7 ms·
Migrate Everything from Linux to BSD
- ltbarcly3 6y agoAny time i see the term "bloatware" I know I'm dealing with a poser.
- umvi 6y agoOk, but then if everyone switches to BSD, won't it suffer the same fate? I.e. whenever something goes mainstream, corporations are drawn to it like insects to a lightbulb.
- abiogenesis 6y agoWe'll then switch to something else, or maybe back to Linux.
- imachine1980 6y agothis is not an argument, this idea that non mainstream is better is harmful , you could and should use bsd over Linux for real argument like loving the idea of "monolithic os", the problem whit the Linux foundation (one or all), or the problem of abundance nesting in most of Linux but it inst about being mainstream, they still exist project whit difference approaches some less orthodox, or non corporation, i think Linux have more robust ecosystems, the thinks works out of the box is a and approach who let people let in the ecosystems like corporations, example if you don't want systemd make a distro(share it please) or use one of the already existing once LTS or rolling realizes approach.
- abiogenesis 6y agoMine was a sarcastic comment but whatever.
- throwawayboise 6y agoThe article addresses that. Companies are free to do whatever they want with BSD and as such they don't need to try to affect the way things are going. If that wasn't the case we would possible see, for example, Sony trying very hard to influence the development of FreeBSD because they use that in their PlayStation products.
- chongli 6y agoAnd yet they do anyway. Netflix contributed network code to FreeBSD. In so doing, they took code they had developed and handed over the maintenance to the FreeBSD team. I think this is the biggest incentive companies have for making contributions to open source: they don't want to pay engineers to keep maintaining their own patches forever.
- tal8d 6y agoIf that code were Netflix-centric then that would be a bad thing, but it isn't - so its not.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI didn't understand that argument at all. The GPL mandates that companies release their code. That's it. There's no rule that the code has to be upstreamed or that the companies need to try to make other projects use it. To the extent such behavior is incentivized, it should be incentivized just as much with more permissively-licensed code.
- ashafer 6y agoI always understood the argument to be that for rapidly changing projects you might be forced to upstream your GPL code or face an uncomfortably high maintenance burden of constantly rebasing it. Linux almost purposefully does this, it's kind of like a "soft" vendor lock in. Linux kernel interfaces change regularly, and if you don't upstream your code you need to commit time to fixing what breaks. If you upstream, then someone else will handle updating your code for you for free. The more regularly they churn the internal interfaces the more it costs to maintain external patches and the more appealing upstreaming becomes. The end result is lots of companies jamming their code upstream because it is cheaper (or they are soft-required) to do so, not because it is good for the project. The benefit is you have large corporate contributions, with the possible downside that the companies want to take your software in a different direction than you do (i.e. Microsoft embracing/extending). The BSD license doesn't try to strongarm people into contributing, and the BSD projects are open to being a base for other projects. This is bad because companies may not contribute back to you. It is good because it means that you don't have 20 companies pressuring you do make decisions. They've gone in their 20 directions and they want you to continue to be a solid base for them to build on. I think a lot of people (me included) like the feel of this way more. When you read through FreeBSD you don't see the legacy code from a bunch of corporations mixed in, you just see the good stuff. People contribute because they want to even though it's more work, versus reluctantly contributing because it's less work. Not saying permissive licenses are perfect and don't have their own problems, just explaining why they might have different advantages.
- d3nj4l 6y agoI'm not in the loop here. What's the "opt-out spyware" in linux distros the author mentions?
- threentaway 6y agoUbuntu at one point packaged in Amazon search by default.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- geofft 6y agoFrom the article, it sounds like it's that upstream systemd uses Google Public DNS as a default (if you don't configure a server or get one in your DHCP lease) and Firefox uses Cloudflare's DNS-over-HTTPS, which would allow those companies to see all your DNS queries.
- wtfrmyinitials 6y agoIf you’re doing DNS some company is going to see your DNS queries. So the objection is the new default choice?
- necovek 6y agoI think the objection is the type of company that sees your requests. Traditionally, it's your ISP who gets to see your and all their users' DNS lookups. But now it's Google (on top of your ISP) and Cloudflare (on top of with 1.1.1.1 and instead of your ISP for DNS-over-HTTPS), and the claim is that they are going to misuse the data (well, it's pretty much a fact for Google). I am generally not in favour of any siloing and centralisation of that scale, but if you want private DNS, your options are quite limited. I also wonder if it'd make sense to bundle a simple DNS-over-Tor service or would that be easy to track? I'd run it on my openwrt router.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CameronNemo 6y agoPipewire is becoming more common, although it is compatible with ALSA, JACK, and pulse clients so more unification than fragmentation.
