4 ms·
I was a Sr Manager for about 4 years, two different "teams", one IT based, one QA based. Regardless, perhaps we need to define the word "Manager", mainly becaus
by 100011_100001 6y ago
I was a Sr Manager for about 4 years, two different "teams", one IT based, one QA based. Regardless, perhaps we need to define the word "Manager", mainly because your example said:
> Creating entire new groups of engineers and then hiring them to solve specific problems of moving traffic between regions.
Albeit admirable, like heck yeah that was a great outcome, it's not a manager decision. Most likely it was a VP or Sr Director decision. Perhaps a manager brought it up as an idea. So if we are talking about Sr Director's+ then yes, their decisions can absolutely bring down a business. Granted I am not familiar with Netflix's org chart so perhaps it works differently, from some basic reading it looks like Netflix follows a decentralized command of sorts.
My beef with the original poster was the implication of risk. Both managers and devs have risk with their decisions. It's not just a manager thing. In the end, when Netflix went down where did the mistake come from? A manager or an architecture decision? Probably it was both.
- jedberg 6y ago> In the end, when Netflix went down where did the mistake come from? A manager or an architecture decision? Probably it was both. In that particular case it was an engineer making a mistake, but my point was that it wasn't anywhere close to a fatal mistake. But more importantly, when a team had repeated technical failures, it was usually the manager who suffered the consequences. Especially if their failures were causing problems with other teams. The manager had the higher risk job because they were blamed for their team's failures. Therefore they had to be compensated to account for that risk to their job. It's the same reason CEOs get huge golden parachutes. Because their job is constantly at risk for not only their decisions but the decisions of everyone below them. So they get compensated for that risk.