2 ms·
I find it a little weird that this story is being attributed to a "philosophy professor", when the lesson imparted is religious advice unrelated to what philoso
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
I find it a little weird that this story is being attributed to a "philosophy professor", when the lesson imparted is religious advice unrelated to what philosophers talk about.
As far as examining how the concept of "fullness" applies to jars, it's pretty straightforward to say that the jar is full every time, including before the giant rocks are added, but what it is full of changes. You can go in different directions from there -- say that "full" is underspecified and the students must infer a more specific meaning from context, or ask whether, if you cap a jar full of air with an airtight lid and chill it, it is still "full" -- but one place you can't go is "these rocks are actually your family".
- Swizec 6y agoIt’s a parable to illustrate a useful lesson and worldview. It’s not a philosophy master thesis. You don’t need to hackernews this one. I bet you it isn’t even factual and no such class ever happened.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI didn't say it was factual. I said it was strange that the person relating the parable-within-the-parable is identified as a "philosophy professor". This is a comment on the narrative properties of the outer parable. Followup: why isn't this demonstration given by a "history professor"? They wouldn't be more relevant, so...?
- Swizec 6y agoI think the target audience most easily identifies a person with such a lesson as a philosopher. Other options include guru, yogi, etc. But then the target auidence puts story in the woo-woo category and doesn’t take to the point.
- SamBam 6y ago> unrelated to what philosophers talk about Plenty of philosophers talk about how to live a full, meaningful and happy life. Plato, Aristotle, the Stoics, St. Augustine, and plenty more. It's not all metaphysics, qualia, or master-slave dialectics.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoAristotle also empirically discussed the form and behavior of various insects, and of course he non-empirically discussed the form and behavior of legendary creatures. And all of that came under the umbrella of "philosophy" as the word was used centuries ago, but it doesn't today, and neither does the material here. When I say "what philosophers talk about", I do not mean to imply that if Daniel Dennett remarks "nice day today", then common weather patterns are a topic in philosophy, and I hope that that lack of implication was obvious to most readers.
- SamBam 6y agoAre you seriously suggesting Aristotle isn't discussed by philosophers, and isn't considered a philosopher by academics?
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI am seriously suggesting that most of what Aristotle wrote was not philosophy. Some of it was, but that doesn't mean the rest of it was too.
- SamBam 6y ago...this is silly. You implied that Aristotle discussing the good life was akin to Dennett discussing the weather, and that such a discourse is not considered "real philosophy" anymore. I'm saying that absurd, and simply shows you don't know enough about philosophy. Here's a quick search of philosophy journals and books that reference "Aristotle" and the "good life." Are you suggesting that these aren't modern philosophy? [1] And how about the rest of them? Do articles on the Stoics not count as philosophy either? (I realize that after a couple undergraduate courses in philosophy everyone covers Dennett, and maybe Wittgenstein and Hume and a few others, and comes away thinking that any discussion of "practical" philosophy isn't "true" philosophy, but that isn't the case at all. I don't know whether this applies to you or not.) 1. https://link.springer.com/search?query=aristotle+good+life&facet-discipline=%22Philosophy%22 https://link.springer.com/search?query=aristotle+good+life&f... . Feel free to filter further by journal articles if you think books don't count as modern philosophy.