3 ms·
> I like this topic especially with the theory that wars are never fought over resources, they are always fought over status. Couldn't it be that the wars are
by tshaddox 6y ago
> I like this topic especially with the theory that wars are never fought over resources, they are always fought over status.
Couldn't it be that the wars are actually fought over resources, but are sold to the public of all involved countries (including the historians and philosophers) as being about status?
- whatshisface 6y agoCould it be that wars are fought for no good reason, but that they are always justified in terms of something that sounds attractive or valuable to whoever they're being justified to at the moment? (This is in the context of modern, useless wars, not pre-1950s conquests which were obviously about stealing as much as possible.)
- unhijo 6y agoIt could be that wars are fought for many reasons and we cannot abstract a general rule that is valid for all or even most wars.
- willcipriano 6y agoI yearn for the heady days back when politicians used to attempt to justify wars, now the media just pretends we aren't in what seven? of them currently.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWhy do you assume no good reasons when there were obvious economic and political incentives for the attacking parties in said "modern, useless wars" conflicts? Note it doesn't have to be one obvious incentive. A government has many parties with differing incentives. But sometimes, a lot of those parties stand to simultaneously benefit from a war. Basically, Hanlon's handgun[0], not Hanlon's razor. -- [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21691282 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21691282
- octodog 6y agoIf you think that historians, philosophers, international relations scholars and the general public have 0 critical thinking skills, you could reach that conclusion. Realistically though, this is not the case. Although many wars are built on lies that may be believable at the outset, the public eventually tends to understand and the mood shifts. We have seen this in Vietnam and Iraq more recently.
- tehchromic 6y agoI'd counter and say that natural resources are one, probably the most significant symbol of status with which wars and their outcome are negotiated. But the war outcome itself, rather than diplomatic or market solutions, is specifically the result of evaluation of relative symbolic status rather than underlying resource needs. Examples: WW I was the result of royal jealousy over who had better navy boats. WW II was fought when a whole cultural identity perceived itself to have loss of status after the fall of Austrian Empire. Vietnam and the cold wars had to do with the ongoing symbolic struggle for status between different factions of aristocratic, government, or corporate interests, etc. And all the mercenary forces enabling the conflict were interested in those resources as status symbols rather than any underlying need for or lack of resources. Same with global water supply. If the question is, how does everyone get enough water, then it's a practical problem which war only hurts. But if the question is, who controls access to what water, then it's a matter of symbolic status and war is inevitable. This is why the argument is tough tho, because natural resources are a primary status symbol, so we say "resource war". But I think it's important to talk about the distinction because the difference is life and death.