- thomascgalvin 6y ago> Proprietary operating systems like Microsoft Windows 10, Apple MacOS, and Google Android have become famous for their ill conduct... I find it mildly ironic that MacOS was based on BSD.
- jmspring 6y agoYou mean like adding systemd and snaps ... that make it harder to run a system in a deterministic manner with easy security updates, etc?
- dralley 6y agoI'd really like to hear your explanation for how systemd is "harder to make deterministic" than piles upon piles of init scripts.
- georgyo 6y agoSnaps, flatpak, and similar containerized package distribution are all trying to build an app store to monetize software distribution. And an attempt to get a software distribution method gain popularity across linux distribution lines. While I will never use these methods, and I think they are completely flawed ideas, I think the goal of them is a natural evolution of fragmented similar systems. The BSDs have the same problem as linux distributions. The open source BSDs share a lot of code but aren't quite the same. If several of them got very popular, someone would attempt to make a method to distribute software across all of them. Though in BSD this is harder because in linux land at least the kernel is standardized.
- hyakosm 6y agoMacOS is not based on BSD, it's an old legend. NeXTStep was designed to be "compatible" with 4.3BSD (the diagram on Wikipedia is wrong because of this confusion). Edit : source about compatibility on the last page : http://www.nextcomputers.org/NeXTfiles/Docs/Developer/NeXT_Development_Tools.pdf http://www.nextcomputers.org/NeXTfiles/Docs/Developer/NeXT_D...
- 6y ago
- vinkelhake 6y ago"Linux is fragmented", and then goes on to list Free, Open, Net, Dragonfly and avoids listing a few more. "Poettering creepware". Web developers who use Google Analytics are "stupid". This is emotion-driven drivel.
- Spivak 6y agoI really don’t get the weird cult of people seemingly obsessed with Lennart. The man sets out to solve really hard problems in the Linux desktop space, isn’t afraid of tackling complexity when it shows up in the problem domain, and is obsessed with correctness. That last one gets him in trouble from people who want him to be more pragmatic but I personally really appreciate it. I really admire him for being the poster child for knowing when to say no. He pumps out really high quality software (seriously, read some of his source code it’s really easy to hack on), is genuinely innovative, and all people seem to do is shit on him and make him out like he’s some Linux daemon laughing manically every time a sysadmin gets frustrated. Anyone who uses the phrase “potteringware” please listen to him talk at any conference he speaks at like All Systems Go. He really is down to earth and really thinks through problems before tackling them.
- raverbashing 6y agoI can agree with not taking things personally but "obsessed with correctness" is not how I would describe systemd or PA
- viraptor 6y agoCorrect. And there are other people working on those projects too, even if we assume Lennart is that good. I found a fairly trivial DoS issue in systemd-resolved in ~10min with a fuzzer. (Years ago, fixed already) That shouldn't happen in a system obsessed with correctness.
- biglost 6y agoI can’t understand why ini format for config files, cant use sed easy... :(
- jcastro 6y agoIt's been multiple decades, "Linux Sucks" still seems to be the only thing BSD advocates talk about. 24 mentions of systemd and 0 mentions of the word "jails", come on, you're not even trying.
- sobriquet9 6y agoAre HiDPI displays supported in BSD?
- tonetheman 6y agonope
- CyberRabbi 6y agoThis post is mostly Linux FUD. I don’t understand what’s the use of this. Actually I always found it funny and a little brave that Linus called ZFS a buzzword. In my opinion he’s right. ZFS breaks a lot of use cases but unless you know what you’re talking about you’re going to think it’s the end-all. I slightly prefer the MD-RAID system.
- silly-silly 6y agoI found it would fail allocations in kernel on 32 bit too.. making me a bit uncomfortable.
- ben509 6y agoI didn't get the ZFS complaint either. Countless years of development went into OOP. Lots of great software has been written with it. It's still a buzzword.
