6 ms·
> The Kearns’ family complaint says, “Not only did Robinhood permit Alex to open the account, but when Alex was a freshman in college later that year, it permit
by pc86 6y ago
> The Kearns’ family complaint says, “Not only did Robinhood permit Alex to open the account, but when Alex was a freshman in college later that year, it permitted him to trade options.”
You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application.
> “Worse, Robinhood provided almost no investment guidance, and its customer ‘service’ was virtually non-existent, consisting of automated e-mail replies devoid of any human contact or interaction,” the family alleged in the suit.
How many brokers provide investment guidance? How many do it without additional fees?
I've only reached out to Robinhood two or three times but a person has responded to the initial inquiry in all but one instance (where an automated email just said it would be a while, and a person followed up about a week later to actually address the issue).
Robinhood is a shit company and I look forward to incoming class action lawsuit but this is a grieving family lashing out and should be dismissed. If anything comes of this the only thing that's going to happen is there are going to be more roadblocks for retail investors to invest.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> How many brokers provide investment guidance? It is usually quite explicit that they are not providing investment advice with the online ones.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edgyquant 6y agoAdvice and guidance are two separate things (even if they sound the same.) Vanguard, for instance, has volumes explaining trading and investment strategies but advice would me more like implying you should use a strategy or buy a specific equity.
- tidepod12 6y ago>You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application. If all it took was a lie on an application for Robinhood to grant someone the ability to use extremely risky trading strategies, that's still Robinhood's fault. Robinhood isn't absolved of responsibility just because the student did something dishonest. Given the fact he was 20 years old, his options application should have automatically been under a heightened degree of scrutiny, if not immediately rejected. That it wasn't indicates Robinhood is not responsibly implementing KYC controls, which is a huge deal.
- giantg2 6y agoYou're an adult 18. I think people need to take more responsibility for their own actions instead of this increasing trend of treating adults as kids.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Godel_unicode 6y agoWe've created this bizarre feedback loop of treating older and older people to like children, which causes older and older people to act like children.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI know man, these hedgefund managers and Boeing executives have been totally infantilized!
- Godel_unicode 6y agoI'm clearly talking about the 18-year-olds referenced in the post I'm replying to. But good job I suppose?
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am just pointing out that there is a range of people trying to absolve themselves of responsibility, and I am not clear what leads folks to conclude that 18-year are the problem. When COVID/2008 hits the fan, its the young people on zero hour contract that loose their income first, landlords might loose some, and banks loose least. If anything our system is setup so that the higher you are, the less consequences you face. I believe this is the new phenomenon and its not helped by 'kids these days, back in my day...'.
- hertzrat 6y ago
- Thorncorona 6y agoRH's entire schtick is to be the amateur's investment broker. Their barrier to entry for margin and options is practically 0. When the only thing you need to do in order to get access to level 3 options is check a couple boxes, you're practically encouraging this type of activity. RH is breaking a ton of rules atm and there is a reason why most brokers are high touch for margin/options and unfortunately the Kearns' family is first hand evidence of this. Most other brokers WILL NOT allow this. When I applied for options Schwab had a broker call me and make sure I knew about all the risks involved for the level I applied for. RH was also down a couple times in March, which lost me a good amount of money. A week is a VERY long time if you're playing short-term options. There's also other issues where they were holding customer shares in margin when they had cash to cover, and when they've allowed customers to leverage 5k -> 1M of positions (a huge nono). The conclusion here is that RH is a toy broker following the mantra of move fast and breaks things. Good if you're casually investing, but for options and serious investing with real amounts of cash it's worth getting a broker that is serious at providing reliable service.
- tidepod12 6y ago>The conclusion here is that RH is a toy broker following the mantra of move fast and breaks things. I personally see them at the Juul of the finance world. They're intentionally targeting young inexperienced people and telling them "just download this app and you'll be rich! all your friends are doing it, don't miss out!"
- nightski 6y agoNot sure how many brokers you have applied to lately but - TDA, Fidelity, Webull, Interactive Brokers, Tasty works, ETrade, and more all make options just as accessible as RH.
- subsaharancoder 6y agoWhen I applied to enable Options trading on my Fidelity account, I had to wait 3 days plus they sent me a booklet which looked like it was printed in the 80s about the risks of options trading, they also pointed me to a section on their site with tutorials about options trading once they had enabled my account. By the time they were done I was rethinking my plan to trade options :-)
- ROARosen 6y ago> and a person followed up about a week late I remember reading when the original story broke that the negative balance / suicide happened over a weekend. And about the the negative balance, I've had a similar story (with much less). The problem is that once a long-short vertical option expires worthless, Robinhood showed a negative balance for the full amount of the short position, even if you had a long position covering most of it. Because they don't update the available balance/money you made from the long side until it clears (which can take a few days). I believe it was extremely bad UX on Robinhood's part, even my heart skipped a beat when I saw the negative bal, and that was for only 5k.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y ago> You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application. Isn't this a problem with most brokers? They all seem to require that you claim experience trading an asset class before they let you trade that asset class.
