4 ms·
Unfortunately, the vast majority of crimes don't produce evidence that rises to the level you call for. After all, if my next door neighbour barged into my hou
by michaelt 6y ago
Unfortunately, the vast majority of crimes don't produce evidence that rises to the level you call for.
After all, if my next door neighbour barged into my house and beat me up, the only evidence would be my visible injuries and my statement that it was my neighbour.
I'm not sure if I'd prefer a society where he would be convicted, or where he wouldn't.
- londons_explore 6y agoMaybe your neighbour has a nicer car than you which makes you feel insecure so you decide to beat yourself up and go to the police saying your neighbour did it. Considering that possibility, I don't want to put your neighbour in prison.
- michaelt 6y agoAnd presumably, if having been denied justice I pursue revenge instead, I can barge into his home and beat him up, as he did to me, and avoid punishment for the same reason? While I admire your devotion to Blackstone's Ratio, this doesn't seem like a recipe for stability and rule of law to me.