4 ms·
There aren’t nearly as many things as you might think that have unbounded failure modes like that. At the mechanical and electrical engineering level you have f
by kortilla 6y ago
There aren’t nearly as many things as you might think that have unbounded failure modes like that. At the mechanical and electrical engineering level you have fuses, breakers, pressure relief valves, etc that make all of these failure scenarios just “the machine shut down”.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAnd then the machine shuts down and you have to fly there anyway to fix it. This sounds like turning "an attacker may destroy power generation infrastructure and maybe kill people" problem into "an attacker may repeatedly DoS the power generation systems, likely damage it, and still probably cause loss of life by second-order effects". Doesn't feel all that different. To use an analogy: it's like saying that attackers accessing the company servers remotely aren't a problem, because the best they can do is to keep them in a reboot loop...
- daniellarusso 6y agoYour analogy made me chuckle.
- rhodozelia 6y agothe western grid has 258,000 MW of generation. renewables go up and down like yo-yos, power plants go on-line and offline all the time and a large and always increasing fraction of it is unscheduled and uncontrolled. Of course it depends on the size and location of the power plant, but there are many more small plants that can go offline without causing any significant effect to the grid than there are large ones, and the large ones probably have the resources to be manned 24/7 either on site or from a remote site over a dedicated and thereby secure fibre link. One take-away from this thread is that not all infrastructure is 'critical'.
- kortilla 6y agoCrappy analogy. There is a huge difference between being able to shut down some power generation that is a drop in the bucket on a grid vs overloading some equipment and killing people. One is life and death, another is lost revenue for a power plant.