2 ms·
Not all monarchies are hereditary. The Holy See is, while technically theocratic and thus not a monarchy, an example of what elective monarchy would look like.
by jcranmer 6y ago
Not all monarchies are hereditary. The Holy See is, while technically theocratic and thus not a monarchy, an example of what elective monarchy would look like. Perhaps the weirdest example is Andorra, which makes Emmanuel Macron (the President of France) an elected, er, diarch (he's only Co-Prince) by the virtue of being elected by people who have no ties to the country.
To answer the question of how hereditary monarchies get started: in the modern era (post-Napoleonic Wars, generally), new monarchies carved out of existing states either elevated important local elites (the Sharif of Mecca's sons got kingdoms in Iraq and Transjordan out of WWI, with the Sharif himself proclaiming a kingdom in Hejaz), or they shopped around important royal families in Europe to import a monarch (e.g., a lot of German princes found themselves kings of newly-created Balkan states in the 19th century). The right of conquest to attain a royal title is pretty well-accepted, although conquest usually comes from someone who already has a heritable noble title anyways (cf. the Dukes of Normandy becoming Kings of England).
The older noble lineages in Europe (and elsewhere, but I really don't know much about the history of nobility outside of Europe) appear to largely arise from a Germanic system of elected chiefdoms where one family gradually gains enough power to force the elections to choose them, eventually (though not always, cf. the Holy Roman Empire) dispensing with the pretense of election. Given the paucity of written sources, we obviously have very little record of how these influential families actually came to gain their influence, and the sources that we do have tend to be edited to suggest divine providence as the originator of their rule.