6 ms·
And as Bitcoins get more scarce and get adopted by more and more banks and companies as reserves, the value of mining rewards is only going to continue rising,
by EGreg 6y ago
And as Bitcoins get more scarce and get adopted by more and more banks and companies as reserves, the value of mining rewards is only going to continue rising, until Bitcoin will consume more electricity than the rest of the world combined. (Around the time it is worth $1.2 Million a coin.)
Change my mind.
Bitcoin rewards miners in Bitcoin, which is the ultimate deflationary “store of value”, and has the world mindshare as such. Even if a network arose that was better in every technological way, if it was a “sidechain” to Bitcoin, then BTC would just be locked up as people migrated to that network, so “unstaked” Bitcoins on the original network would become even more scarce, thus mining rewards would go up even more. Bitcoin would be a store of value / collectible just like gold, except its supply would always be shrinking and mining rewards rising.
PS: Consider I am right. How would governments even begin to stop it, if this use of electricity would net the provider more profit than powering a home?
- foepys 6y agoHow does it scale when a block can only contain about 3,000 transactions?
- EGreg 6y agoIt doesn’t. Proof of work is the wrong architecture. We started https://intercoin.org https://intercoin.org to solve the problem. Others started other projects. But it doesn’t do anything to demand for Bitcoin because nearly all of it is for Bitcoin as a store of value and deflationary investment that will go up, up, up. Yes it was called a cash system in the original whitepaper - but somewhere around 2013 the narrative shifted from Peer to Peer Cash to Store of Value. And it has stuck. This is a copout but it works! Bitcoin has all the features to be a great store of value and nothing more... Bitcoin is now a store of value and you dont need it to scale if once in a while someone wants to move $50K from their savings account to their checking account to actually use. They can also have Nexo, BitPay etc as debit cards backed by BTC reserves. So why do you need Bitcoin to be a good currency too?
- charcircuit 6y agoIt doesn't. Bitcoins themselves will eventually be migrated of the bitcoin network so that they can be used with the rest of the defi ecosystem.
- EGreg 6y agoIt won’t matter because the remaining “unstaked” bitcoins will be worth even more so all mining rewards will be worth even more - get it?
- abledon 6y agoSpaceX could probably help usher in a new age where we have mining nodes in space, big solar arrays (100 or so) powering a small 100-GPU cluster or ASIC cluster....
- mkl 6y agoIt would be far cheaper and easier to do this on Earth. There's plenty of sunny desert, heat dissipation is much easier, broken things can be repaired, etc.
- abledon 6y agoya but heat would dissipate into space and not contribute to global warming?
- EGreg 6y agoIn capitalism, most players in the economy do not make decisions based on this
- mkl 6y agoDissipating heat into space is very challenging (vacuum makes a great insulator). On Earth the solar energy is arriving here already, so converting it to electricity and using it to perform calculations won't directly contribute to global warming.
- ulzeraj 6y agoCombined world governments going after miners is the best thing could happen to Bitcoin. Difficulty would drop allowing people to mine from general purpose computers again, which is a huge incentive. Then things will scale up again. The toothpaste is out of the tube. Nothing can be done.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> Change my mind. Well, personally, I'm still convinced Bitcoin is going to crash at some point. It doesn't work well as an actual currency because transfer times/fees are too high. I don't know if that will happen in one year or 20 years though.
- EGreg 6y agoBut that’s not it use anymore. Yes it was called a Peer to Peer cash system but it failed at that. Somewhere around 2013 the narrative shifted to it being a store of value. And that has stuck. It is the ultimate store of value. You think people will let governments destroy their store of value so that the world can use electricity for other uses? Let’s explore that shall we. One third of the world farmland is desertified, today. Insects are dwindling and other species are experiencing an extinction on unprecedented scales today. Fossil fuels are being extracted at rates that are not stopping anytime soon. We never switched to electric cars yet. We couldn’t even switch to biodegradeable plastic and instead polluted all the bodies of water on earth. You really think humanity will be able to stop this runaway economic effect designed to get bigger and bigger until it consumes the world’s use of electricity? Why is this any different? PS: with exponential growth, by the time you note the electric use is one quarter of the world, it’s too late.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> But that’s not it use anymore. Yes it was called a Peer to Peer cash system but it failed at that. Somewhere around 2013 the narrative shifted to it being a store of value. And that has stuck. Yep, a "store of value" created out of thin air, just like tulip petals! I don't expect it to last myself.
