4 ms·
Yes, and it's not wrong. In the US, 21% of GDP is from finance, which is materially non-productive, and this sector was growing at 6% pre-pandemic. The use of
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Yes, and it's not wrong. In the US, 21% of GDP is from finance, which is materially non-productive, and this sector was growing at 6% pre-pandemic.
The use of finance is, at least in theory, it's ability to provide growth to productive sectors. When you're seeing finance being one of the primary drivers of growth by itself, whereas productive sectors don't grow, this indicates that you're lagging behind in your capacity to actually produce value.
To note, this isn't just an "interview with a Marxist". Michael Hudson has a PhD in economics and is a professor of economics at the Univeristy of Missouri. He's a classical economist, that happens to use some elements of Marxian economics too.
- DebtDeflation 6y ago>The use of finance is, at least in theory, it's ability to provide growth to productive sectors. The main distinction is between the primary market (which provides new funding to companies) and the secondary market (which trades existing securities). You need a certain amount of the latter to support the former by providing liquidity. But anything beyond the required amount starts creating what's known as deadweight losses in economics. Unfortunately, an increasing share of the overall financial sector is the secondary market (mainly proprietary trading operations).
- sudosysgen 6y agoUnless I'm misremenbering, in theory the effects of the primary market should correlate with growth in production, right? I'm dusty so I might misremember.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The use of finance is, at least in theory, it's ability to provide growth to productive sectors. No, like all other capitalist industries, the use of finance is increase the wealth of capital owners. > When you're seeing finance being one of the primary drivers of growth by itself, whereas productive sectors don't grow, this indicates that you're lagging behind in your capacity to actually produce value. No, because of its driving growth, it is producing value (not just for it's owners, which is it's narrow purpose, but for whoever is purchasing the service.) If a nation is seeing finance-driven growth, it's just a sign that that is where it's Ricardian comparative advantage lies in the system of trade. And if you look at international trade regimes, there's a pretty clear finance (and information/knowledge work more generally) - manufacturing - extractive heirarchy ranging from the core to the peripheries. Positive changes in relative position in the world economic order are associated very much with moving to the earlier part of that list.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe issue is that you're presupposing that there is a commensurate increase in production in the rest of the market so that you can import it. If you had a closed economy where only the secondary finance sector was growing, you wouldn't see any increase in production at all. And not all information/knowledge work is non-productive. In fact, the vast majority is productive. Just not finance, as nothing is produced. Commensurately, if you had an economy where abstract capital is being accumulated, but production isn't increasing, you're in huge trouble.