7 ms·
I’m not denying there’s a rational reason for an assault weapons ban, apart from a ban on handguns. (I might even support it, for the reasons you mention, if I
by rayiner 6y ago
I’m not denying there’s a rational reason for an assault weapons ban, apart from a ban on handguns. (I might even support it, for the reasons you mention, if I didn’t believe that assault weapons—arms you could use in a militia capacity if necessary—are actually more protected under the second amendment than self-defense weapons like handguns).
But insofar as gun control advocates cite “gun violence” as a problem to be solved, lumping together both homicides and suicides, well handguns are the thing driving that and support for banning those, like in the UK or some other countries, is at historic lows.
- tptacek 6y agoWell, you disagree with Scalia in Heller then, who drew a sharp distinction between military weapons and arms carried for self defense, over like 8 paragraphs, and concludes with a distinction between the kinds of weapons civilians carry and the kind soldiers carry, the latter not necessarily being protected. I agree that we're not likely to get a handgun ban any time in the next 50 years.
- Bancakes 6y agoYou can carry an AR-15 for self defense in your truck. The question is do you require the ballistics of an AR-15's .223 round over a 9x19? In many cases yes, if your intent is to neutralise a threat, then the .223 is a vastly superior round to a 9x19. An ar-15 is more accurate than any pistol, so you will have no misses or at least not as many. And you need fewer bullets to achieve your goal. There is only one major distinction between military weapons and civilian self-defense weapons. For self defense, you have a clear target and you take a few shots. In the military, you provide a base of fire and often don't see what you shoot at. Everything else is commentary.
- jki275 6y agoOh hell no. In the military you are accountable for every round you fire, and you better not shoot something you don't see.
- Bancakes 6y agoYou shoot where and how you are commanded to, it is not your job to think about the rules of engagement when you are given clear orders to, for instance, fire bursts ar a bunch of rocks someone's hiding behind. The average civilian involved in a shooting bears more responsiblity and is scrutinized much heavier than any policeman and certainly any military personnel.
- jki275 6y agoI'm guessing you have no military experience carrying a weapon. I do. It is absolutely the duty of everyone carrying a weapon to employ that weapon in accordance with the rules of engagement and the law of war.
- Bancakes 6y agoI have no active military experience but I have been trained in small arms and tactics. There is sufficient video evidence of US troops shooting to suppress an enemy when given an order to do so. I'm not rejecting RoE but I am referencing such scenarios.
- jki275 6y agoYou simply don't know what you're talking about. Let it go.
- Bancakes 6y agoI guess they never taught you basic infantry tactics or you've never actually shot at someone if you deny a concept like suppressive fire.
- jki275 6y agoIronic coming from someone who has never carried a weapon. A Soldier is responsible for every round they fire. Yes, suppressive fire is a thing, and it has nothing to do with what you're talking about. You don't randomly "suppressive fire" on things you can't identify. You don't randomly shoot at things someone "orders" you to shoot. You don't get to say "oh but LT dumbfuck told me to shoot that civilian" when you shoot a non combatant. In fact, by law you MUST refuse that order as it violates the LOAC. Go google that because I know you don't know what it means. You are responsible for every round you fire. There are plenty of former Soldiers in prison for not believing that.
- jki275 6y agoScalia wrote certain things in dicta in Heller in order to get Justice Kennedy's vote, in a very narrow ruling in a case specifically about handguns. I wouldn't read much into that on the constitutionality of "military weapon" bans -- keeping in mind of course that the things gun control advocates like to call "assault weapons" aren't actually military weapons at all, as manufacture of actual military weapons for civilian ownership has been heavily restricted since 1968 and absolutely banned since 1986.
- tptacek 6y agoI guess my counterargument would be that the modern sporting rifle was designed to be a military weapon. I'd be interested in learning more about the technicalities that designate something as an according-to-Hoyle military weapon, but I'm a little dubious that such a definition will cause me to forget the history of the AR-15.
