7 ms·
In chess there's an idiom for this. "Long think, wrong think" because it's a quite common phenomenon that very good players will ruin positions by rather than p
by Barrin92 6y ago
In chess there's an idiom for this. "Long think, wrong think" because it's a quite common phenomenon that very good players will ruin positions by rather than playing with their good instinct, over-analyzing a position, there's a related situation of the hardest games to win being already won positions because there's so many ways to win that people will on occasion start doing something really stupid akin to the example of having too much choice in the article.
I think a nice collective analogue to this is Alfred Whitehead's observation that 'civilisation advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking of them'. Progress is being made by holistically integrating knowledge in a way that makes it sort of ambient.
It also reminds me of a slightly snarky article why all the people in the rationalist cult never seem to actually be successful at anything other than rationalism. It's precisely because consciously thinking is easy, it's the integration of knowledge into the whole is what's difficult but actually necessary.
- 2112 6y ago“In the words of the ancients, one should make his decisions within the space of seven breaths. Lord Takandobu said, “If discrimination is long, it will spoil.” Lord Naoshige said, “When matters are done leisurely, seven out of ten will turn out badly. A warrior is a person who does things quickly. When your mind is going hither and thither, discrimination will never be brought to a conclusion. With an intense, fresh and undelaying spirit, one will make his judgments within the space of seven breaths. It is a matter of being determined and having the spirit to break right through to the other side.” Initially from ; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hagakure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hagakure But taken from a site [0] I just found in the process that apparently has nothing to do with the OS and informs us that ; "Ubuntu is a concept that we have in our Bantu languages at home. Ubuntu is the essence of being a person. It means that we are people through other people. We cannot be fully human alone. We are made for interdependence, we are made for family. When you have ubuntu, you embrace others. You are generous, compassionate. If the world had more ubuntu, we would not have war. We would not have this huge gap between the rich and the poor. You are rich so that you can make up what is lacking for others. You are powerful so that you can help the weak, just as a mother or father helps their children. This is God's dream.” - Ubuntu, as explained by Bishop Desmond Tutu [0] https://ubuntutheory.blogspot.com/2008/08/7-breaths.html https://ubuntutheory.blogspot.com/2008/08/7-breaths.html
- codetrotter 6y agoUbuntu the operating system takes its name from the concept that you talk about here. That is also why the logo of Ubuntu the operating system is three people holding hands, which kind of blew my mind when I first heard about it. Prior to that I thought the logo was just some lines and circles in a pretty pattern with no specific meaning.
- quickthrower2 6y agoUbuntu is the distribution. GNU is the operating system. Linux is the kernel.
- codetrotter 6y agoA GNU/Linux distro can be referred to as an operating system. Not sure if you are memeing or not, but in conversation going into specifics about the GNU/Linux, or GNU plus Linux as you might like to call it, distinction, is not relevant here. And in fact, I would say that saying that “GNU is the operating system” is even incorrect. GNU plus Linux is the operating system. Neither part by itself is a complete operating system. So, the distro is the operating system. Ubuntu is the operating system.
- wongarsu 6y ago"GNU is the operating system" only makes sense when speaking about GNU Hurd or Linux-libre. The kernel is part of the OS, so in the case of ubuntu GNU can't be the operating system. But if Linux is the kernel, and GNU is part of the operating system because the OS is more than the kernel, then why is the OS GNU/Linux and not Systemd/GNU/Linux? And on Ubuntu you install most stuff with apt instead of using gcc, and use most software with X.org instead of bash, so the OS is really apt/X.org/systemd/GNU/Linux. Of course that name quickly becomes silly, it's much more practical to just call the OS Ubuntu (as that expresses a specific package selection that includes GNU, linux, and a large number of equally indispensable parts, as well as their update cadence and methodology)
- 6y ago
- rcoveson 6y agoKeep in mind the expertise required to build that intuition, though. The average person who merely knows how to play Chess should probably think before they move, or else blunder away the whole game by putting their queen on a square threatened by a knight they didn't look at. That said, most people are probably "experts"--in the sense that their intuitions can often outdo their conscious trains of thought--in more than a few things. I'll bet that drivers in their 40's make better decisions with instinct than conscious thought. The same probably goes for middle aged home cooks. But teenagers should go over their driving lessons in their heads, and stick to the recipes.
- imagica 6y agoLearning something new requires a lot of concentration and deliberate thinking and practice. When I learned chess I remember the friend I was playing with becoming a bit bored waiting for my moves but with time it became more automatic and only certain moves would make me think more and when not being able to evaluate or choose between alternative I'd go to gut feeling, possibly distilled from thousands and thousands of chess games played. At some point the tipping point leaned too much towards gut feeling and after some bluffing I decided to take a break from chess and moved on to something else. I think I got bored and my brain would jump to shortcuts. Then I discovered musical instruments
- ngc248 6y agoTrue, with enough experience you know when to move fast and when to dither, a kinda game sense.
- cocoa19 6y ago"civilisation advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking of them" Similar concept is applied to programming, we call that concept abstraction.
- salawat 6y agoThat's completely different, and not wholely beneficial either. The piper's due is merely deferred until the last of the original abstractor's guard dies, then everyome who relied on it has to rederive the fundamentals, or stagnate.
