5 ms·
I laughed a lot at imperial until I did a lot of woodworking. 12 is divisible evenly by 1,2,3,4,6,12. What a great number. Now I only laugh a little.
by Waterluvian 6y ago
I laughed a lot at imperial until I did a lot of woodworking. 12 is divisible evenly by 1,2,3,4,6,12. What a great number. Now I only laugh a little.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI'm a lifelong imperial-ist but switched to metric after getting into woodworking. It was too tempting to do math in my head like "This piece is 13 & 3/8ths, I need to subtract 13/32nds and then find the midpoint of that..." and then screw it all up at some point. Now it is just "This piece is 340mm, I need to subtract 9mm and find the midpoint: 116mm": relatively easy peasy.
- a1369209993 6y agoThat's not a problem with imperial (13+3/8 mm and 13/32 mm have the same problem); it's a problem with fractions (especially 'proper' fractions, which should never be used for anything ever, since they combine all the downsides of both decimals and rational numbers, with no benefit). Normalize everything to, say, 1/64 inch units and "This piece is 856/64in, I need to subtract 26/64in and then find the midpoint of that: (856-26)/2 = 415, so it's 415/64in." works fine.
- namanyayg 6y agoAre the conversions to normalised proper fractions and back to conventional improper fractions easier to do in the head or should one just use mm?
- chriswarbo 6y ago> Normalize everything to, say, 1/64 inch units If you "normalize everything" you get the metric system (up to a scaling factor): all distances are expressed in metres, all energies in Joules, all forces in Newtons, all pressures in Pascals, etc. Note that the latter are just naming conventions (for kgm^2/s^2, kgm/s^2 and kg/ms^2, respectively). This can lead to some unwieldy numbers, e.g. "turn left after four million 1/64 inches", so naming conventions are often used, like "mega" for "million".
- oh_sigh 6y agoTrue, but 1/2^n fractions are highly encouraged only with imperial in my experience, and my problem comes in that my different measuring instruments give me different levels of precision, ranging from 1/8" if I'm using a big measuring stick, to 1/16" on my tape measure, to 1/32" on my embedded measure, to 1/128" on my calipers. And then there are times when you are given measurements in tenths of an inch which feels natural for most (13.2" long), and that gets ugly... Probably if I was a better woodworker I would have a solution for this without switching to metric.
- yencabulator 6y ago> 13+3/8 mm and 13/32 mm have the same problem Nobody who grew up with metric uses such measurements. Outside of the US, metric measurements are usually to the millimeter (add decimal places for serious CNC etc work), not to some odd fractions. The equivalent math is what they said: (340mm-9mm)/2. No weird fractions.
- a1369209993 6y agoEr, yes, that was my point: the problem is with the fractions (and especially though not exclusively the 'proper' fractions), not with the choice of metric vs imperial for units.
- yencabulator 6y agoImperial explicitly endorses the use of all the weird fractions and measuring tenths of an inch with a measuring tape is simply not a thing that would ever happen in the US. I hate converting between 3/8ths and 7/32nds all the time. It's such a stupid system, and I miss metric.
- ramses0 6y agoYou might consider switching back to imperial... (165.5mm)
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI’m all for metric for standardization but I do think something is lost with 10-based systems. Walking is usually measured in pairs, many music systems in fours, many cooking measures in thirds, many art techniques in combinations of thirds and powers of two. It’s also worth pointing out that as far as I know efforts to 10-base time have failed.
- CaptArmchair 6y ago> It’s also worth pointing out that as far as I know efforts to 10-base time have failed. Sure, the French Republican Calendar "failed". But it "failed" less so because it was 10-base. Napoleon abolished it because of 2 main flaws: (a) The decree that formalized the calendar contradicted itself when it came to determining leap years. (b) The beginning of the year/era was based on commemorating a historical event rather then observing the beginning of Winter or Spring. Which would make adoption of the calendar hard. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Republican_calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Republican_calendar Then again, the traditional Chinese timekeeping was/is partly 10-based. This system developed in it's own right separate of systems that emerged throughout Europe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditional_Chinese_timekeeping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditional_Chinese_timekeepin... Time keeping is a "hard problem" anyway. As a historian, dating a historic document can be a daunting task when you're confronted with different calendars.
- phreeza 6y agoComplete tangent, but I am currently listening to the excellent "Age of Napoleon" podcast, and the host suggests that the abolition of the calendar by Napoleon was (a) basically ratifying what was already widely done in society and (b) a symbolic guesture to assuage conservatives and catholics.
- InitialLastName 6y ago> Walking is usually measured in pairs I don't understand this at all, but I want to. Is it that we use pairs of steps sometimes (single paces seem just as useful)? Walk out and back? Walk in groups of two?
- exporectomy 6y agoI hear this a lot as an abstract statement but can you give a real world example of where you personally have used that fact? I've struggled to think of any way it would be useful. Dividing by 2 is useful for finding a center, but obviously you can do that just as easily in metric.
- thih9 6y agoWoodworking could be a mix of divisibility and industry specific product sizing. Dividing a 2" by 4" into pieces seems easier than dividing a 50.8 mm × 101.6 mm.
- klik99 6y agoExcept a 2"x4" is actually a 1.5"x3.5" [edit] I have no skin in this game - I grew up in England and America and literally don't care - just pointing out how weird the "2 by 4" terminology is
- goodcanadian 6y agoMy understanding was that those were meant to be the dimensions prior to planing . . .
- mnw21cam 6y agoAgreed, but that's a heck of a margin to plane off.
- nicwolff 6y agoThe board is 2"x4" before drying; after drying it will usually have cupped and twisted slightly, so the planing really is bringing the sides back into plane, which takes more removal than if it were just to smooth them.
