3 ms·
I wonder if it's possible to get the job applicants to evaluate each other? That way you have a process that automatically scales to the number of applicants y
by londons_explore 6y ago
I wonder if it's possible to get the job applicants to evaluate each other?
That way you have a process that automatically scales to the number of applicants you have.
Exactly how to structure it so it can't be gamed/subverted is tricky, but you might imagine some team activity where the team does a task together, and then each person in the team is asked to so some kind of review of the other people in the team.
If you make the team activity be a small nugget of the actual work you need done, and you pay all the interviewees generously for their time, I can't imagine interviewees walking away unhappy at the end, even if they don't get the job.
You then interview the top 2 people from each team.
- dcolkitt 6y ago> Exactly how to structure it so it can't be gamed/subverted is tricky Most companies pay a commission to the recruiter or a referral bonus. You could distribute that to those candidates who contribute to the recommendation of the winning candidate. You're incentivized to recommend the best person, because you can still make money even if you don't get the job. Also you could always hire for a batch of positions, or at least more than one person at a time. That way, just because someone else gets the job doesn't preclude you from also getting it.
- wccrawford 6y agoAny time people are asked to review their peers, there's at least some compulsion to rate others poorly because it'll make you look better. IME, the only times that it can go well is with people who don't think the results will matter. And in which case, why do it? The one exception is someone who is already somewhat of a leader and isn't looking for a promotion, and so they don't have much desire to make themselves look better.
- xyzelement 6y ago>> I wonder if it's possible to get the job applicants to evaluate each other? I can't tell if this is the stupidest idea or brilliant. On one hand you're saying "take a bunch of people we don't know are qualified to work here and empower them to make our hiring decisions" which sounds dumb. But on the other hand, if people chosen through this process do well, you should go back and hire those who "hired" them as managers :)