- EGreg 6y agoAnd why not? What backs gold? It is more durable than tulip petals The more people buy Bitcoin as reserves the more it IS reserves. It is a network effect, man. That’s how languages and cultures work too.
- peteretep 6y ago> Bitcoin, which is the ultimate deflationary “store of value” Inflating the supply of bitcoins is a value in a config file + buy-in from miners, who are the ones with all the capital to benefit from inflating the supply. Unsure why you think the miners are just going to go home when it’s all mined and sell off their expensive equipment at firesale prices when they can collaborate to increase the amount of Bitcoin?
- EGreg 6y agoMiners benefit from deflating the supply. If there were only 50,000 bitcoins and the rest was locked up in sidechains, then every mining reward would be worth far more. They would like more sidechains to Bitcoin. (Somewhere Joel Spolsky is yelling: “Commoditize your complements!”)
- noch 6y ago> Inflating the supply of bitcoins is a value in a config file + buy-in from miners Please learn about how consensus rules work. "The consensus rules are the specific set of rules that all Bitcoin full nodes will unfailingly enforce when considering the validity of a block and its transactions. For example, the Bitcoin consensus rules require that blocks only create a certain number of bitcoins. If a block creates more bitcoins than is allowed, all full nodes will reject this block, even if every other node and miner in the world accepts it." [0] Because users must consent to run full-node software with a particular version of consensus rules, miners cannot simply change the rules. This was shown in 2017 with Segwit2x and UASF(User Activated Soft Fork).[1] In other words, "If securing Bitcoin requires consensus on what Bitcoin is, and Bitcoin is a database of values assigned to keys, and Bitcoin has a protocol for reassignment of keys, then securing Bitcoin can only be done by … your node!" [2] > [Miners] are the ones with all the capital to benefit from inflating the supply. You're not thinking clearly about supply and demand. Because bitcoin has a fixed supply (21M), its price movement is a pure result of demand. If someone were to start inflating the supply, the price would drop, devaluing the coins for everyone including those doing the inflation because created coins are instantly visible to everyone. (Incidentally, this also creates a disincentive for Satoshi to ever move his "lost" 1M BTC. Moving them would instantly make them appear available to the market/network and be a massively inflationary event. Prices would immediately drop in response to this perceived increase in supply.) > Unsure why you think the miners are just going to go home when it’s all mined and sell off their expensive equipment at firesale prices when they can collaborate to increase the amount of Bitcoin? Miners work for the block reward (which halves every four years) but also for transaction fees (an auction in which you bid for blockspace for your transactions). The question for the distant future is: will transaction fees be sufficient to ensure the security of the network? [0]: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Consensus https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Consensus [1]: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/bitcoin-independence-day-how-this-watershed-day-defines-community-consensus https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/bitcoin-independence-da... [2]: https://medium.com/bitcoinerrorlog/who-secures-bitcoin-95b19bbcda3c https://medium.com/bitcoinerrorlog/who-secures-bitcoin-95b19...
- PeterisP 6y ago"the value of mining rewards is only going to continue rising" is not consistent with the design of Bitcoin. There is a finite number of BTC left to mine (15% of the eventual total?) and the amount of BTC received from mining is designed to halve every four years, so in the long run BTC processing will have to be funded more by transaction costs and less so by mining. "How would governments even begin to stop it" - I don't thing that governments will choose to try it, but if they did want to do so, a simple ban on all sale and barter in BTC would work. It wouldn't stop all trade, but making exits difficult would reduce investment interest sufficiently to get a huge decrease in price, especially since current price seems mostly defined by "store of value" i.e. investment arguments, not based on usefulness for transactions. If many investors can't exit, then it ceases to be a good store of value for them, reducing the demand. For example, Tesla $1.5B purchase was a big pressure upwards; but if it's known that no such purchases are ever coming again, and that Tesla's holding is now worthless (unlike some small-scale drug trader, a US company like Tesla can't really use a black market or person-to-person transactions to exhange it for anything), that would kill the short-term price; this would mean that the mining costs much more than their electricity costs (there is an inherent lag in block difficulty adjustments that's potentially huge in case of a rapid slowdown in mining rate) which may cause many miners to cease mining.