about a better solution. At the same time that doesn't mean this was a good outcome or what should happen. I.e. if 9 doses have to go to waste to safely improve the distribution process as a whole it's probably better than telling doctors to independently try to take it on the road unplanned.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI don't necessarily disagree with any of that, but I think it's a delicate balance. If two people cancel one morning because, I don't know, a storm knocked down a bunch of trees in their area, and you've tried your future appointments list, do you now have to phone the other six patients and ask them to reschedule too? Or do you have a nurse go out and find two people off the street who want a COVID vaccine, and bring them to the office asap? Remember that the vaccines have a limited shelf-life even in the freezer, and that the ultimate goal is to get shots into arms as quickly as possible. You can optimize for speed, or you can optimize for equity. I don't think we should throw out equity, but we should lean towards speed.