- nine_k 6y agoThe fragmented nature is what I love about Linux. In other words it's called "choice". Because of the fragmentation, I don't have to use systemd, or pulseaudio, or snap, or Gnome desktop, or most other things I don't want to use for whatever reason. I can configure my box (or my container) mostly the way I see fit. If you want ultimate unification, choose macOS. These guys are certain that they know what you need, and rid you of the need to choose. If you want a bit less strict unification but with backwards compatibility, choose Windows. BSD sees less fragmentation mostly because it's less widely used. Though FreeBSD, OpenBSD, NetBSD, DragonflyBSD, and even Darwin exist, and differ significantly form each other. The BSD land, fortunately, also offers choice.
- dataflow 6y ago> Because of the fragmentation, I don't have to use systemd, or pulseaudio, or snap, or Gnome desktop, or most other things I don't want to use for whatever reason. I think part of the very reason some folks like you don't like to use some of those things is their shortcomings... which likely come about in part due to the plethora of choices leading to fragmented efforts on the development side. People shift their attention to the newer/shinier things all the time, and nothing ends up becoming rock-solid to the point where you wouldn't even think about wanting to replace it. To put this into perspective, consider how bizarre it would be to hear end-users complain "What if I want to replace the Windows Audio/Task Scheduler/etc. service with something else?" in Windows land.
- badsectoracula 6y agoEnd users might not complain about that but most end users do not care about that. For those that care there are replacements like Process Explorer/Hacker. And people have tried a LOT to replace stuff in Windows, it is just that Microsoft doesn't make it as easy as on Linux.
- nine_k 6y agoI specifically did not speak about kernel services. I would gladly replace the window manager and the desktop manager in Windows. It is even possible.
- dcassett 6y agoI recently moved my home systems from Ubuntu to Debian because Ubuntu dropped 32-bit support (I have a mix of 64 and 32-bit and wanted to keep them on the same OS). The installer didn't work on my oldest laptop from 2003 with a new mSATA SSD IDE adapter (it hung when formatting the SSD). In the process of debugging the problem I tried FreeBSD for the first time, which not only installed successfully but even supported the wireless adapter. I'm running LXDE as I'm doing with the other machines. The learning curve was far less than I expected, so hats off to the FreeBSD project!
- crazy_hombre 6y agoFreeBSD 13 is moving the i386 architecture to tier 2 status, so looks like the days of 32-bit support in FreeBSD might be numbered as well: https://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-announce/2021-January/002006.html https://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-announce/2021-Ja...
- est31 6y agoThe licensing agreements of BSD make it more likely to be taken over by corporations, not less. Copyleft is a feature of Linux, not a bug. From a practical level, BSDs have also way less driver and software support than Linuxes. Outside of FreeBSDs network stack being better than the Linux stack, I can't see a reason to use BSD over Linux unless you want full proprietary control over your platform, which most times you don't need to make lots of money, at least to that degree.
- vitus 6y ago> DNS over HTTPS is by itself bad enough, and highly criticized with good reason The criticisms of DoH seem to be around removing the ability of third parties to snoop on your DNS queries. Am I missing something here? Like, yes, some of the use cases outlined in the linked wiki article [0] are arguably legitimate (parental controls, cybersecurity identification of C&C nodes), but then we quickly move into murkier territory (ISP blockages due to government mandates). Preventing MitM attacks is an explicit design goal of DoH, not a side effect. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS_over_HTTPS#Criticisms_and_implementation_considerations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS_over_HTTPS#Criticisms_and_...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hg35h4 6y agoIt's horrible for environments with split horizon DNS. It presumes that the only network that should exist are home users consuming public Internet cloud services. For privacy it's a discussion of do I trust my obnoxious non-US ISP or a US based .com with seeing all my browsing habits based on DNS queries. At least I could have legal recourse with my ISP in my own country, and there is slightly better privacy laws.
- mcguire 6y agoSplit DNS is a stupid, stupid idea. But DoH doesn't sound like an improvement.
