Not a fan of this sort of argument logic. Y is like X to a lesser degree, and no it's not as good as Z, but does that mean Y is bad? We're only talking about X

Not a fan of this sort of argument logic. Y is like X to a lesser degree, and no it's not as good as Z, but does that mean Y is bad? We're only talking about X and no it's not a good store of value given the other options.