5 ms·
> I have been able to outpace my retirement account's rate of growth by a very substantial margin Me and my fellow bogleheads are ... skeptical.
by JKCalhoun 6y ago
> I have been able to outpace my retirement account's rate of growth by a very substantial margin
Me and my fellow bogleheads are ... skeptical.
- lvh 6y agoOnly if that 401(k) is invested in a bunch of low-fee index funds. I've helped people move off 401(k)s with horrible QDIAs with 2% GERs that somehow managed to lose money in _2019_.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoYes, that is exactly what I am doing.
- lvh 6y agoI assumed that's what _you_ are doing since you proclaim to be a Boglehead :-) I'm saying that the GPs claim is only hard to believe as a Boglehead if you know they're invested in index funds in their retirement account. But 401(k)s are notorious for not having access to those. Saying that your brokerage account substantially outperforms your retirement account is perfectly compatible with a Boglehead perspective: all that means is that your brokerage account holds SCHB and your retirement account holds some infernal actively managed trash from Voya or whatever. There's a clear broken incentive there: a 401(k) manager with a sibling advisory firm will happily be the loss leader on giving companies 401(k)s for free because they'll make up for it in management fees. This is strictly bad for employees, who rarely have the knowledge to differentiate between 401(k) plans and even more rarely have the agency to do anything about it.
- bob1029 6y agoI used to subscribe to the boglehead ideology - I.e. there's no way to beat the institutional investors. Then, I encountered about a decade of real-world experience and actually tried my hand at investing in things that made a lot of sense to me, not based on historical pricing or other ridiculous voodoo, but based upon my knowledge of those securities relative to my experience in the technology sector. At no point do I screw with day trading or options. Simple long positions gets the job done. Risk still must be managed, even if we decide we are OK with more of it. I will absolutely grant you that the boglehead methodology makes sense if you dont want any stress at all regarding your investments, or otherwise have concerns that actively managing your money would devolve into a gambling addiction. For most people, this is probably the best path. If you consider where the incentives and power lie in the system, you might come to the realization that these ideologies might be based upon ulterior motives which are at your expense. If you are managing trillions of dollars in 401k assets, the last thing you want is for everyone to take full ownership of their portfolios and divest from managed funds.