4 ms·
> I'm always stunned and disappointed at how easy it is to game the American political system. It’s easy to be a cynic, but you still need to match your belief
by rayiner 6y ago
> I'm always stunned and disappointed at how easy it is to game the American political system.
It’s easy to be a cynic, but you still need to match your beliefs up against reality. This particular belief really shouldn’t have survived the Trump era. Trump won in 2016 and almost won in 2020 despite Clinton and Biden having a huge financial edge from donors in the biggest industries (Wall Street, media, tech, etc.) See: https://mobile.twitter.com/annalecta/status/1323370439306055683 https://mobile.twitter.com/annalecta/status/1323370439306055.... See: https://www.npr.org/2020/10/26/927453369/outspent-in-the-homestretch-trump-campaign-says-its-ground-game-is-stronger https://www.npr.org/2020/10/26/927453369/outspent-in-the-hom...
Bloomberg spent $100 million in Florida alone only to have Trump win it by a bigger margin than in 2016.
See also: https://www.cnbc.com/2016/11/09/trump-spent-about-half-of-what-clinton-did-on-his-way-to-the-presidency.html https://www.cnbc.com/2016/11/09/trump-spent-about-half-of-wh... (“Trump spent about half of what Clinton did on his way to the presidency.”).
In the 2018-2020 timeframe, gun control supporters vastly outspent gun control opponents. They failed. Supporters of Prop 209 in California vastly outspent the opposition. They failed by a huge margin.
It’s actually hard to “game” the American political system. What companies like Intuit do is spend money to expose existing fault lines. Republicans are up and down the line opposed to easy tax filing because they think it’ll make it easier for government to raise taxes if people have to manually do their taxes every year. Intuit didn’t create this political fault line. It’s pre-existing. It’s based on ideology. The money is to connect Intuit’s issue (tax filing software) to this existing political fault line.
- User23 6y ago> It’s actually hard to “game” the American political system. Time magazine disagrees with you[1]. [1] https://time.com/5936036/secret-2020-election-campaign/ https://time.com/5936036/secret-2020-election-campaign/
- rayiner 6y agoThe Time story supports my point. Trump was a historically unpopular President who had basically stopped governing during COVID. And as the Time article points out, Biden had everyone from Wall Street to the media to Big Tech in the bag for him. Biden vastly outspent Trump in October. Bloomberg dumped $100 million into Florida. Yet Biden won by just 80,000 votes in Arizona, Georgia, and Nevada, with Trump getting the second most votes in history, higher than Obama. Maybe the full backing of Wall Street, Tech, and the media combined pushed Biden over the finish line. But it was at best a nudge. And how modest that effect was should be good for thought for skeptics.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI'm curious what your definition for "full backing" is. Trump had a banner advertisement on youtube on election day. NetPAC and similar corporate pacs donate as much or more to Republic candidates as dems. Similarly, you have many powerful people in silicon valley, including Paul Graham criticizing companies for dropping the veneer of impartiality that favored trump, and moving to actually uphold their own values. Wallstreet similarly didn't exactly do much to favor biden. You can't talk about the media without mentioning fox, which is the largest single media institution, and favored Trump until at least December. Yes, biden had much stronger support from individuals, and in some cases that translated to endorsement from institutions. But it didn't really translate to institutional support like you seem to be implying. I mean the only sort of institutional support you could argue is that generic GOTV efforts favor dems, which while true isn't strong favoritism. There's a vast difference between targeted lobbying for a particular policy position (especially when there isn't a clear opposition, who is the group that lobbies for clear govt managed tax handling?) And political campaigning. For the first, you don't even need to appeal to voters.
- rayiner 6y agoThe generic gotv efforts were in geographic locations strongly favoring democrats. Zuck wasn’t helping to get out the vote in rural Wisconsin.
- joshuamorton 6y agoThe Generic Gotv efforts I'm speaking about are generic. They're on the facebook timeline and Google search page. They exist just as much in rural wisconsin as they do in downtown SF.
- 93po 6y agoIn what way did he stop governing?
- wombatmobile 6y ago> What companies like Intuit do is spend money to expose existing fault lines. ... > Intuit didn’t create this political fault line. It’s pre-existing. It’s based on ideology. I'm not sure what you're trying to say here, in moral terms. Is your intention to defend Intuit's actions?
