4 ms·
There's no 1000 page EULA to read, and FB wasn't the predator. CA asked for data and user said yes, same as if you accept a friend request with someone who goss
by lupire 6y ago
There's no 1000 page EULA to read, and FB wasn't the predator. CA asked for data and user said yes, same as if you accept a friend request with someone who gossips about you behind your back.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThis is ludicrous. So somebody friends me on Facebook, someone who I know and trust. Then that person comes along some quiz, and then in teeny text at the bottom of what looks like a standard "blah blah blah" popup is the information, carefully worded as to not be too alarmist, that that person's friends' data (i.e. me) will also be sucked up. At that point, why just stop at friends? Why not go to any transitive relationship with the argument "well, you trusted that person, so it's just like them sharing the data you already gave to them". Of course, the absurdity of that is that one person can share the whole world. I do not think this is a slippery slope argument at all, given that FB already went halfway down the slope before there was outrage.
- londons_explore 6y agoThe same argument could be said today about your web browser. I wrote this comment for people in this conversation to see. Yet you allowed Google Chrome access to the comment. You let your adblocker see it. You let lots of software companies scrape it. You shared the data with a wider audience than I intended. Sure, the argument doesn't hold much water on the public internet. But now consider HN was an invite-only forum, in fact an invite-only forum just like my facebook page...
- lovecg 6y agoYou’re making the same argument. Public comments are fair game and there’s no expectations of privacy. A private, or invite only, or a network like fb with complex privacy controls is another story entirely.
- CivBase 6y agoIf you told Facebook to give someone access to your personal information and they took it and handed it off to a third party, what is Facebook supposed to do about that? What can Facebook do about that? What could any website do about that? I despise Facebook, but I really don't understand this whole Cambridge Analytica thing. There doesn't appear to be an endgame for those criticizing Facebook over the ordeal. Of all the despicable things Facebook has done, why is this the one that everyone clings to?
- efdee 6y agoIt's not that my friend gave my info to someone else. My friend allowed the app to ask Facebook information about me. In the end, it's still Facebook who handed over my data. That my friend decided that was OK doesn't change much.
- CivBase 6y agoAs I understand, it was a browser extension which scraped data off the Facebook pages visited by users. There is no way Facebook could reasonably detect or combat that.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> As I understand, it was a browser extension which scraped data off the Facebook pages visited by users. That is false: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Ana...
- CivBase 6y agoNevermind. I thought it was a browser extension. I was not aware of the "Open Graph" platform. Thank you for the correction.
- cronix 6y agoI think you're confusing it with another recent FB event where they sued browser extension makers for scraping FB data. https://www.zdnet.com/article/facebook-sues-two-chrome-extension-devs-for-scraping-user-data/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/facebook-sues-two-chrome-exten...
- squeaky-clean 6y ago> CA asked for data and user said yes I think a lot of people are forgetting that you were also able to get tons of data on a user's friends, just from that user accepting. No consent on the friends part. If you and I were FB friends and I accepted one of those requests, CA now also knows your profile info and likes.
- coding123 6y agoWhat you said. I was starting to read the like 100 comments about how people clicked yes and so be it, but the entire time I was thinking, wait, no, that's not what happened. It's what you just said. Amazing how a little time leads to revisionist history for these people defending facebook.
- 14 6y agoI absolutely believe in my mind that big companies are actively posting to HN, Reddit, FB, et all, to steer different narratives.