2 ms·
Nuclear is its own complicated issue. If newer plants can replace that last 10-20% of power generation -- and can do so safely, and can do so within budget cons
by jfengel 6y ago
Nuclear is its own complicated issue. If newer plants can replace that last 10-20% of power generation -- and can do so safely, and can do so within budget constraints, and can do so on a 5-year plan that turns into a 15 year project, and puts away sufficient money for its eventual decommissioning -- then that's fantastic.
But even without that, it's a smooth curve. The existing fossil fuel plants can cover base load, and will last long enough that they can be shut down when they're no longer needed. By the time we need to consider replacing them, technology will have shifted, and we can't really know whether we'll want to replace them with new fossil fuel plants, Nth generation nuclear, batteries, superconducting grids, or fusion. The timeline for shutting down all of the exiting fossil capacity is the same as the practical-fusion time scale.
The point is that there's no reason for the public to worry about base load. The planners have to, of course. But it's a problem with a solution, rather than a leap into the unknown.
Nuclear is a nice add-on, if it succeeds, and allows us to shut down fossil fuels faster, but it's not necessary and not the long pole in the tent of reducing carbon. Renewables are built much faster and will reduce much more carbon before the first new nuclear plant is completed.
- mschaef 6y agoSo you're saying we shouldn't worry about it - the planners will take care of it all while we wait for large scale investments in renewable power and soon to be invented load smoothing and battery technologies? I hope you're right, but I'm not as sanguine as all that.