- tidepod12 6y agoBrokers are required by law to "protect" traders from financially harming themselves by restricting the trades that can be made until the trader verifies that they know what they are doing. Some brokers will go as far as to personally call you up and give you an on-the-spot quiz about how options work before letting you trade them, for example. Many brokers seem to have gotten very lax about this in recent years, and even Schwab/Ameritrade allowed me to trade options without verifying anything. My guess is that the recent Robinhhood/GME fiasco is going to see FINRA cracking down hard and reinstating some strict verification procedures.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoI was able to trade options with TradeKing in 2010 by just checking a box, claiming that I knew that I was doing. (I was still in college and did not know what I was doing, but fortunately only ended up losing a few hundred bucks.) This isn't new - it's how it's worked for a good long while.
- tidepod12 6y agoThe regulations, such as FINRA Rule 2111, were not in place until the early 2010s. FINRA/SEC implemented stricter requirements for the verification I mentioned in my first comment, but over the past ~5-7 years the brokerages have relaxed them. So yes, it is new relative to your experience in 2010.
- rickyc091 6y agoYeah, it's pretty easy to get level 3 trading option these days. In fact, if you select level 3 and answer incorrect, they even prompt you and say, hey that option won't let you get verified for level 3. With older brokerage firms, they use to call you up after you signed up. You would have to chat with them on the phone before they unlocked your account.
- JeremyBanks 6y ago> You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application. Could you please clarify, what does the application ask that he would have had to lie about?
- pc86 6y agoQuestions like trading experience with different kinds of options, annual income, liquid net worth, total net worth are all pretty standard. Some brokers (not RH) also about about the source of your experience. Actual experience trading options may push you higher on the list than simply being instructed in what options are by an investment professional if you're otherwise on the border between two. I've been declined for top options levels before because my total net worth was too low even with years of actual options trading experience (including complicated multi-leg strategies).
- notyourwork 6y agoSadly I agree. The idea that someone willingly applied to have options trading available and is in fact an adult should be enough that its not the trading platform's fault.
- gchamonlive 6y agoIf it were underage girls that lied for pornhub amateur and got accepted the argument would not hold, so I don't think it should hold in this case either. It is the company's job to make sure the screening process is not too permissive.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoWhat I do not understand, is how do you just accept that a major company managing people's (potentially) life savings in a regulated market has no responsibility to pick up the phone? I would accept it if RH did not communicate with the customer at all because they were overwhelmed or something. But they did communicate, they sent out an email demanding money. Do they have no process to talk to a customer who has lost a lot of money? This is not a rare freak event, it's key part of the business they are in. You'd think about this within the first 10 minutes of even entertaining the idea of starting a trading firm. Even the WSB reddit had a link to a suicide prevention hotline, how is RH more irresponsible than a random web forum. We as a society don't need to bend over backwards to accomodate these zero-support business models - and especially not as the bedrock of our economy. Lastly, I want to share a court case from Russia: for a few years it was common for banks to mass send out loan contracts in the post to random Tom, Dick and Harry. It would just appear in your postbox randomly, and if you countersign it you would get the money. One bloke scanned the document and amended it, he really went to town: increased the borrowing limit, put in a negative interest rate, etc. The bank signed it without realising. Obviously the bank sued, argued that their business model made it impossible to read every contract and the that the guy knew that. The judge held up the contract, saying it wasn't the customers problem their business model involves spamming people and signing things without reading.
- thedevelopnik 6y agoThose are changes RH made in reaction to this kid killing himself. They added increased barriers and human interaction because of this, that weren’t present when this happened to him.
- tarsinge 6y agoNovice question: to lose that much money do you need to sell options? My understanding was that buying options was relatively safe.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoOptions are considered binary plays: they either expire in the money, or they expire worthless. It would be trivially simple to empty out your entire account by buying foolishly deep out-of-the-money options. (E.g. betting that GameStop shares will be worth $800 by the end of the week).
- mam2 6y agoyes but the catch is that he didn't lose the money really ... it was a UX glitch that made him suicide
- pc86 6y agoSome options (buying calls or puts, selling covered calls or cash-secured puts) are "safe" in the sense that you can't lose more than your initial investment. Some do have a larger downside that can exceed your initial investment, and some have technically infinite downside. That's why there are several levels of options, so you can be approved for the safe bets but not the ones that could cost you a million dollars on a $1,000 bet.