5 ms·
I don't think it's as bad as it might seem. I'd rather have this on the frontpage than lolcats or accident pictures. In fact, I think some of the people who u
by pg 18y ago
I don't think it's as bad as it might seem. I'd rather have this
on the frontpage than lolcats or accident pictures. In fact, I
think some of the people who upvote or submit things like this do
it as a way of keeping News.YC good. They don't want the site to
degenerate into an intellectual monoculture. That doesn't mean
they necessarily agree with everything it says.
Back in the 1960s, the Communists used to get so many votes in
French elections that some people in the US worried the country
would align with Russia. But as Laurence Wylie pointed out in
Village in the Vaucluse (great book btw), most of the voters
didn't actually agree with the Communists' policies. They were
just voting for them because they worried that the dominant party
was getting too powerful. Really they were voting for diversity.
- abiek 18y agoWhat falls in the deemed YC monoculture and what lies outside of it?
- dfranke 18y agoI think trying to resist the monoculture is a mistake. Your stated aim for the constituency of the news.yc community is "the 10,000 best hackers and nobody else". If you achieved that aim, you'd have a monoculture. It would be a slightly different monoculture than the current one and less in your image, but a monoculture nonetheless. If it's even possible to move away from monoculture without moving toward Digg, I don't think it's worth the risk of trying.
- nostrademons 18y agoIt could be that in order to get the 10,000 best hackers, he has to resist the monoculture. Good hackers usually get that way because they're curious and like to learn new things. It gets boring when the same few dozen people submit the same thousand articles.
- dfranke 18y agoI'm talking about a monoculture of values, not of abilities or interests. "Curious and like to learn new things" is one aspect of the monoculture that I'm referring to. It's a relatively uncommon attribute.
- demandred 18y agoI do wonder how many upvotes this got because people wanted to see a good discussion/ rebuttal.
- run4yourlives 18y agoThat's certainly why I up voted.
- paul 18y agoI'd rather see LOLCATs. I haven't quite figured out how to articulate what's wrong with this kind of thing, but it's somewhat similar to Fox news -- they're not simply useless, they're corrosive. I'm still trying to think of a better explanation. Disagreement is fine and good, but this kind of thing is something else. The 37signals posts do a good job of presenting an alternate perspective, but in a way that is generally positive and helpful.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI'd like to see you explain yourself better, Paul. How can free speech corrode anything? Is it like when you tell a kid there's no Santa Claus, then you've hurt his innocence with your cynicism? It sounds like you've got your thumb on a very specific feeling, and I'd be interested to hear about it, but heck if I can figure out where you're going. I'm a big free speech guy, and I love a good kick in the butt from time to time, so I liked it for that reason. WE always want to judge our position against our critics, right? If not we're just living in a echo-room. But that's just me.
- paul 18y agoI'm in favor of free speech as a legal concept, but that doesn't mean that I want to listen to and promote everything. There is some content that will actually make you dumber. Most tv news is in this category, actually. I'll try to come up with a better explanation though.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoIt's appreciated. I support the legal concept because it makes sense both for politics and me personally. Something about how do you know you're wrong unless you listen to those you disagree with? After all, can't be right all of the time. [Insert clever J.S. Mill comment here]
- pg 18y agoFree speech is not a type of speech. It's a policy about speech. So the question reduces to "How can speech be corrosive?" Corrosive is not a very precise word, but I can guess what Paul means: he means when people are deliberately intellectually dishonest, as for example Fox News seems to be. When someone (a) deliberately misrepresents what an opponent is saying (b) as if he were attacking something that is a hot button for the audience, and then (c) replies with rousing platitudes.
- asdflkj 18y agoThe result might be the opposite of what those well-intentioned people want. If the alternative view is obviously lame and impotent, it only reinforces the mainstream. This is a well-known trick in politics. When Michael Moore argued for gun control in Bowling for Columbine, he let the other side be represented--by Charlton Heston, a particularly dull and inarticulate man. You will probably agree that there are far more compelling objections to the ethos of Hacker News than this article.