4 ms·
In the Phaedrus, it was predicted that writing and reading in general (let alone specific examples such as pseudophilosophy) would eventually encourage confused
by 082349872349872 6y ago
In the Phaedrus, it was predicted that writing and reading in general (let alone specific examples such as pseudophilosophy) would eventually encourage confused, self-indulgent thinking.
> You offer your pupils the appearance of wisdom, not true wisdom, for they will read many things without instruction and will therefore seem to know many things, when they are for the most part ignorant and hard to get along with, since they are not wise, but only appear wise.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737221
- prox 6y agoI’ve engaged in philosophy for years, and the most important thing you learn when actually debating, is to learn to think in different frameworks of mind. This alone is of great benefit when reading or taking in thoughts of others.
- asimpletune 6y agoI haven’t read phaedrus in a while, but I think that interpretation is taken a little out of context. It’s better to say reading and writing, alone, would encourage these things. There’s this theme in Plato that power isn’t the end all be all. By that same logic, reading/writing were a technology that gave you power. Specifically the ability to record/recall things. Plato/Socrates argue that power alone gives you as much ability to achieve bad as it does good. Then they go on to argue that it’s wisdom that allows one to know what is good bad, thus wisdom is critical in all things. So, that’s why it’s says that in phaedrus, probably haha. It’s not that controversial actually, and not the sky is falling kind of thing. Socrates was just really particular about the pursuit of truth being sort of like the singular focus to achieving good, and the rest were important but had to follow from there. Parenthetically, I’ll add, he also seemed to believe that working out your body was just as important and necessary to being a philosopher.
- nescioquid 6y agoThere's a strand of suspicion towards literacy in Plato. Mainly I'm thinking of the dialog in which Socrates talks to a man about to sue his father (I'm sorry, I'm blanking on the name of the dialog); mainly the idea is that writing enfeebles the memory and intellect. > In the Phaedrus, it was predicted that writing and reading in general... would eventually encourage confused, self-indulgent thinking. We don't learn things, according to Plato, but the soul is brought to remember them again, and the remembering happens by virtue of a Socratic interrogation. If you read "x is the case", your soul hasn't been made to remember it, and worse, that proposition just might not be true which you won't discover without interrogation. Elsewhere (apologies, can't remember which dialog) Plato offers a description of thinking: the mind asks a question and then answers it. The form of the dialog models that process nicely.
- denton-scratch 6y agoPlato was an elitist; he wasn't against reading and writing in general, he simply thought that proles and people who weren't "like him" shouldn't be allowed to attempt it. 2,200 years later, I find I disagree. There's much that is good in Plato, but I don't include his social opinions.
- nescioquid 6y agoThat Plato's criticism of reading and writing comes down to us through his composed dialogs (and who furthermore abandoned his aspiration to become a playwright) was the surface-level irony that caught my attention. That Plato didn't want people to read and write in order to keep them out of philosophy because he was an elitist seems very doubtful. In fact, wouldn't the literate, educated, paying students of the sophists constitute an elite? The concept of elitism itself, I find a bit anachronistic here. I think there's something more interesting going on, and it has to do more with epistemic concerns than gate-keeping.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoHmm, Plato didn't consider that sophistry might be easier through oration than through writing ?
- nescioquid 6y agoSure, there's the dialog where Socrates encounters the two brothers who teach people how to "fight with words" (Euthydemus). The dialog is really pretty funny to read, and the arguments the brothers throw around I've seen referenced as examples of eristics (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eristic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eristic).
- BlueTemplar 6y agoDoes he really say something in the vein that it wouldn't be as bad if they did this in writing ?