4 ms·
The person's guilt must be proven beyond all reasonable doubt. If you are accusing him there is a range of possible proof. If all you have is based on an unread
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
The person's guilt must be proven beyond all reasonable doubt. If you are accusing him there is a range of possible proof. If all you have is based on an unreadable codebase, that takes 100 years to read, that's your (the prosecution's) fuckup. As a jury I would not convict.
I don't want prosecutors sleeping on the job, bringing in fraudsters laymen and psychics to accuse people, etc.
The prosecutor should use a company that can present independent proof that their system actually works.
- kenjackson 6y agoSo what if I say i need to review camera footage of me doing a crime and it will take me 100 years to validate it? You need to establish reasonable timelines for this or any guilty person will claim any technology used will take 100 years to verify. There is no reason you can’t analyze a DNA analysis codebase in 6 months. Unless you also need to verify the science.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am not clear what you are arguing - it there a real problem where people invent fantastical amount of time to review simple evidence? The claim about the amount of time was not made by the defendant, it was from the company that produced the code.
- kenjackson 6y agoThanks for the clarification -- I actually misread it and thought the defendant was making the claim. With it being the company, then I agree that the company has an obligation to make review simple enough that it can be done in a reasonable amount of time (from someone knowledgeable in the field -- I still don't think we need to allow someone 10 years to understand statistics and progreamming before even beginning the code review) or recuse the tool from use in a trial.