5 ms·
If it was likely the other person has a gun, I would think twice before doing something. It makes more sense to me to be more wary when I assume that the person
by johnisgood 6y ago
If it was likely the other person has a gun, I would think twice before doing something. It makes more sense to me to be more wary when I assume that the person I may be thinking of robbing has a gun on them, vs. knowing it is extremely unlikely that the person is not going to have a gun on them.
Are you sure the problem is guns? What makes you so sure? I am genuinely interested, because Serbia is known for having lots of guns, too, but firearm-related death rate is low, vs. Honduras, which has much less guns per 100 inhabitants and extremely high firearm-related death rate that is homicide.
In any case, here is the table:
| Country | Homicide | Guns per 100 inhabitants |
| US | 4.46 | 120.5 |
| Serbia | 0.72 | 37.82 |
| Honduras | 28.65 | 9.9-11.24 |
Taken from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-r....
What do you think explains this? Curious to explore.
- 23iofj 6y ago"Lies, damned lies, and statistics" as they say. Serbia and Honduras are anomalies. Within the entire data set there's a significant positive correlation between "Guns per 100 inhabitants" and Homicide rate.
- johnisgood 6y agoAre they really anomalies? | Country | Homicide | Guns per 100 inhabitants | | US | 4.46 | 120.5 | | Serbia | 0.72 | 37.82 | | Honduras | 28.65 | 9.9-11.24 | | | | | | Cyprus | 0.50 | 36.4 | | Canada | 0.72 | 34.70 | | Finland | 0.20 | 32.4 | | ... | | | | | | | | Jamaica | 38.20 | 5.8 | | Eswatini | 37.16 | 8.1 | | Brazil | 23.93 | 8.6 | | ... | | | Are they anomalies, too, or what do you mean by anomaly? I do not want to edit the table anymore, but someone also mentioned Switzerland, indeed, extremely low rate of firearm-related homicide (0.13) with high rate of gun ownership (27.6-41.2). There are many more.
- 23iofj 6y agoWhy cherry-pick? Just running the regression analysis on the entire dataset.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aurelius12 6y agoFrom the Harvard Injury Control Research Center: "Where there are more guns there is more homicide." "Across high-income nations more guns = more homicide." "Across states, more guns = more homicide." "More guns = more homicides of police." https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-and-death/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-an...
- filoleg 6y agoI would be careful with this information, because correlation != causation, as well as the fact that cause and effect might be reversed. And to be fair to the HICRC, they don't claim the causation. Could it be that states with high homicide rates lead to people in those states buying more guns to feel more protected at home (and not the other way around)? For a real life example, I live in Seattle, and we had a giant spike in the first-time firearm ownership numbers last year. It was driven by a lot of people who previously had zero interest in owning guns who suddenly became more concerned about their safety due to all the violence happening adjacent to protests, as well as due to the local District Attorney refusing to prosecute a lot of violent criminals with many repeated offenses and letting them out (to clarify: when I say "violent", I am not talking about protests, I am talking about people with multiple battery and assault charges, robbery, gang violence, rape, etc.). So in the Seattle scenario, it was indeed an increased rate of crime and homicides that caused a spike in firearm ownership, not the other way around. And what about Switzerland, with their extremely high rate of gun ownership but low rate of homicides? I don't have an answer to these questions, but it makes me feel like it is a bit less simplistic than just "higher rates of gun ownership in high-income nations create higher homicide rates".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pas 6y agoThe problem is, even if people buy guns to feel safer, it doesn't help. (It simply makes crime more violent. Guns don't deter crime.) Politics is broken if the DA is not effectively enforcing laws. Guns can't fix it. (Just as every surveillance thread on HN has comments about "technology can't really fix this, it's a politics problem", guns are very much just technology when it comes to socioeconomics/politics of crime.) Switzerland has very high regulation. Not just for guns, for everything. And a very effective (almost direct) democracy. And an almost universal very-very-very high standard of living. (Yet their suicide rate is pretty high! Used to be higher than the US' - https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/suicide-death-rates?tab=chart&country=USA~CHE https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/suicide-death-rates?tab=c... ) Gun ownership there is more of a cultural heritage, and very much not a safety device.