5 ms·
Your argument sounds very similar to the "let's abolish timezones" argument so let me post this again: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish Changi
by remram 6y ago
Your argument sounds very similar to the "let's abolish timezones" argument so let me post this again: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish
Changing your schedule works for you and your boss, but does not let people in other parts of the world know when they can reach you. Officially shifting something is necessary, and then you might as well have timezones.
- SamBam 6y agoI find it insane that there are otherwise-smart people in the world that want to abolish time zones. For example, this NY Times article. [1] In includes the most bizarre history: > A century and a half ago, time zones didn’t exist. They were a consequence of the invention of railroads. ... and goes on to describe that it's suddenly so confusing and laughable that when it was 7:00 in New York, it would now be 8:00 in Chicago and 5:00 in San Francisco. But what on Earth did the writer think the time was in San Francisco before there were time zones? Before there were time zones, everyone synchronized to local noon. The result was much more fine-grained "time zones." What time zones did was to actually flatten those difference, leading to fewer time zones, because now suddenly the time in Maine was the same as the time in Michigan, despite being at completely different longitudes. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/06/opinion/sunday/time-to-dump-time-zones.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/06/opinion/sunday/time-to-du...
- amalcon 6y agoFor some evidence of this, consider that sundials have existed since about 1500 BCE. The existence of such a device easily disproves the notion that the "current time" was ever the same globally. Even mechanical clocks would obviously need to be set such that they would agree with a sundial, or the reading of the mechanical clock would be useless in a world where others are using sundials.
- WorldMaker 6y agoSome extended timezone databases even have tried to collect historic city timezones from before the railroads, most often to the nearest 15 minute offset, but sometimes even minute specific offsets. It's interesting to explore those. On that Michigan versus Maine thing, as someone in a city that historically was -0045 from its current timezone, I feel it interesting to point out that DST is closer to local noon than "Standard Time" in the city, versus that cities that define the other edge of the time zone and have local noon closer to Standard Time noon. (Our hour-wide time zones make the question of DST versus Standard Time much more complex than just picking one or the other, when talking about abolishing DST or standardizing only on DST.)
- inglor_cz 6y ago> The result was much more fine-grained "time zones." That is true, but it did not bother anyone, because fast long-distance communication either did not exist or was very limited (e.g. smoke signals) and syncing of clocks wasn't necessary in everyday activities; for a medieval person, the idea that clocks in Vienna and Prague MUST be synchronized would be as strange as for us the idea that everyone in the same city should have their breakfast at the same time. It just did not serve any obvious purpose. There are only two exceptions I can think of. a) people doing astrological horoscopes for someone who was born in a different place (a big thing among some nobility and royalty) would probably be bothered a bit by the time difference, b) armies trying to converge on the same target at the same moment.
- Piskvorrr 6y ago...didn't bother anyone until railroads entered the equation: astrology did take the difference into account, armies didn't move quickly enough to notice it: just keep adjusting to local time every day or so (even on horseback, any tactic is far more dependent on physical limits, so you're coordinating on the order of minutes, not milliseconds). For railroads, even at 40 kph, an east-west train would be subject to time shift (not in the Lorentz sense, it would just keep switching "timezones" too quickly). Given that the primary security element was "this train is supposed to pass this set of switches between this and that time and wait there, else it risks colliding with that other train running opposite," both accurate timekeeping and geographically wider timezones were needed (as in "the railroad will use its own time, Prague's lunchtimes notwithstanding").
- SamBam 6y ago> That is true, but it did not bother anyone Time zones were implemented in the United States in 1883. This was well after the use of telegraphs had become widespread, and after the invention of the telephone. While the telephone would not by able to make coast-to-coast calls for another few decades, the idea of communicating with people in other cities was already becoming commonplace. My point was that the "messy" system the Times article describes would already have seemed reasonable to everyone, who already knew that people in other cities would have different working hours. What annoyed people was the "flattening" of the time zones, making it such that all the cities had to now synchronize their clocks to railway time, no matter what their local noon was. But this is the opposite of the point that the "one global time" advocate thinks he's making.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoPeople in other parts of the world can reach me at any time by email, during the work hours of the email server.
- remram 6y agoIf that is how everyone at your company feel, you don't need a schedule at all (or even a clock).
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoIt's just the best way of contact, if people know anything else, they can use it, but even in one building it's impossible to know who is on vacation, who is fired, who is on lunch, who is on a smoking break, who is off on an errand, who left a little earlier, who is busy at a meeting, who is just busy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- remram 6y agoGood for you. Obviously the rest of the world uses phones and video calls, which is why this thread exists. You should give them a try sometime!
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoAs I said even in the same building it's impossible to video call, because people aren't killing time all day long.
- remram 6y agoObviously some people use video calls successfully. I don't know what else to say...
- scbrg 6y agoIt's a while since I read that article, so I may forget some details, but I do recall that I found it pretty stupid. It somehow assumes that it would be harder to find out what the regular working hours are in a country are than it is to find out what time it is in that country, possibly in addition to what the regular working hours are. If Google today tells me, "It's now 5PM in Singapore", with no time zones it could just as easily tell me "Regular working hours in Singapore are 12-20". OK, so that's two numbers to remember rather than one, but come on. Thing is, what a certain time means varies wildly country to country, and from person to person anyway. My Swedish friends eat dinner at 17:30. My friends in southern Europe eat dinner at ~22:00. Unless I know who I'm calling, and their regular hours I have no idea if it's OK to give them a call at, say, 07:00 or 22:00. So I need extra information about them anyway - and that information wouldn't be harder to package in a world lacking time zones. In fact, it would be easier, since it'd contain only one element (times available) rather than two (times available plus timezone).
- blueblisters 6y agoFine, let's have separate working hours for every region. Now, how do you determine what longitudes share working hours?
- scbrg 6y agoI don't see how the question is relevant. I'm generally not communicating with collections of longitudes. I'm communicating with people. They can tell me what their working hours are. The point is that they already have to, since working hours are, in fact, not identical between neither regions nor people within a region. That said, I'm not saying that we should abolish time zones. I'm just saying that that article is stupid and fighting a straw man.
- thedufer 6y agoHave you ever said "let's hang out Tuesday afternoon"? Abolishing time zones makes that a useless phrase for a large slice of the world - consider the area where the date changes in the middle of the afternoon. And which days are the weekdays? The ones where it's Monday-Friday in the morning (with Tuesday-Saturday afternoons) or where it's Monday-Friday in the afternoon (with Sunday-Thursday mornings)? This doesn't really solve the problems with times, it just moves them from times to dates.
- recursive 6y agoI read it last time. I still think it's a weak argument, and that abolishing time zones has benefits that outweigh its costs.