4 ms·
> We spent too much time thinking that aging is something inevitable, unaddressable and thus not worth studying too much. We have so many more important and ur
by lm28469 6y ago
> We spent too much time thinking that aging is something inevitable, unaddressable and thus not worth studying too much.
We have so many more important and urgent problems to take care of. Not even technical ones, but societal ones. Let's not even talk about the fact that any meaningful advances in the field would benefit the top 0.0001% of the world and would never trickle down to the rest of us.
- conjectures 6y agoNot totally true. There's a whole suite of social problems stemming from having a large elderly population in poor health. Insufficient pensions, how to pay for healthcare, staffing in caring professions. If 'studying the science of ageing' translates into 'keep older people healthier for longer', then those problems may be mitigated somewhat. Also, scientific advances can make treaments cheaper. E.g. modifying bacteria to produce insulin is cheaper than extracting it from pigs.
- nicoburns 6y agoTrue, but an ageing cure is also likely to cause a lot of problem around overpopulation.
- inglor_cz 6y agoMy worst expectation is actually people in lifetime offices (e.g. judges) sticking there much longer than today. A SCOTUS formed entirely of centenarians - what could go wrong?
- esperent 6y agoLifetime appointments are already a dumb idea. The obvious solution is term limits of ten years or so.
- lm28469 6y ago> 'keep older people healthier for longer', then those problems may be mitigated somewhat. Do you want to work until your very last breath ? Because this is where we're heading. This is exactly the kind of problem I'm concerned about when people start talking about "curing age". https://www.liveinhomecare.com/elderly-in-japan-are-wearing-exoskeletons-to-keep-working-past-retirement-age/information/ https://www.liveinhomecare.com/elderly-in-japan-are-wearing-... > Also, scientific advances can make treaments cheaper. E.g. modifying bacteria to produce insulin is cheaper than extracting it from pigs. Yes, but again, scientific advances without societal advances = doom. Look at the price of insulin in the US, it's the living proof health is much more complex than "X = Y, hence Z will be cheaper and everyone will live happily ever after" https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/1431F/production/_105991728_optimised-insulin_1-nc.png https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/1431F/production...
- melling 6y agoI wouldn’t mind working until the end if it was on something interesting. How about we all end up as scientists who work on discovery?
- lm28469 6y agoLet's keep it real. With automation we should already work less and retire earlier, which was promised by 70s/80s politicians, it's not the case, at all. Working hours and retirement age are going up virtually everywhere, making us live longer won't change any of that in a good way
- inglor_cz 6y agoThe vast majority of healthcare spending and disease burden is made worse by aging. In cases of diseases like cancer, several orders of magnitude worse. If we could stretch people's healthspan to 90 or even 110, the resulting society would be much happier and could spend more money on the other important urgent problems. > Let's not even talk about the fact that any meaningful advances in the field would benefit the top 0.0001% of the world and would never trickle down to the rest of us. You are literally writing this on a device that 50 years ago would cost millions. It somehow trickled down to you and me. I fail to see why something that would be almost universally demanded could stay outside of common reach forever. Consider that just the cost of DNA sequencing, arguably an interesting and important biotech, went down six orders of magnitude within 20 years. It is literally 1000000x cheaper than in the mid-90s.
- lm28469 6y ago> I fail to see why something that would be almost universally demanded could stay outside of common reach forever. You fail to see how the elite would keep advances letting them live longer/healthier for them ? You probably don't have a very fruitful imagination then. What about a 250 years old Jeff Bezos ? 250 years old Putin ? The only limit to these people is literally ageing and being mortal Do you think people who aren't able to live decently and afford food at every meal in 2021's America would be offered a "longer and healthier life" pill ? Do you think people dying in 2021's America of diabetes because they can't afford insulin would be offered a "longer and healthier life" pill ? > You are literally writing this on a device that 50 years ago would cost millions. It somehow trickled down to you and me. If you fail to see the moral difference between typing on a computer and "curing ageing"... I don't know what to say to be honest
- inglor_cz 6y agoI have enough imagination to be a professional writer. You still do not convince me. Life extension is desired by too many people to be kept in billionaire's circle forever, or even for too long. As soon as the details of any procedure leak out, you can bet that someone in Brazil or India will set up a clinic to run the treatments for reasonable price. > What about a 250 years old Jeff Bezos ? 250 years old Putin ? The only limit to these people is literally ageing and being mortal I can imagine that very well and frankly, this seems to me the only downside to the whole process. Yes, this is troubling. > Do you think people who aren't able to live decently and afford food at every meal in 2021's America would be offered a "longer and healthier life" pill ? Do you think people dying in 2021's America of diabetes because they can't afford insulin would be offered a "longer and healthier life" pill ? Not everywhere is America, in fact, 95 per cent of the world is not America. Single payer systems might do just the thing you consider absurd. How Americans respond to that is up to them. Also, looking at Americans in general, their general problem is not lack of food, but excess thereof. Most American health problems are caused by overeating. > If you fail to see the moral difference between typing on a computer and "curing ageing"... This is Hacker news, not Preacher news, and I haven't addressed the morality of the intervention at all. You are shifting the goalposts, it is fairly clear that I addressed your "trickle down" argument in my rebuttal. Technologies that are expensive in the beginning tend to become cheaper over time and "trickle down" to the less wealthy precisely in the way that you denied. Look around the very room you are sitting in, most things there would be way less affordable to your grandfather.
- esperent 6y ago> We have so many more important and urgent problems to take care of. Fortunately, with 7.8 billion people alive today, we have some capacity for multitasking.
- leereeves 6y agoAnd with 7.8 billion people alive today, if someone does cure aging, we'll have a new problem: who gets to live forever? It can't be everyone, unless no more children are born.
- melling 6y agoProbably have to leave the planet. the solar system is pretty big. The galaxy is incredibly large, the universe...
- ben_w 6y agoThat isn’t as helpful as it might seem. If each person has an average of 2.4 offspring, and reproduction still requires two people, and the generation gap is an average of (say) 50 years, and if the average person has a mass of 70 kg; then after 27,000 years the biomass of humanity exceeds the mass of the universe, and after about 18,000 years you need FTL to reach that mass. That said, this remains true even if we don’t solve ageing. Exponentials grow faster than polynomials like “volume”.
- melling 6y agoIt’s already at 1.71 in the United States.
- inglor_cz 6y agoThere might be a huge gap between finding out "how to live to be 120" and "how to live forever". So far, we can only learn about human aging from people who are at most like 117 years old, because there is no one alive now who would be older than that. So, there is a chance of doing the first steps and finding out that there are other aging-related problems beyond the age of 110-120. Some of them may prove to be unsurmountable. That would probably mean "just" a much longer generation span. People used to have their first kids at 17, in fact they still do in places like Niger or Chad. But in the rich part of the world, length of a generation is now around 30. I can see it being 60 if people live to be 120.
- dingoegret 6y agoThat was needlessly incredulous. Keeping ourselves alive is definitely our most important priority.