4 ms·
I still remember, all the way back in the Nixon era, my dad grumbling: "Most people just want to be ruled by a king." But I think a symbolic monarchy could ser
by analog31 6y ago
I still remember, all the way back in the Nixon era, my dad grumbling: "Most people just want to be ruled by a king."
But I think a symbolic monarchy could serve a useful purpose by giving those people a ceremonial role in return for promising that they will never attempt to actually govern.
Edit: Deleted first sentence per comment below.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWhat does a monarchy have to do with Jan 6? And how does a ceremonial role impact operations or anyone’s life?
- woodruffw 6y agoI'm not going to try to answer the first, but as to the second question: Britain is exactly the example of this. The Queen (or King) is a symbol of national pride and unity. The British people regularly give her an approval rating of over 90%[1], which is astounding for someone who lives off of the public welfare. I happen to agree with the GP that monarchies should be abolished outright, but it is clear that people feel strongly and build identities around ceremonial roles. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality_and_image_of_Elizabeth_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality_and_image_of_Eliza...
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> someone who lives off of the public welfare It isn't welfare if the person works in an official capacity.
- zepto 6y agoGiven that the article claims she had reviewed more than 1000 laws, it’s hardly fair to call it public welfare.
- woodruffw 6y agoMy reading of the article is that it's supposed to be a reveal of something that most of the British public aren't aware of. Given that they aren't aware of it, it's probably safe to say that it doesn't factor into their estimation of her. In other words, she might as well have not reviewed more than 1000 laws, as far as the factors that go into her approval are concerned.
- zepto 6y agoSure - but the point is she does a lot of work.
- mbreese 6y agoI think the symbolism of the state (in this case embodied by the monarch, but it doesn’t have to be a monarch) as a separate entity from the “government” is very appealing. In this way, you can have certain offices that work for the state and others that work for the government. The state/crown side would be apolitical whereas the government side would be politically appointed. But it would be helpful to have the two sides explicitly separated to have minimal interference. I have no idea if this is how the British monarchy works in practice, rather just the view from my side of the pond. In the US, we have the concept of career vs political positions in government agencies, but in practice, there is a great risk of interference between the sides.