4 ms·
Imagine you are going to hire something expensive, and the owner wants a rental bond. So you go to a 3rd party, they set up a smart contract which automatically
by roenxi 6y ago
Imagine you are going to hire something expensive, and the owner wants a rental bond. So you go to a 3rd party, they set up a smart contract which automatically returns the bond to you 2 weeks after the lease ends, but the 3rd party can redirect the money to the owner by manually intervening.
The example is basic, but now the 3rd party can't take the money, go broke, take risks using your bond, etc, etc, etc. There is clear-in-code records of what the powers of the parties are and when things happen. You can prove where the money ended up.
This isn't an earth-shattering example, and things can still go wrong. But the failure cases have shrunk vs using paper. It is an improvement on the status quo.
- bildung 6y agoI've done your example in the real world, without smart contracts. The 3rd party is a notary. If I understood you right the notary here is replaced by a notary plus smart contracts. A notary in my juristication (Germany) is a quasi-employee of the government, so has little risk to go broke etc. The particular bonds for these cases are usually non-transferrable. OTOH smart contracts introduce new risks like bugs and costs like high gas prices - for what gain? Edit: To clarify, the modes of failure are vastly worse for the smart contract scenario. If the notary goes broke, my money will not be part of the insolvency estate. If OTOH the smart contract has a bug, everone's money is gone.
- roenxi 6y ago> A notary in my juristication (Germany) is a quasi-employee of the government, In a sense; precisely. At the moment, to fill that function, you need a quasi-government employee to have a trustworthy bondholder. With a smart contract, literally I could be the notary and while that would be super weird, I can't actually do anything not specified in the contract. Something is possible that wasn't possible before. That is why people can get excited about the idea.
- fock 6y agoyet you can do something not matching the real world outcome. and there's no way to roll that back. and people still need real-world trust in you... seems not soo smart to me.
- koonsolo 6y agoI don't know about Germany, but in Belgium you pay a crazy amount of money for the notary service. So it only makes sense to hire them for when dealing with large amounts of money. So what do you do with small amounts of money? Plus, not only notaries but also escrow services might be replaced with smart contracts. Smart contracts might be way cheaper. It will be very interesting to see this play out. But I wouldn't just discard smart contracts because we have some ancient way of doing things right now. And let's be honest, every time I have to deal with a notary, the work looks like it comes from Medieval times.
- hiq 6y agoIn Switzerland that's the default for deposits: you create a bank account in your name, but you're not allowed to touch this money until you've left the accommodation and the landlord has agreed that you left it in good shape. I've heard that it's also rather hard for the landlord to claim this money, they need a strong case.
- seniorivn 6y agoall those cases are examples of how old institutions have managed to solve issues relevant to the smartcontract case. But most people don't have access to such institutions, and it turns out building political institutions capable of providing such tools and trustworthy is really hard. Even worse, some people don't have as much trust in longterm longevity of governments. for all those people, trust-less smart contracts is a replacement of institutions they don't have, available as long as its tech works.
- Adrox 6y agoI still don't understand what happens when you actually break something expensive that you hire? Doesn't some 3rd part have to verify the damage? Doesn't the 2nd part then have to still take a part of the bond? What if the 2nd part just says you broke something, when you didn't, who solves that?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThis is an exact example of what I'm talking about, where, in your example, I actually see 0 utility, really negative utility, in using a smart contract. At the end of the day, this third party escrow service is still the only one that needs to evaluate the performance of services rendered - so where did your "trustless" distributed network go? I get that the smart contract can ensure that there are only 2 outcomes (money sent or money returned), but it's not like you can remove the legal system here - there is nothing to stop the 3rd party from colluding with one of the other parties to make the decision their way. Heck, even is you still wanted to use crypto, why not just get rid of the smart contract altogether and send the money to the 3rd party's escrow account? You still have a full audit trail so you're guaranteed to know is the 3rd party sent the money somewhere else.