- hg35h4 6y agoIt was a fine simple solution until DoH. In some internal environments the internal traffic volume can be much higher than the few services that might be publicly exposed. Sure lots of ways you could do it - get a fat edge firewall to hairpin the traffic + support Internet access but you end up paying a lot more for all the threat licenses on the oversized edge. Could add many more tiers, maybe more translations or overlays... but why bother with a lot more complexity or especially more cost just because someone saw a threat in another country and are trying to solve a problem that does not apply to most. Further more there can be internal only host names that are now getting probed and exposed externally. Exfiltration to a US company in the name of "security"
- tlhunter 6y agoI've been using Linux as a daily driver on laptops for about the last 12 years. I mostly do backend service development, having code that ultimately runs on a Linux server, so it's been quite easy for me to adopt. I would have installed BSD on one of my primary dev laptops by now, but there's one huge software compatibility missing for me: https://wiki.freebsd.org/Docker Docker's currently broken. It's not that I need something-like-Docker, which BSD absolutely has. It's that I need straight-up-Docker. I also write a lot of books, the last one having the reader run applications in Docker and run various services from Docker, so it's important that I'm doing something on my Linux dev laptop that isn't too different than my readers who seem to be mostly on MacOS.
- athms 6y agoYou can use Bhyve and run Docker in a Linux virtual machine. Docker works similarly under MacOS using the Hypervisor Framework. FreeBSD would need to radically change in order to implement Docker natively.
- pmlnr 6y agoFreeBSD had "containers" - jails - a decade before linux: https://docs.freebsd.org/en/books/handbook/jails/ https://docs.freebsd.org/en/books/handbook/jails/ I still don't understand why Docker was not made to run on jails as well.
- jsmith45 6y agoI'm not sure the default jail utility is quite as flexible as what Linux namespaces+cgroups can do. It does look like most of what really matters does exist in some form, and I'd guess any important cases that don't exist could be fixed with a few new simple sysctl options. However, BSD's do not guarantee that their userlands will work with a mismatched kernel. Sure, it often does work, hence why jails only give a warning on mismatch rather than refuse to run at all. Also containers are most useful when most containers you want are actually available for your platform. Unless you use the Linux Emulation features, I'd suspect that relatively few containers would be mode available to run on FreeBSD. And the problem with Linux personality systems is that while many programs will work fine with them, there will always be some Linux syscalls that are unimplemented, or have important limitations/differences. So while many programs may work, some will not work. Even if the system call is fully supported, not all use cases will be. For example, not every file system Linux supports will be mountable, and programs could be using loopback mounts that need such support for weird reasons (I'd bet has made an app-bundle system for linux that relies on loopback mounting ext4). There is a reason why Microsoft abandoned the personality like implementation of WSL1 in favor of virtualization for WSL2. Now admittedly, things are not nearly as bad on FreeBSD, since implementing one Unix-like personality in a different Unix is going to be easier and work better than trying to implement it on a decidedly non-Unix kernel. But even so, there will always be some programs (however obscure) that won't work right, while virtualization can largely avoid that. (Albeit with new limitations like not being able to easily access host hardware). Noth of the above is at all a dealbreaker. containerd and docker support windows containers which have many of the above mentioned concerns, and many additional ones like the restrictions on distributing the windows base images. What really needs to happen for jail support for docker is to come up with the FreeBSD specific options for the OCI spec, implement an OCI runtime based on jails, add support for setting the OS specific options in containerd, and implement needed network support in dockerd. (containerd leaves networking setup to its caller, as docker has different opinions than kubernetes for example). The containerd people will almost certainly not object to the needed patches. If I had to guess, the docker maintainer's big concerns over a moby patch will be the overhead of supporting the needed patches (since FreeBSD will rightfully be seen as far more niche than Linux), and that the end-user experience of various docker command lines work more or less as users expect. (I.e. not more different from docker-on-linux than docker-for-windows-containers is). None of this is at all insurmountable.
- timClicks 6y agoIt's 2021 and we're still complaining about systemd.
- enriquto 6y agoyeah that thing is tough to kill, isn't it?
- jaimex2 6y agoI had no idea about the creepware. Good write up!
- scythe 6y agoThere's just not enough in BSD for desktops. Ultimately, BSD solves package manager fragmentation (kinda, although there are now four BSDs) but not graphics layer fragmentation, and nobody's investing their time in half of a solution. Sure, "it's for servers [and powerusers]", but the barrier to entry is always lower for OSs you can use on the desktop and the narrative that most developers like tinkering with their config files has by now been conclusively disproven. As for graphics layer fragmentation, it seems like Wayland makes it worse by handing more of the graphics stack over to window managers. But I guess it's also an opportunity for a BSD to make their own 'blessed' compositor (although this is extremely unlikely IMHO, for graphics driver reasons if nothing else).
- _ZeD_ 6y ago>>> The GPL license is more strict on developers and it is an open source anti-pattern ...oookk...
