4 ms·
As much as Bitcoin proponents talk about the protocol, the majority of Bitcoin buyers couldn’t care less about anything related to the blockchain. They just wan
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
As much as Bitcoin proponents talk about the protocol, the majority of Bitcoin buyers couldn’t care less about anything related to the blockchain. They just want to buy some BTC in Coinbase and see the number go up and down (preferably up). They don’t want to hold their coins or be their own bank.
Meanwhile, the amount of misinformation around inflation and fiat money is getting ridiculous. Bitcoin proponents talk about Bitcoin as if the only alternative investment was to keep all of your savings in cash under your mattress. Too many people think that inflation means everything loses value except Bitcoin, all while ignoring the fact that inflation literally means the value of traditional assets and commodities goes up in dollar terms.
- Ancapistani 6y ago> inflation literally means the value of traditional assets and commodities goes up. No, the value of assets doesn’t change - the price goes up.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoValue goes up in dollar terms, which is the same as price going up.
- Ancapistani 6y agoThis makes no sense. Price in dollars (or any other currency) is a proxy for value, but not the same thing. A loaf of bread has the same value whether it costs $1, $5, or $0.05.
- axiosgunnar 6y agoA bread that costs 10 USD would take a worker earning 10USD/hour an hour to earn. Surely a bread that requires the worker to work only 5 minutes has a lower value than a bread that requires 2h or labor?
- Ancapistani 6y agoOf course, but neither inflation nor deflation occur in a vacuum. Barring a major increase in productivity, a single commodity doesn’t fall 95% in price without wages falling at the same time.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThat’s the point. If your house is worth $100,000 one year and the equivalent house costs $105,000 next year, inflation is 5% in the cost of housing. The absolute value is the same (assuming all things equal). The price in dollar terms is higher. The point is that Bitcoin advocates try to imply that Bitcoin is the only place to put cash that is safe from inflation. Meanwhile, investing in nearly any asset or stock will hedge against inflation. I regret using phrasing that invited pedantic debates about terminology. Only distracts from the point.
- Ancapistani 6y agoFor what it’s worth, while I am a proponent of Bitcoin (and other cryptocurrencies), I’m not really interested in starting a flame war on HN :) I also don’t take any issue with your assertion that the vast majority of “investors” in Bitcoin aren’t interested with the mechanics of the protocol or in the economic possibilities - they’re interested in the price going up, and the majority of them don’t dive any deeper than to see that it has continued to do so. > The point is that Bitcoin advocates try to imply that Bitcoin is the only place to put cash that is safe from inflation. Meanwhile, investing in nearly any asset or stock will hedge against inflation. This strikes me as a bit of a straw man, though I’m very much aware that there are definitely some people like this. They’re disproportionately loud to be sure. Neither inflation nor deflation are a good thing for the economy overall. In the US, the purpose of the Federal Reserve system is to limit and - to the extent that it is possible - control both. Consider for the sake of this conversation that there are three classes of people: “savers”, who keep a substantial part of their wealth in liquid assets (like USD), “borrowers”, who owe debts denominated in USD, and “lenders”, who are owed debts denominated in USD. Inflation hurts savers. The “cash in their mattress” is worth less, and they are therefore encouraged to participate in the overall economy. It hurts lenders, who see the future value of the debts owed to them decrease due to the decrease in failure of the USD. It helps borrowers, because the value of their debts are decreased in comparison to the value of their work. Deflation helps savers and lenders, and hurts borrowers. The big problem here - and from this point forward I’m speaking of my inferences, not from facts - is that both inflation and deflation harm economic mobility. In an inflationary environment, lenders don’t want to loan money because they money they get back in the future will be worth less. To offset that, interest rates and lending requirements rise, which cuts the poor off from access to capital. In a deflationary environment, money is expected to be worth more in the future, so borderline investments have to produce a larger expected return in order to “beat” deflation. Periods of stability are therefore what we should seek, in order to maximize access to capital for those most in need of it (the poor). Bitcoin is mildly inflationary now, but is more than offset by adoption/speculation. At some point in the future, when mining rewards taper into nothing and mining is incentivized only by transaction fees, Bitcoin will become mildly (but consistently) deflationary. This assumes adoption and speculation is fully saturated by then. I don’t know if Bitcoin itself will ever get there, but I’m reasonably confident that some cryptocurrency will. From a larger economic perspective, that’s what I want to see from the cryptocurrency world. I could speak all day about the anti-state/pro-individual-freedom aspects, but from a purely economic perspective, I strongly prefer the rapid feedback of fixed-supply (but infinitely divisible) currencies (in the form of boom/bust cycles).
