3 ms·
As I wrote in a comment[1] in their other attention-seeking post[2], they keep talking about "risks" and "vulnerability". There's no exploit or vulnerability h
by sneak 6y ago
As I wrote in a comment[1] in their other attention-seeking post[2], they keep talking about "risks" and "vulnerability".
There's no exploit or vulnerability here (despite their use of the "PoC" and "responsible disclosure" terms that apply to such things). The fact that you can detect a Signal proxy as a Signal proxy isn't a vulnerability; if it gets censored you're no worse off than you were if that proxy didn't exist: the main Signal servers are censored in Iran already. Indeed, this is the Signal circumvention proxy working precisely as designed.
As I understand it, these people got banned from the Signal forum for spreading this FUD there, too. Predictably, they started accusing Signal of some coverup. They managed to get an interview to further publicize their FUD, but eventually reason prevailed and that was pulled by the author, too.
Sometimes I really wonder the motives and identities behind the people causing such massive and unnecessary drama and fear in the community surrounding the only mainstream, reliable, end-to-end encrypted messenger out there. iMessage and WhatsApp both got their end-to-end crypto backdoored en masse via plaintext backup/escrow systems, but Signal remains generally safe and secure (provided general endpoint security practices are followed). These sorts of FUD attacks make me wonder about why they're happening, and the motives and incentives of the people causing them.
One of the people harassing Moxie about it on Twitter has <50 followers and an account that's only ~2 years old, with only a handful of posts in that time. My money's on sockpupppets.
1: https://github.com/net4people/bbs/issues/60#issuecomment-775179822 https://github.com/net4people/bbs/issues/60#issuecomment-775...
2: https://github.com/net4people/bbs/issues/60 https://github.com/net4people/bbs/issues/60
- rfoo 6y ago> Sometimes I really wonder the motives and identities behind the people causing such massive and unnecessary drama In this case, it's pretty boring. They are just a group of "your average power users" or "wannabe programmers" in their highschool or junior years who happened to be born in China so had some exposure to anti-censorship. Being in their overconfident period of life, they pass by various myth they don't really understand as truth. The community is quite toxic but usually they don't cause trouble outside of their own circle, but when it happens, I don't know how to deal with them either. They also misuses words like "vulnerability" or "responsible disclosure" because some of them have read a lot of news about security research, thought it is extremely cool but have no idea what it actually means.
- sneak 6y agoI've seen a growing number of anti-Signal posts and activism lately, mostly surrounding the (well-documented) design tradeoffs that Signal makes for usability and privacy (such as opting to use phone numbers for usernames, to avoid having to store contact lists/social graphs on Signal servers), or their famous decision not to federate/interoperate. Perhaps it's just criticism growing in lockstep with Signal's overall growth and notoriety, and there aren't any concerted efforts to discredit Signal and sow doubt about using it because it's harder for the intelligence agencies to surveil. I'd like to live in that world. I'm not sure that I do.
- fmajid 6y agoDid you know Signal, like Tor, was financed by an offshoot of the CIA? https://www.opentech.fund/results/supported-projects/open-whisper-systems/ https://www.opentech.fund/results/supported-projects/open-wh... https://pando.com/2015/03/01/internet-privacy-funded-by-spooks-a-brief-history-of-the-bbg/ https://pando.com/2015/03/01/internet-privacy-funded-by-spoo... Now if I were an Iranian dissident, I would be reasonably confident Signal is designed to withstand the Iranian regime’s interception efforts (but not necessarily traffic analysis). If I were someone on the US government’s shitlist like Edward Snowden or Julian Assange, my calculus would be entirely different. (Yes, I know Snowden has endorsed Signal)
- maqp 6y agoExcept Snowden said he uses the app everyday and is still alive. OTF money doesn't come with strings attached, if you can _prove_ otherwise, you might actually have something valuable to contribute to this conversation, but now it's just words that should be dismissed as conspiratorial.
- upofadown 6y agoOne major reason for the push back against Signal promotion is that it does not represent any sort of federated protocol. It is a complete silo. So if it did become popular it would eventually be a serious problem and would need to be fought against.
- rocqua 6y ago> The fact that you can detect a Signal proxy as a Signal proxy isn't a vulnerability; if it gets censored you're no worse off than you were if that proxy didn't exist: the main Signal servers are censored in Iran already. Indeed, this is the Signal circumvention proxy working precisely as designed. There is more risk than just "if it gets censored". If the proxy can be detected, so can users of that proxy. If users of a proxy can be detected, they can be punished for that. To what extend this actually happens, I am not sure of. So the severity of this vulnerability is unclear to me. What is clear, is that this is a vulnerability. Circumventing blocks tends to be illegal. If we want to help people circumvent such blocks, we need to help them from being caught as well. After all, we want to help against the blocks because we believe the blocks to be immoral.
- sneak 6y ago> What is clear, is that this is a vulnerability. Circumventing blocks tends to be illegal. If we want to help people circumvent such blocks, we need to help them from being caught as well. Nah, circumventing a block doesn't imply obfuscation of any kind. Signal's normal server connections are not obfuscated, there is no reasonable expectation that a connection to it via a proxy would be, either. It seems like people are considering this a vulnerability because accessing Signal (via a proxy or otherwise) in Iran is illegal (as I understand it). It doesn't seem like people would view this as a vulnerability if that weren't legally the case, so I don't think that points to this being a vulnerability in the software.
- rocqua 6y agoSignal put forward the TLS-proxy as a way to circumvent specifically the block on signal. This suggests they want people to be able to access signal despite it being illegal. The feature is 'use access in Iran despite it being illegal'. If that is your pitch, then 'being detectable as doing the illegal thing we want to enable' counts as a vulnerability for that feature. Whether software has a vulnerability or not cannot be determined without knowing how that software is meant to be used.