3 ms·
Yes, this could work, and has definitely been done, sometimes, against other public CAs. We found convincing evidence of this during work at one of my previous
by tialaramex 6y ago
Yes, this could work, and has definitely been done, sometimes, against other public CAs. We found convincing evidence of this during work at one of my previous employers.
But what tempers my concern over that finding is that we found this by looking at cases where there's clearly a DNS takeover - and actually it was rare to do certificate issuance. In most cases it seems if you can MitM say, an Arab's country's army headquarters group mail servers, you can just offer no encryption or serve a self-signed certificate and the users will accept that. So while the Ten Blessed Methods are, as expected, not enough in the face of a resourceful adversary (in this case perhaps the Mossad, NSA or similar) they're also a padlock on a fence with a huge gaping hole in it anyway, our first attention should be on fixing the hole in the fence.