- olah_1 6y ago>They don’t want to hold their coins or be their own bank. If the UX is better around this, I think they would. It's only in the last 15 years that people really stopped carrying large amounts of cash around. And from what I understand, people still use a lot of cash in places outside of the US. But for example, there are bitcoin wallets (ZenGo) and nodes (Umbrel) that provide protections around footguns now and make for a much more straightforward user experience. If Bitcoin sluggishness and fees got sorted out, I think people would like this. But I suspect that the powers that be do not want these issues fixed. Bitcoin is not a threat when it is "just another commodity".
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> If the UX is better around this, I think they would. The UX isn’t the point. Why would anyone want to use a protocol with $8 transaction fees and no recourse for vendors stealing their money? We all have credit cards in our pockets that might even pay us cash back to use them, and if a vendor fails to deliver I can get the charges reversed with a phone call. It’s not a conspiracy by “the powers that be” to keep Bitcoin sluggish and unusable. It’s Bitcoiners themselves who reject proposals to increase block size (see the BCH drama) Bitcoin holders don’t want people spending or using coins. They only want people to do things that increase price: Buying and hoarding.
- lostmsu 6y agoFrom what I understand, credit cards don't really protect people in that way in most countries. Only on the ones where fraud is already rare.
- sprash 6y ago> If Bitcoin sluggishness and fees got sorted out, I think people would like this. They got sorted out via Lightning Network. Instantanious transactions with very low fees are possible. However UX around Lightning is lacking and regular transmission fees are still too low to incentivize the majority of people to take a look at it.
- davemp 6y ago> Meanwhile, the amount of misinformation around inflation and fiat money is getting ridiculous. Bitcoin proponents talk about Bitcoin as if the only alternative investment was to keep all of your savings in cash under your mattress. Too many people think that inflation means everything loses value except Bitcoin, all while ignoring the fact that inflation literally means the value of traditional assets and commodities goes up in dollar terms. Exactly. Afaik the entire point of inflation modern monetary strategy is to force people to take the money out of their mattresses and participate in the economy. Bitcoin is basically just a better mattress. The most compelling arguments for bitcoin's usefulness is as a store of value.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIt’s another myth that inflation is purely the result of monetary policy or government intervention. Government intervention does tweak the trajectory of inflation or deflation, but it’s not the only input to the system or even necessarily the main input. It’s a lever. Bitcoin proponents like to focus on things like M0 money supply while ignoring the fact that value isn’t created by the government printing money. It’s created by people producing valuable things and businesses. Likewise, storing money under your mattress isn’t a useful thing to do, digital or otherwise. In the real world, investors don’t stuff cash under mattresses, they invest it in things that produce value. Bitcoin incentivizes the opposite of that: It discourages investing in anything that creates value and instead encourages people to not spend or use the currency at all. The Bitcoin narrative only works as long as there is a net influx of people looking to stuff digital money under their mattress instead of deploying it to something useful.
- sprash 6y ago> Likewise, storing money under your mattress isn’t a useful thing to do, digital or otherwise. This is just not true. It is a tool to let prices properly represent the risk of future price changes. People who save money supply a net positive value to the economy while withholding demand to sometimes in future at the risk that they will afford less for the money. This lowers the price for people that need that immediate demand. Fiat money and central banks completely destroy that kind of price discovery obviously.
- cryptica 6y agoThe only misinformation about inflation is the one that government agencies are peddling. Bitcoin is valuable because it holds the collective attention of a huge number of people - This makes it an ideal asset to soak up the surplus fiat which is constantly being injected into the economy which would otherwise have been soaked up by some mega-corporation. People can collectively keep taking out more loans from banks and dump it on Bitcoin. It will always go up that way so long as the next generation starts doing the same thing. This is not a new thing. That's basically what was happening with corporate stocks over the past few decades; it's a continuation of the same fiat pyramid scheme except that now the focus point of the scheme is crypto instead of stocks. The fact that crypto is honest about the reality of the scheme which it benefits from is why it will succeed. They just capitalize on distrust and contempt for the monetary system and it cannot really crash because the really smart investors know exactly what they're buying.
- me_me_me 6y ago> As much as Stock Market proponents talk about the investing in the companies, the majority of Stock buyers couldn’t care less about anything related to the Stock Market/supporting companies growth. They just want to buy some Stock in Stock Market Exchange and see the number go up and down (preferably up). They don’t want to hold their stock paper cert or be their own store value.