- exporectomy 6y agoYou mean the advantage is in the fact that materials come in convenient imperial measurements? In metric countries, they come in convenient metric sizes too, so that's no real advantage when everyone else cooperates. Obviously, nobody uses 50.8 x 101.6 mm timber unless they've converted from inches, so without inches, it wouldn't exist. The advantage I'm talking about is what comes from having 12 inches in a foot. If you're only using inches and not feet then there's obviously no advantage from that.
- chriswarbo 6y agoBase-10 is rather incidental to metric: we can have a "kilofoot" just as easily as "a dozen metres". The main benefits of metric (actually SI) are: - One unit for each dimension, e.g. all distances are in metres. - The conversion factor between dimensions is 1, e.g. 1Nm = 1J, 1Pa = 1N/m^2, etc. We often use prefixes like "centi" or "kilo", but they're just multipliers rather than separate units (SI calls them "derived units"). The main problems with metric are: - Still some redundancy, e.g. litres, tonnes, hours, etc. These are avoided by SI. - The base unit of mass is confusingly called the "kilogram". Hence any conversion factor involving grams will get a 1/1000, since the gram is 1/1000 of the base unit. I wrote about this at http://chriswarbo.net/blog/2020-05-22-metric_red_herring.html http://chriswarbo.net/blog/2020-05-22-metric_red_herring.htm...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- globular-toast 6y agoHaving grown up in the UK I was taught metric for everything, but there is plenty of exposure to imperial from older generations. The one thing I've come to realise about imperial is, it's much more "human". Centimetres, kilograms etc. seem completely arbitrary and unrelatable. Even people my age who learnt metric can eyeball "about an inch", but "about a centimetre"? It's too small to be useful, and being smaller means your error percentage is way higher. Similarly, some recipes are expressed really neatly in imperial. Shortcrust pastry to fill a 9-inch pan? 5 ounces of flour and 4 ounces of butter. Good luck trying to remember the metric equivalent. Same with Celsius vs Farenheit. The former puts landmarks at freezing and boiling of water. OK, freezing is useful, but who actually cares about the boiling point of water? It boils when it boils. Farenheit instead gives you a scale from "bloody cold" to "bloody hot". The choice of base 10 units is also completely arbitrary. So we have ten fingers? So what? That's not useful. Metric takes the view that everyone will work with arbitrary real number measurements, but we don't. We naturally use fractions. The fact you can't evenly divide a metric unit in three is terrible. If you look at standard sizes for, say, kitchen units in Europe, they actually are multiples of 6. A unit is 600mm and therefore divisible by 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10 and 12. Wouldn't it be so much neater if we could just write 100mm instead of 600mm? We know humans can remember more than ten symbols because our alphabet is larger. Sigh... I suppose having one standard is better than a few competing standards or no standard at all.
- Waterluvian 6y agoOn reading this I thought, "hmm, I can eyeball a centimetre just fine." And then I realized that I do that by eyeballing an inch and taking a bit less than half of it.
- goodcanadian 6y agoA centimetre is about the width of my pinky finger. And, an inch is about the width of my thumb.
- KozmoNau7 6y ago> "Shortcrust pastry to fill a 9-inch pan? 5 ounces of flour and 4 ounces of butter" Useful mnemonic, but completely arbitrary. If you cook/bake regularly, you know the standard amounts used. I know the amounts needed for a bread that fits into my rising basket, starting with 450g white flour and 50g rye flour, 350g water and so on. If you decide to go more advanced, you use baker's percentages anyway, which of course map neatly to a base-10 system. > "The fact you can't evenly divide a metric unit in three is terrible." The elegance of metric is that everything divides neatly into 10ths and powers of 10, which makes it simple to convert measurements from one scale to another, for whichever level of precision you require. Meters work for farming, centimeters work for houses, millimeters for woodworking, micrometers for machining. Just as the common misconception of a 2x4" (really 1.5x3.5") becoming a bizarre 3.81x8.89cm is unrealistic and based on misconceptions, so is the idea of people somehow being unable to divide a metric measurement into thirds. Your pencil line is going to be thicker than any inaccuracy anyway, but the precision (repeatability) is going to be the same no matter which measuring system you use, as long as your measuring device is accurate. If you want a more accurate measurement and cut, you use a more accurate measuring device and scale. I grew up learning and using metric for everything. Imperial may as well be an alien measurement from another planet, to me an inch is just an old-fashioned way of saying 2.54cm, and eyeballing a cm has literally never been an issue. Regarding the kitchen cabinets, if you were to redefine 100mm as "the width of a kitchen cabinet", you would be optimizing for one specific use case over others. The entire point of a measurements system is that it is universal, repeatable and logical, not based on arbitrary units. 600mm is a perfectly good measurement, no harder to remember than 100mm or 20 kilometers or 250 grams.
- pampa 6y agoThat is exactly my experience with imperial in woodworking! I had no previous experience with imperial measurements, my country is metric for over a hundred years, but the majority of information on woodworking on the internet or in print comes from English speaking countries that use imperial units in woodworking almost exclusively. So instead of trying to translate everything to metric I bought an imperial tape measure and a set of rulers. Since then I switched most of my woodworking measurements to imperial, because it just very convenient and makes much more sense when building items that will be used by humans. Chairs, tables, cabinets, chests, even guitars.
- userbinator 6y agoOn the other hand, in metalworking and precision machining, decimals are used again - a common resolution is 1/1000th of an inch (0.001"), or a "thou".
- ncmncm 6y agoIn the US we call that a "mil". I have not encountered "thou".