2 ms·
Getting a warning 24 hours "early" that you might be infected is still useful. Perhaps in that 24 hours you were going to make a grocery trip and potentially i
by kelnos 6y ago
Getting a warning 24 hours "early" that you might be infected is still useful. Perhaps in that 24 hours you were going to make a grocery trip and potentially infect a bunch of people, but now you won't because you got that early warning.
Claiming that something is useless because it doesn't cover all cases seems a little weird to me. It's a tool in the toolbox that can reduce the possibility of spread in a limited set of cases.
Using lateral flow tests requires everyone to purchase a big supply of them and use one every day. This watch-based warning just requires you to have an Apple watch and run a new app on it (which I hope they'll make publicly available), and it'll just let you know without any extra action taken. Your average Apple watch user is probably pretty likely to take the simple step of installing a new app; they're not going to buy a supply of lateral flow tests (which they probably don't even know much about or haven't even heard of) and test themselves every day.
- rimliu 6y agoYup. I was lucky the person whom I contracted COVID from informed me the moment they got the test result. I was on my way to work, just about to leave the car. Turned around and went back home. Developed symptoms the same evening. It was a lucky coincidence that was Monday so I've stayed home the whole weekend and had no contacts for a couple of days I was likely already infectious. (The person I got it from only developed symptoms two days after our contact). People who do contact tracking only on Wednesday. So my contact informing me saved three days worth of my potential contacts from getting COVID from me.
- prower 6y agoHope you're fine now. Can I ask how did you contract it? What I mean is: did you and the other person follow the usual distancing rules (mask + 1 meter apart + no touching)? Only if you're willing to share of course :)
- stuartbman 6y agoI can only comment on the study in front of me, and not the use cases that 'might have been'. In this case, they tested in a healthcare setting as there is a presumed higher risk of catching covid amongst participants. Would the same false positive rate be true in the community, where transmission is much lower? We don't know because that wasn't the experiment. The study authors claim that this is useful in the healthcare setting- I'm saying that it's useless because there are better tools in the arsenal (lateral flow tests), and watches are an infection risk.