3 ms·
> If all it took was a lie on an application for Robinhood to grant someone the ability to use extremely risky trading strategies, that's still Robinhood's faul
by nomel 6y ago
> If all it took was a lie on an application for Robinhood to grant someone the ability to use extremely risky trading strategies, that's still Robinhood's fault.
In your world, do we blame casinos when someone goes in and gambles away their money? My naive perspective sees no difference. The concept of an individual being responsible for their own terrible choices really seems to have changed unbelievably in the last 20 years.
- tidepod12 6y agoThe minimum age for gambling in many states is 21. So yes, if this 20 year old student walked into a casino and gambled away all his money, it would be the casino's fault for allowing that to happen.
- totalZero 6y agohttps://www.finra.org/rules-guidance/rulebooks/finra-rules/2360 https://www.finra.org/rules-guidance/rulebooks/finra-rules/2... Try CTRL+F "suitability" for a five-second read of why the casino comparison doesn't apply here.
- nomel 6y agoFor the personal accountability perspective, I would say it applies even more, since there are no requirements at all for walking into a casino and burning up $100k, yet we don't blame the casinos, we blame the person burning the money. For the perspective that Robinhood owns his risk somehow, from not following their suitability guidelines, I'm not familiar with any of this so can't speak about it. Naively reading this, it appears to be extremely open ended, requiring a consistent internal process for approval, along with a warning, rather than anything specific.
- totalZero 6y ago"No member or person associated with a member shall recommend to any customer any transaction for the purchase or sale (writing) of an option contract unless such member or person associated therewith has *reasonable grounds* to believe upon the basis of information furnished by such customer after *reasonable inquiry* by the member or person associated therewith concerning the customer's investment objectives, financial situation and needs, and any other information known by such member or associated person, that the recommended transaction is not unsuitable for such customer." The burden's on the firm to demonstrate why it believed the customer was qualified to trade the product, and to demonstrate that it made an effort to evaluate the customer's goals, finances, and needs.
- nomel 6y agoMaybe the terminology is too foreign to me, but > ... shall recommend to any customer any transaction ... > ... that the recommended transaction is not suitable Was Robinhood recommending transactions, or just enabling transactions? Even if not, this seems very open ended with no specifics, since “reasonable” is up for interpretation. I suppose we’ll see, probably sooner rather than later. I assume some actual specifics will result from all of this though.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoWhen I ask a criminal barrister for advise, he/she carries some responsibility, and should have my best interest in mind. If I ask a guy on the street, he does not. If Robinhood wants to carry same responsibility as casinos, they should call themselves a casino. Then they will loose certain privileges like in UK it's illegal for casinos to provide leverage or 'gambling debt', they will be subject to payout percentage regulation, etc. https://www.casino.co.uk/guides/payout-percentages-rtp/ https://www.casino.co.uk/guides/payout-percentages-rtp/