3 ms·
There has been for quite a while a big concern that industrial control systems are accessible, often poorly hardened (and by that I mean to the extent of having
by colechristensen 6y ago
There has been for quite a while a big concern that industrial control systems are accessible, often poorly hardened (and by that I mean to the extent of having default passwords), and quite vulnerable to attack.
The only thing surprising about this is that we don't hear about it tenfold more.
- laurowyn 6y agoAbsolutely. Meanwhile, we live in a world where VPNs are sold to the casual user while critical systems are left on internet facing networks. I've never understood why, if these critical systems need remote access, it's not all done through a VPN of some sort. VPNs are not infallible, but it significantly increases the bar for entry from script kiddie to nation state real quick (depending on choice of crypt), while choosing a well supported implementation ensures long term bug fixes and security patches.
- bilbo0s 6y agoIn all honesty, why is a system so critical on the internet at all? People say, ease of administration, but there are other methods of achieving the same thing. Up to and including running your own network. On the one hand your engineers and chemists won't be able to fiddle with the aeration stage using their brand new, whiz bang, iPhone. On the other, the people in your community won't be put in harms way.
- the_only_law 6y ago> On the one hand your engineers and chemists won't be able to fiddle with the aeration stage using their brand new, whiz bang, iPhone Maybe not at home, but couldn’t they have a local 802.11 network set up for this?
- pseudoramble 6y agoNo idea why this wasn’t. Often times they’re not for this reason _and_ because the hardware itself is too difficult or impossible to get online and can’t be upgraded. Forget networks for a moment - a system running Windows XP is way less risk than an upgrade to Windows 7. Plenty of companies have older systems running vital hardware that if it went offline could cause massive outages, revenue loss being only one if the impacts. So air gapped networks are pretty common in ICS environments as a result.
- JPKab 6y agoAfter meeting enough SAP consultants in the ICS space, all I can say is I'm shocked it doesn't happen every day.
- 2bitencryption 6y ago> The only thing surprising about this is that we don't hear about it tenfold more. If you're someone who stands to gain from disrupting a nation's infrastructure... you don't tip your hand until it most benefits you. If it really is the case that large parts of the infrastructure are very unsecure, expect to hear about it all at once, instead of little by little.
- munk-a 6y agoWater seems like a really weird system to sabotage though - power can bring businesses offline in a serious way but a city reservoir likely isn't supplying any businesses with a real need of water for any sorts of industrial needs... It's more of an inconvenience. Messing with chemical balances in particular seems like a prank or someone really twisted trying to give a bunch of folks long term health complications.
- devonkim 6y agoSometimes attacks are probes and discoveries meant to determine or validate efficacy of a set of attack vectors including but not limited to human assets. Other uses are for distractions from other efforts. And yeah, sometimes they’re pranks. It’s not clear with the given facts what’s really going on.
- vlovich123 6y agoYou can't cause a rash of serious short term problems that increase the load on your health care system? That would be pretty compelling from a terrorist perspective or for nation states trying to demoralize/reduce trust in the current government.
- TimothyBJacobs 6y agoDepends how long you can shut it down for. Even if only a few hours, an _unexpected_ shutdown of water across an entire city would certainly cause a panic with people descending on any stores open to buy water.
- deleted 6y ago
- Analemma_ 6y agoTo be honest, these days I just take it as a given that all critical US infrastructure (the power grid, hospitals, and now apparently water treatment plants) is riddled with time bombs, and that if we were to ever get in a shooting war with the countries which put them there, they'd all go off at once and we'd be in a world of hurt. I hope government/military planners are making the same assumption. It would be sort of darkly amusing if we've done the same thing to other countries, and so time bombs in infrastructure essentially replace nuclear weapons as the guarantors of Mutually Assured Destruction.