- jki275 6y agoWell, I suppose there really aren't any technicalities that designate a weapon as "military style" -- it's really a point that doesn't mean anything. The military has used pump action shotguns similar to what you'd find in a duck blind, they've used Remington 700s (the most common hunting rifle and military sniper rifle), they've used air guns (all the way back to the revolutionary war -- the first semiautomatic rifles were air guns used in the Revolutionary War), they've used Ruger .22 handguns with suppressors on them... The distinction that was made in 1986 was that anything fully automatic was banned. I think that's pretty silly, as I'm just as effective with a semi-automatic AR-15 as with a fully automatic M4A1. It makes no real difference, most military troops never flip the switch to automatic because the weapon isn't really even designed for it (machine guns need to have spare barrels, an assistant gunner, normally belt fed ammunition, etc -- they're ineffective otherwise). But that's the legal "definition" such as it is. anyway, kind of all over the place, but the general point is this -- if you look the history of the time in which the 2nd amendment was written, civilians could -- and did -- own ships, cannon, artillery, etc at the time. Who cares about small arms if you can own a ship of the line with cannon? The concept of civilians being restricted in which types of weapons they could own based on whether or not the military could own them would have been considered ridiculous to the founding fathers. "military weapons" are the most effective weapons, if we have the right to own weapons, why would we be restricted to ineffective ones? Conversely, if you're going to ban weapons, why would banning the most effective weapons have any real impact, when a>there are still millions of them in circulation that are never going to come out of circulation, and b> even "ineffective" weapons can be just as effective as those "military style" weapons in a barely trained shooter's hands? I can literally teach someone in fifteen minutes how to be just as effective with a Glock 19 as with an M4A1 inside of a building. Even with 10 round magazines.
- zepto 6y agoCalifornia is heading towards a de-facto handgun ban as we speak.
- wl 6y agoSpecifically, California requires any handgun sold new in California (with exceptions for law enforcement) to be on a "safe handgun roster" maintained by the state. A handgun must meet certain standards to be placed on this roster. That started out with safety testing, like the requirement that a handgun not fire when dropped, but was later expanded to require features like an indicator that there's a bullet in the chamber. In 2008, the law was amended to require that semi-automatic handguns stamp identifying marks on shell casings in certain ways that researchers later determined to be more or less impossible. This provision of the law, however, was not to go into effect until the Attorney General of California certified that the technology was commercially available. In 2013, Kamala Harris falsely made that certification and no new model handguns have been added to the roster since. As manufacturers improve their designs, older versions have gone out of production. As a result, the roster has shrunk significantly since. I wouldn't go as far as to say it's a handgun ban. I think Glock, for example, is perfectly happy to continue to manufacture their Gen3 models as long as the California market exists. But it does lead to a situation where the selection for enthusiasts is extremely limited and will become even more so over time.
- zepto 6y agoAll new commonly available handguns introduced since 2013 are completely banned from sale in California, including all of the safest and most popular handguns in the country. A recent bill passed, requiring that for every new gun added to the roster, 3 must be removed. This is a slow moving handgun ban.
- rayiner 6y agoYes, I do. Second amendment scholarship has changed a lot over the past few decades. It was in the past much more hospitable to gun control than today. Scalia is a product of that. Scalia was also, presumably, trying to build the 5-4 part of the majority. And in any event, the case itself was directed to a self-defense context. But post-Heller scholarship has acknowledged that the case didn’t go as far as it could have. The DC Circuit opinion, by contrast, was simpler and blunter: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/478/370/473051/ https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/478... > The premise that private arms would be used for self-defense accords with Blackstone's observation, which had influenced thinking in the American colonies, that the people's right to arms was auxiliary to the natural right of self-preservation. See WILLIAM BLACKSTONE, 1 COMMENTARIES 136, 139; see also Silveira, 328 F.3d at 583-85 (Kleinfeld, J.); Kasler v. Lockyer, 23 Cal. 4th 472, 97 Cal. Rptr. 2d 334, 2 P.3d 581, 602 (2000) (Brown, J., concurring). The right of self-preservation, in turn, was understood as the right to defend oneself against attacks by lawless individuals, or, if absolutely necessary, to resist and throw off a tyrannical government.
- tptacek 6y agoI obviously don't agree with you here (I'd vote for basically any firearms restriction anyone came up with, though) but this is super interesting.