13 ms·
There is support for restrictions at the edges. But support for a handgun ban is the lowest it’s been in 40 years: https://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/G
by rayiner 6y ago
There is support for restrictions at the edges. But support for a handgun ban is the lowest it’s been in 40 years: https://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/wluipu4hueiosnowvhjepg.png https://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Pro.... It used to be at over 50% in the 1960s. It’s just 25% today.
Handguns are responsible for almost all gun homicides, and are also the main category of firearms used for self defense. And on that core issue, support for restricting access is more unpopular than its ever been.
- tptacek 6y agoYou used to call out that flaw in that logic yourself. We're not generally motivated by routine gun homicides, but by mass shootings, because, as you say, "the activity threatens social stability vastly out of proportion with the probability of any given person being victim to it." It can be rational for policy to target tactical rifles, which can be used to stand off police forces (as they have in several mass shootings) and to rain death down onto a crowded street from a high-rise window, while not addressing the more-common handgun fatalities, just like gun policy doesn't need address the still-more-common traffic fatalities.
- tengbretson 6y agoHandguns are involved in over 80 percent of mass shootings. https://www.statista.com/statistics/476409/mass-shootings-in-the-us-by-weapon-types-used/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/476409/mass-shootings-in...
- tptacek 6y agoThat would be more a mic drop if I hadn't also provided reasoning for heightened concern about tactical rifles, which your stat doesn't rebut.
- zepto 6y agoTechnically true, but extraordinarily misleading. Most people think of ‘mass shootings’ as indiscriminate public events like Parkland or Las Vegas. However the stats cover any event in which where 4 or more people died. The vast majority of these are drug deals gone wrong, gang violence, and other forms of organized crime. Almost none of what most people think of as mass shootings involve handguns. Most people do not think of a drug deal done wrong, which is very likely to involve handguns, as a mass shooting. So when used this way, the statistics are contributing to the spread of misleading bullshit.
- Bancakes 6y agoWhat you just explained is that people are mislead from the start and nobody should show them real data.
- zepto 6y ago> nobody should show them real data. I’m not sure what you mean by this.
- Bancakes 6y agoThe guy posted some statistics on handguns and you asked him not to mislead people. The facts are very clear that shooting 4 dudes in your apartment is considered a mass shooting. Such is the law in this case. People who think mass shootings are sensational breaking-news events like a mad teenager shooting at innocent people, have been led to believe so. It is simply not the case, I'm afraid.
- zepto 6y agoShooting 4 dudes in your apartment is considered a mass shooting by almost nobody. You are welcome to argue for the authority of those who have classified it this way. I’d love it if more people realized that what they are being told are ‘mass shootings’ are not what they have been led to believe.
- rayiner 6y agoI’m not denying there’s a rational reason for an assault weapons ban, apart from a ban on handguns. (I might even support it, for the reasons you mention, if I didn’t believe that assault weapons—arms you could use in a militia capacity if necessary—are actually more protected under the second amendment than self-defense weapons like handguns). But insofar as gun control advocates cite “gun violence” as a problem to be solved, lumping together both homicides and suicides, well handguns are the thing driving that and support for banning those, like in the UK or some other countries, is at historic lows.
- tptacek 6y agoWell, you disagree with Scalia in Heller then, who drew a sharp distinction between military weapons and arms carried for self defense, over like 8 paragraphs, and concludes with a distinction between the kinds of weapons civilians carry and the kind soldiers carry, the latter not necessarily being protected. I agree that we're not likely to get a handgun ban any time in the next 50 years.
- Bancakes 6y agoYou can carry an AR-15 for self defense in your truck. The question is do you require the ballistics of an AR-15's .223 round over a 9x19? In many cases yes, if your intent is to neutralise a threat, then the .223 is a vastly superior round to a 9x19. An ar-15 is more accurate than any pistol, so you will have no misses or at least not as many. And you need fewer bullets to achieve your goal. There is only one major distinction between military weapons and civilian self-defense weapons. For self defense, you have a clear target and you take a few shots. In the military, you provide a base of fire and often don't see what you shoot at. Everything else is commentary.
- jki275 6y agoOh hell no. In the military you are accountable for every round you fire, and you better not shoot something you don't see.
- nokcha 6y agoI initially thought that a ban on 'assault weapons' might make sense, but after learning more about firearms technology, I've come to the conclusion that 'assault weapons' just doesn't make sense as a legal classification. It's mostly about minor cosmetic and ergonomic features (such as having a pistol grip) that look scary to large segments of the population. A Mini-14 Ranch Rifle is nearly as capable as an AR-15, yet nobody is trying to ban it because it looks like a traditional hunting rifle. And there isn't really a clear-cut meaningful distinction between rifles and pistols; a so-called 'AR-15 pistol' is legally a pistol even though it can be easily converted to a rifle by replacing the arm brace with a stock (but to do so legally requires a $200 tax stamp if the barrel under 16 inches long).
- tptacek 6y agoI don't want to recapitulate the whole very long argument here, but I believe this meme about "assault weapons" being incoherent and cosmetic is essentially propaganda. The original FAWB proposals targeted all semi-automatic rifles with detachable clips. Like you, I took the time to learn more about firearms technology and I came to the opposite conclusion you did. See this thread for my reasoning (somewhere in there, there's a back-and-forth about the Mini-14, which is a favorite Facebook meme subject). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21021388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21021388
- ChrisLomont 6y ago>The original FAWB proposals targeted all semi-automatic rifles with detachable clips Yet that was not the definition used in the law. The original FAWB (for rifles) itself defined an assault weapon as a semi-auto rifle with 2 of - folding or telescoping stock - pistol grip - bayonet mount - flash hider - grenade launcher. This was such a ridiculous list, with about zero to do with lethality, that it was trivial to work around. No one was killing people with grenade launchers or bayonets, for example. Targeting only detachable clips only leads to fast loaders like those used for 6-shooters, i.e., it's not much of a deterrent to quickly reloading weapons. In practice and history, these bans seem more based on scary looking features than empirical lethality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Assault_Weapons_Ban https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Assault_Weapons_Ban
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoStarting in the 1980s anti-gun groups pivoted from trying to ban handguns to a top-down approach. Start with bans on big scary weapons AKA "assault weapons", which aren't as common, then move on to handgun bans. Ironically, their push to ban "assault weapons" has only made them more popular with the general public.
- germinalphrase 6y agoI’m actually convinced that most ‘anti-gun’ groups don’t care about banning guns so much as making political hay over the general issue. If they were serious, the “solution” to the “assault weapon problem” is a semi-automatic firearms ban. It’s not realistic, but it is the maximalist position (and only effective way to remove guns of that capability from common possession).
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoI mean, the latest assault weapon bans are approaching a full semi-auto ban minus handguns (unless defined as an "assault pistol"). The strategy is probably to pass -something-, then followup with a more complete ban.
- skinkestek 6y agoIn other words: not every slippery slope is a fallacy?
- ahctully 6y agoIt's always a "fallacy" because the fallacy points out that the "next step" is not an inevitable consequence of the step it's arguing against. An assault weapons ban, to follow this example, will not magically manifest a handgun ban by its very existence, and it is entirely plausible that a handgun ban will still face tremendous resistance. That the "next step" can be someone's eventual goal or desire is irrelevant to the "fallacy" part.
- xyzzyz 6y ago