- foxhop 6y agoI wish the post had actionable advice to migrate.
- jaza 6y agoIn terms of the privacy and corporate interests concerns, at least, it seems like a lot of this article consists of systemd hate. So use a non systemd Linux distro. Simple! https://nosystemd.org/ https://nosystemd.org/ can help you choose one. (I know, pretty much all the major distros have fallen like dominoes, but there are still reasonably mainstream choices out there). There's almost no mention of such issues in the Linux kernel itself, except for "the kernel forcing adaption of DRM". I'm not versed in that story, feel free to enlighten me. But from following the link to the kernel.org thread, it seems fairly clear that the feature in question is opt-in, and that the Linux kernel therefore isn't forcing DRM onto anyone.
- zelly 6y ago> Linux is fragmented Ten year old FUD. Most distros are on systemd now. Whatever you want to say about systemd, it's definitely not fragmentation. Also there's the freedesktop project and dbus which creates a standard API for desktop applications. All Linux distros use glibc and GNU coreutils. Where's the fragmentation? Linux desktop applications are all very fragmented and broken (GNOME, KDE, 100 different tiling window managers, 100 different music players that all suck), but that's not Linux, that's userspace. > Torvalds has a bad opinion on ZFS Doesn't matter. ZFS on Linux still works. Also ZFS is not immune to criticism. BTRFS is getting better and is more than adequate for everyone who is not running a CDN. Also ZFS isn't exactly usable on all BSDs, just FreeBSD (nor did FreeBSD come up with ZFS in the first place (why not migrate everything to Solaris then?)). > Linux is being heavily influenced by corporate interests Good. Problem? The computer is a tool not a political bumper sticker. I'm happy to use something for free that developers are paid to improve and that I still have complete control over. Linux [Android] is the most widely deployed OS in the world. It's constantly improving and lots of eyes are on the code. There just aren't enough skilled volunteers to maintain a giant codebase as critical as an OS. https://madaidans-insecurities.github.io/openbsd.html https://madaidans-insecurities.github.io/openbsd.html When BSD is used by corporations, they fork it and make their improvements proprietary. > Time to migrate everything to BSD Then almost everything I do with my computer would be impossible except for dicking around in a web browser. How do I run containers, modern hardware, or CUDA? Hard mode: No Linux emulation.
- Qub3d 6y ago> Linux desktop applications are all very fragmented and broken (GNOME, KDE, 100 different tiling window managers, 100 different music players that all suck), but that's not Linux, that's userspace. See, I get where you are coming from, and I use Linux myself, but I feel that the author sees this as the fragmentation problem. One of the author's points is that the division between userspace and kernel is a problem, and the *BSDs offer up full operating systems, not just kernels. From TFA: "Linus Torvalds has many times made it very clear that he doesn't care about what goes on in the "Linux world", all he cares about is the kernel development" Otherwise, yeah... BSD is a great choice for some stuff, but it certainly falls short of the tools available to a Linux environment.
- 6y ago
- greatgoat420 6y agoFix Realtec Ethernet Driver support?(In response to the title). I have tried to use FreeBSD many times at work, but due to the driver support I cannot. It hangs and fails super often when using a Realtek device. I got to look like a dick during a board meeting trying to show off our throughput when the issue manifested itself for the third time.
- Jkvngt 6y agoI’m doing this right now. Linux has gotten too large, bloated, corporate. It no longer feels like a community project and there are quite a few recent move that make me question whether or not it will be viable down the line.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoYou'll be back :)
- Jkvngt 6y agoI've already moved the whole office. Even have the one proprietary program that we need, Mathematica, running in Linux VMs on OpenBSD and displaying without a hitch thanks to x.org.
- Ceezy 6y agoLinux is bad doesn t tell us why we should use BSD
- FrozenVoid 6y agoThis article insight is GPL 'virality' forces commercial developers to modify and maintain Linux components as open-source which results in Linux being developed for the commercial developers benefit, vs BSD license allowing commercial developers to keep their modifications to themselves. The latter prevents companies from directing/pressuring OS development and removes incentives to meddle in design - while it does lose 'progress' it retains more freedom in choosing the direction of progress.
- juststeve 6y agoWell that sounds like dependency nightmare.
- 0dayz 6y agoOh no, I remember reading this sometime ago and most of the complains were either subjective or proven wrong by the author themselves.