- WJW 6y agoThis is wholly untrue. It is very possible to maintain a subset of the population to guard the knowledge of the fundamentals so that the rest never has to worry about the abstraction failing in any real sense. For example, humanity has abstracted away the vagaries of internal combustion engines for car propulsion through a standardized interface and the "last of the original abstractor's guard" for combustion engines died several decades ago.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> civilisation advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking of them Interesting take. My first thought was that this relates to societal trust, a cornerstone of civilization. I can buy food from someone I've never met, and keep myself fed, 'without thinking'. Related: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liars_and_Outliers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liars_and_Outliers * https://www.schneier.com/books/liars-and-outliers/ https://www.schneier.com/books/liars-and-outliers/
- Robotbeat 6y agoThat’s an interesting point. Makes me think of the loops that are required to be jumped through to enable a trustless digital currency like Bitcoin. The entire network, with transactions of about 1kB in size, can do at most 7 transactions per second (3-4 orders of magnitude lower than Visanet, which itself is lower throughput than all the world’s physical cash transactions could theoretically do if everyone bought one or two things a day on average). That’s the same data throughput of a mid-1990s modem, but with power consumption of about 10GW to secure the transactions. Pure trustlessness indeed has a massive computational and mental overhead. Some compromise (like the Lightning network, or even a central trusted banking institution) is essential to get anything done. (Even with Bitcoin, you’re trusting open source software, often an actual intermediary like Coinbase, etc... Try to do it without any crypto libraries whatsoever—writing it really from scratch—and it is an enormous project. How many people teach themselves Finite Field theory before doing Bitcoin because they take the trustlessness seriously?)
- WJW 6y agoThere are quite a few places in bitcoin where trust is required. For example, the software is developed by a relatively small group of core devs and 99%+ of bitcoin users will never read that code (and its dependencies) to see if it contains backdoors. We just have to trust the devs to "do it right" and not get compromised by either greed or blackmailed by external parties. If you presuppose a sophisticated enough attacker, the distribution methods could be MITMed so that the distributed binaries are not what is in the source code. The various miner pools could be compromised as well so that they run different software than the "main" bitcoin branch (but with a similar interface). If you accept that crypto exchanges are essential to bring down the barrier to entry, they need to be trusted as well. For any transaction also involving an exchange of goods or services not on the blockchain, you need to either trust the counterparty to actually fulfill their obligations, you have to involve a (trusted) clearing house or you have to trust the legal system to enforce the contract. Tbh, trustlessness in payment systems is pretty much unachievable at scale. And if you are going to need trusted parties anyway, why have a blockchain in the first place? You can get a much better solution with a centralized database managed by the trusted party.
- hertzrat 6y agoI’m working on a video game right now and I’m having this problem with the story and dialogue. In the past my game design was in the realm of tabletop rpgs, so you come up with the idea, add some details, and then you run it right away. You see the player responses in person, face to face, learn whether you did well or not, and then move on to do even better the next time. It works great. In a video game, there can be months between conception and a player experiencing it, and you won’t be there to see most of them react, so you can second guess every single detail hundreds of times until it’s hard to judge things clearly. I’ve never been into heavy up front design before, but it might actually be helpful for this specific problem - ie, to just write it and then trust it later on
- threatofrain 6y agoBut most people are noticeably stronger with longer time than with shorter time. You need merely play a long time control and not give yourself the benefit of using that time and see whether your rating drops.
- jasondigitized 6y agoIn Dominoes the term is “study long study wrong”
- avindroth 6y agoOr in Korea we call this “long time wrong move (장고 뒤에 악수)”
- purplecats 6y ago> all the people in the rationalist cult never seem to actually be successful at anything other than rationalism do you have a link? would love to read this, and it probably applies to me :)
- personlurking 6y ago>Alfred Whitehead's observation that 'civilisation advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking of them'. Reminds me a bit of a quote I heard recently: "Tradition is a set of solutions for which we have forgotten the problems. Throw away the solution and you get the problem back."
- mam2 6y agoIt's actually a very interesting line of thought, but people lose their mind as soon as you start digging in.
- esperent 6y agoIt might apply to some traditions. However, for others, this is more accurate: "Tradition is a set of solutions for problems that don't exist anymore". An example of the latter that immediately springs to mind is circumcision.
- hansbo 6y agoWhat problem did it solve before?
- discreteevent 6y agoHygiene
- janeroe 6y agoThat's the modern justification. Surgery "in the middle of a desert in the insanitary conditions and no water" for "hygiene" is a very counter-intuitive practice, don't you think?
- Layke1123 6y agoWow, I never thought about this. It would be interesting to do a study to see what lead to more disease, child circumcision during that time, or hygiene complications later in life, not to mention and STDs that might be spread more easily. Fascinating new way to look at it.
- animal531 6y agoI was thinking about this the other day. When I was a kid I'd think 1-12 moves ahead, I'd obviously learned to prune bad moves and it worked pretty well for me. But then thinking about it, this is exactly the wrong way to train your brain. It's job isn't to evaluate every single position, but rather to train it in the form of a "neural network" to institutionally recognize good vs. bad positions, and to expand on that. Looking at some high ranked players online, this seems to be the way they recognize positions and possibilities.
- IAmNotAFix 6y agoThis is true at every level of chess. The thinking optimum is somewhere between "playing without caution" and "over-analysing". Over-analysing is theorically the best but because we're not computers there are mistakes in our resulting assertions.
- omega3 6y agoI don't think this proves anything other than there are often contradictory idioms in chess, here's one attributed to Larsen: "If you find a good move, look for a better one".
- thomasahle 6y ago> very good players will ruin positions by rather than playing with their good instinct, over-analyzing a position I wonder if this is due to errors happening and getting mixed into the search. Computers pretty monotonously improve with thinking time, and the algorithm is pretty simple once you have good intuition to guide it. However, a single memory error down a line will turn the whole thing to mush.
- pelario 6y agoEven disregarding the errors, when "overthinking" is easy t go deeper in some branches than in others, without a very good probability estimation (which something the computer can do more easily: weight the branches). The "intuitive" approach is not that deep, but the depth is more even.