- rayiner 6y agoWhat about my post makes it seem like I’m making a moral point?
- sundarurfriend 6y agoI think their point is more generally against the "you can buy anything in politics with money" idea in this thread. They're saying there's evidence to the contrary in the big elections, and that the weak points in the political system are in specific places for specific reasons, and companies like Intuit are exploiting those places, not subverting the entire political system just because they have money. I'm not sure I 100% agree with the argument, but it's a decent case to be made. (Unfortunately, mentioning Trump and the election quickly triggers people's defense mechanisms and attracts downvotes like here, even if the comment is using it as just supporting data in their argument.)
- wombatmobile 6y agoThat's a good attempt to clarify the post, and it does make it easier to parse, or at least it would if I understood what a "weak point in the political system" means, but I don't know what that means.
- anigbrowl 6y agoRepublicans are up and down the line opposed to easy tax filing because they think it’ll make it easier for government to raise taxes if people have to manually do their taxes every year. I think you meant to say it would make it harder to raise taxes if people had to do their returns manually. I also think you're mistaking the excuse offered by Republicans for the underlying reason. After all, if it were true then Republicans would be logically be opposed to any sort of electronic filing, whether offered from the IRS or by a third party.
- rayiner 6y agoYes that’s what I meant sorry.
- refurb 6y agoAgreed. There are plenty of examples where overwhelming money failed to change the outcome. Bloomberg’s presidential run where he spent $1B and failed miserably is a great example. As is the failure of the Keystone XL pipeline where according to HN that sweet, sweet oil money would be impossible to defeat. Well, it was defeated. The mistake people make is “oh this problem hasn’t been fixed and someone is spending lobbying dollars so it won’t be fixed, so that must be the reason”. I’d ask if Intuit wasn’t lobbying against cheaper ways to files taxes so we really think it would have been implemented?
- triceratops 6y ago> This particular belief really shouldn’t have survived the Trump era If the effect of money is really not significant, why don't politicians simply ignore the funding and do what they think their constituents want?
- munk-a 6y agoThe effect of money on campaign outcomes is what he was speaking in reference to - a lot of lobbying money ends up getting funneled directly into candidates pockets through advantageous deals and future employment promises as well as undercharged services (like renoing someone's house for a few dollars) and that money can be quite significant. America has an insane bribery problem.
- monkpit 6y ago> America has an insane bribery problem. I wonder if this is more or less applicable to Politics in general, and not specifically American Politics.
- munk-a 6y agoI think that Politics is naturally self-corrupting but the extreme partisan divide in America has, IMO, made politicians less vulnerable to the crap they tread in. There is very little you can do to make yourself less desirable than someone on the other team so corruption is really only an issue for being primaried and toeing the party line can still protect you pretty effectively.
- boulos 6y agoI think this thread is conflating election contributions/outcomes with lobbying. The main point of lobbying is not in the direct, (historically) small campaign contributions but in the large staff of lobbyists who spend time with congressional staff and leadership. Lobbyist groups don’t care (too) much about who’s elected. They want to influence the lawmaking process. The election examples above are not particularly relevant to lobbying. But they are relevant to money in politics, so I for one upvoted your comment. You definitely hint at the distinction between elections (and the relative lack of effectiveness) and lobbying, but I imagine people were confused by your reply (though “game the political system” is also vague).
- munk-a 6y agoI would strongly disagree with > Republicans are up and down the line opposed to easy tax filing because they think it’ll make it easier for government to raise taxes if people have to manually do their taxes every year. I think republicans tend to be against easy tax filing since it would involve wider access to the plethora of loopholes that exist in our tax system. Automatic filing would really level the playing field if small businesses and individuals got access to some[1] of the loopholes that corporations regularly exploit. 1. Ignoring, of course, accounting tricks required to set some of these up by offshoring profits/income and other advanced techniques around valuation.
- leetcrew 6y agothis doesn't really make sense to me. most people have pretty simple tax situations. no matter how much you pay your accountant, there aren't many loopholes for a W-2 employee to exploit. "easy tax filing" doesn't have to mean that the government guarantees an absolutely optimal filing (how could it? it's not clear to me that it understands its own rules without ambiguity). it could instead mean that your return gets prepopulated with the most obvious filing strategy for your situation. for most people, the obvious way would be the same as the optimal way, and people with weird situations could keep doing their own taxes.