4 ms·
> Late last month, a judge dismissed the charge as groundless, after which the local district attorney vowed to present the matter to a grand jury Considering
by vlovich123 6y ago
> Late last month, a judge dismissed the charge as groundless, after which the local district attorney vowed to present the matter to a grand jury
Considering that grand juries would indict a ham sandwhich, this seems like the prosecutor is reaching just to prolong the process and pain this doctor is going through. Even assuming the best case argument for the prosecutor that he did “steal it”, he vaccinated 10 people with expiring vials. More realistically, given that it was only 10 expiring vials that went to eligible patients, the doctor should be commended for driving around and finding people who needed it. Who the fuck cares if it was primarily his own community or one of the vials went to his sick wife?
This just looks like the DA was caught being overly aggressive (perhaps even racist given the comments in the article) and is just trying to save face. Dollars to donuts the case is thrown away and I hope the doctor countersues for malicious prosecution, although more realistically he’ll take a plea to avoid going to trial and end this nightmare.
- geophile 6y agoWhile this case is quite bizarre, giving doses to random people rather than having the vaccine go bad is pretty common, and makes sense. Except for one thing: If I am the lucky recipient of this vaccine, ahead of schedule (since I am under 75 and have no comorbidities), then what about the second dose? Do I have to get lucky a second time, the right amount of time after my first dose? (My understanding is that there have been no studies of delayed second doses.) Or am I given priority because I've had the first dose?
- vlovich123 6y agoI don't think anyone really has any formal policies or if there are they probably vary drastically based on your municipality (the US healthcare system is a mess). The data does indicate that even 1 dose gives you some immunity, just not the 95%. That's why there's been a big push from some scientific corners to just get needles in arms to inoculate as many people as people with some immunity & worry about making sure optimal 2nd shot later (broad herd immunity with less efficacy vs smaller more effective herd immunity).
- analyte123 6y agoThat the extra doses were administered in a different county (Fort Bend) probably exacerbated the response, plus the very plausible bias of the local officials in Humble. The Harris DA Kim Ogg is a Democrat (tellingly not mentioned in this article) who is painted by opponents as a “Soros DA” who is soft on crime.
- smnrchrds 6y ago> Considering that grand juries would indict a ham sandwhich I am not American. When I hear about grand juries in American media, it is usually when they refuse to indict in a case of brutality or killing by police officers, even though there is clear evidence about the incident. It seems that grand juries never indict anyone, not the other way around. Where do grand juries' biases lie in reality?
- vlovich123 6y agoGrand juries give you the result the prosecutor wants. The ham sandwich tounge-in-cheek joke is that usually the prosecutor wants to indict, otherwise why would they bother going to a grand jury. For police officer involved brutality/killings, it's usually the opposite. The prosecutor doesn't want to bring the case (since their office needs to work with cops to prosecute civilians) but there's political pressure from the community, so the prosecutor brings the case to the grand jury & scuttles the indictment. A huge improvement is probably actually to just remove the grand jury. That way prosecutors can't hide behind the "well I wanted to indict but the grand jury didn't let me" while removing the guilty by association act of "well a jury clearly thought the indictment had merit".
- MertsA 6y agoThe grand jury's bias is the bias of the prosecutor trying to convince them on a one sided case. The prosecutor is the one explaining the law to them and trying to get them to agree with their view. When there's no defense to provide a rebuttal it's a lot easier to convince a jury.