3 ms·
Battleships, far from being a ridiculous idea, were a logical and necessary step for any navy wishing to project power at sea. They were so heavily armoured and
by stcredzero 15y ago
Battleships, far from being a ridiculous idea, were a logical and necessary step for any navy wishing to project power at sea. They were so heavily armoured and gunned that for a long time, from the late 19th Century to just before WWII, the only realistic defence against a battleship was another battleship.
Or, playing the "wolf card" amidst the fog of war and a resourcefully laid smokescreen with a bunch of smaller ships. (Causing the enemy commander to think, "They must have larger ships back there." This was destroyers vs. cruisers, not battleships, though.)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_off_Samar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_off_Samar
I suspect that the future belongs to drones. Autonomous Air Independent Propulsion submersible drones would be far less expensive than an aircraft carrier, but very likely to be able to lie in wait for a carrier and torpedo it.
EDIT: Correction -- one could actually say those American destroyers engaged the Yamato, which was the biggest, baddest battleship ever.
- ramchip 15y ago> Autonomous Air Independent Propulsion submersible drones Isn't this basically an electric torpedo?
- Unseelie 15y agoonly if it runs into things and explodes...if it launches its own torpedoes, its not a torpedo. Mother-torpedo..
- stcredzero 15y agoI'd equip those drones to launch anti-aircraft and anti-ship missiles as well as aerial drones.
- Unseelie 15y agoNot just drones, but -swarms- of drones. I make that point because its important to differentiate between what could be massive, battleship (or, likely, crusier) sized drones, and collections of very small drones. There's reasons this makes sense, even in the context of a fight against battleships (please assume similar technical capability, since a WWII Battleship would likely not fair well against a 2020 drone swarm..) A battleship, even a big automated one, has a series of weak points, such as sensors, removal of which can cripple the ship, and a swarm doesn't lose effectiveness at a blast from heavy weaponry...it may get a hole punched through it, and have only a few drones taken out...
- stcredzero 15y agoA battleship, even a big automated one, has a series of weak points, such as sensors, removal of which can cripple the ship The smoke and the rain squalls at the Battle of Samar were sufficient to make the larger guns available to the Japanese fleet irrelevant.