3 ms·
The US has some terrible problems but this article doesn't discuss them, preferring a convenient and lazy argument based on nonsense: > America doesn’t make it
by gumby 6y ago
The US has some terrible problems but this article doesn't discuss them, preferring a convenient and lazy argument based on nonsense:
> America doesn’t make its own shoes. It doesn’t make some nuts and bolts or fasteners, it doesn’t make industrial things anymore because if money is to be made off an industrial company it’s to buy and sell the company, not to make loans to increase the company’s production.
This is of course utter bullshit. The US manufacturing output is more than 1/2 china's (about 16% of world production vs 28% for china) despite having less than a quarter the population. Sure, on a per capita basis Germany produces more than the US but back of the envelope the US is #2 or #3. And that doesn't include agriculture which in the US (and other OECD countries but not China) is highly industrialized, or housing or other such: just factories making physical goods.
What has happened is that the US manufacturing has moved into a saddle curve: either products that are too low in value compared to their transport costs (e.g. paper) or of such high added value that the other costs mentioned in the article are not relevant (high precision bearings, some kinds of software, chip fab equipment...and yes some fasteners). Unfortunately some of this consists of arms (e.g. F-35) which are sort of the ultimate in Bastiat-style "broken windows" and end up reflecting very little in actual economic development and fundamental growth). But still, a huge amount of manufacturing.
Of course by the nature of this, the US ends up exporting less of its manufacturing output than a country like China would, as its goods are either non-exportable or of more limited utility.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI don't see how your facts disagree with the assertion. The US manufactures more in terms of dollars, but in terms of volume of goods the US falls behind significantly. These goods require efficient labour - that is, labour that is efficiently reproduced, and therefore cost-effective housing, healthcare, and so on, to be made effectively, as well as high-volume, low cost, logistics. Because of this, the US cannot do the kind of manufacturing China can do systematically, whereas China simply needs better technology to be able to manufacture the very high value goods that are dominant in the US This inevitably leads to a weakening of the US manufacturing sector assuming competitive markets. Also, if you're taking into account goods that cannot be imported or exported for structural reasons and whose components are of negligible price, you should do some adjustment for purchasing power parity, as the exact same goods in another economy would be sold at a much lower price
- gumby 6y agoThanks for your thoughtful comment. I'm afraid I'm not sure I understand/agree with your position. Certainly the volume of manufactured goods doesn't matter much to me any more than the total mass (which might even tip the scales, so to speak, in the US's favor). I assume you mean that the US makes a smaller distribution of goods. From a Ricardo PoV this should be irrelevant. OK, but we live in the real world. As I said, I do think there are some bad problems, a major one in this regard being the lack of supply chain diversity (some of which would be handy to have in the US). Lack of such diversity increases friction on developing new products. Not sure it's a long term problem though (see below). The clue is in your statement "China simply needs better technology to be able to manufacture the very high value goods that are dominant in the US". China's labor advantage is where humans are required, and demographically, China faces a labor force squeeze in the coming decades, especially when compared to India and much of Africa, but also when compared to the USA. So the Chinese government does have a focus on increased high tech value add (consider planes and the humble biro (ball) pen) and automation. The US is also investing heavily in automation and has been for a while due to its labor costs (I believe the labor content of US manufacturing is lower than the OECD average). So there's a race in the traditional Christiansen sense of "innovation" but in this case the US is extending the automation advantage downwards while China is following the "classic" path upwards (as with the canonical example of minimills). As the degree of automation increases the US margins go up leaving more capital for further development and eroding the advantages of economies that compete only on the basis of human labor -- a kind of extractive industry, actually, though not typically thought of that way. As the marginal cost of production drops, the comparative advantage shifts the other way and I presume all developed economies would incrementally "onshore" more of their manufacturing, in part for a simpler just in time system, and otherwise because at that point shipping cost becomes a material part of BOM cost. This is almost completely a good thing, unless what you have to sell is labor. And that's the problem all around: the US labor force is not that well equipped any more for manufacturing jobs. That doesn't really bother me; I've always considered it absurd that some people think the function of companies is to provide jobs (or much worse, that the function of humans is to perform jobs). The right objective is to simply pay people to be alive and let them enjoy the goods and services they like. Let automation eliminate as much of the drudgery and danger as possible. This does seem to be discouraging for probably 3B of the world's population who have nothing to sell but their unskilled labor. But the topic of this thread is the USA and China, so...