10 ms·
Times change: 2nd graders killed in Newtown, country music fans laid waste in Las Vegas, etc., etc. You look, for example, at ballot measures in Washington sta
by JKCalhoun 6y ago
Times change: 2nd graders killed in Newtown, country music fans laid waste in Las Vegas, etc., etc.
You look, for example, at ballot measures in Washington state that are about tougher gun laws and they pass by the majority of voters.
Restricting access to guns is popular in this country. I am not surprised that the NRA is finding itself increasingly diminished.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoNot really. Texas is about to become a 2A sanctuary, Utah, Iowa, Texas, Tennessee, Florida are close to passing constitutional carry. Kansas wants to expand concealed carry to 18-20 year olds. Gun sales are at record highs, etc etc.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoThe numbers suggest that a minority of gun owners are buying more and more guns, not that we are seeing more and more gun owners as a percentage — just gun hoarding.
- anewaccount2021 6y agoNo. Five million gun purchase background checks were done last year for new gun owners. https://www.nssf.org/first-time-gun-buyers-grow-to-nearly-5-million-in-2020/ https://www.nssf.org/first-time-gun-buyers-grow-to-nearly-5-... At no time in history have more Americans owned guns per-capita
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoNot according to industry surveys such as data from the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) which reported that 40% of new guns sold in 2020 went to first time buyers, a total of 5 million new gun owners. There's also reason to believe that in an increasingly anti-gun climate, gun owners are lying on traditional gun ownership surveys. On these studies, there's always a significant portion of respondents who refuse to answer the question. I think these are silent gun owners. When democrats like Beto are calling for gun confiscation, would you want to make yourself known as a gun owner?
- HideousKojima 6y agoI realize this is anecdata, but I can confirm that my wife has personally lied on a survey about gun ownership. I've never been part of a survey that asked, but would definitely lie if I was.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoIt should also be noted that phone surveys bias women. How many husbands hide their guns from their wife? I know my dad did.
- dragonwriter 6y agoUm, that statistic you just quoted says that the majority of new guns sold were to existing gun owners, so it's perfectly consistent with the thesis you are using it to contradict (and that's even before considering how many of those first-time buyers aren't first-time owners, but people raised in gun-owning families making their first independent purchase.) The long term trend in gun ownership (both individually and by households) has been down for a long time (different data sources have different exact numbers, but the trend is consistent across them.) The increase over time in guns per capita is the smaller share of gun owning households getting more guns each: more women in those households getting guns, more guns per adult owner, and kids in gun families getting real firearms younger.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoIt doesn't matter if 40% of new sales went to new gun owners or 4%. If people who were not gun owners are buying guns, then the % of people who owns guns is increased. >The long term trend in gun ownership (both individually and by households) has been down for a long time (different data sources have different exact numbers, but the trend is consistent across them.) Or, the number of people willing to admit owning a gun has been on the decline in a gun-hostile climate.
- extra88 6y agoNo, because the data can’t address how many gun owners gave up their guns (willingly or not) in the time period. Or how many gun owners died for that matter. If first-time buyers made up 40% of sales, a net increase in gun ownership is likely. If it’s much lower, maybe not.
- jrgaston 6y agoAnother reason I've never regretted leaving Texas.
- dQw4w9WgXcQ 6y agoWell you must be onto something, because Californians are leaving for Texas in record numbers.
- SeanBoocock 6y agoLike every other state, there is a stark divide in the culture and politics of the major metropolitan areas and everywhere else. San Francisco vs parts of rural Northern California are an even starker example of that than what you would see between Austin or San Antonio and rural Texas.
- paulie_a 6y agoGun owners are a minority in this country. The average american doesnt own one, let alone ten. The minority just is lou.d as hell. The NRA used to be a reasonable organization with a reasonable mission. Then it went batshit crazy
- claytongulick 6y agoDo you have a source for this? It was my understanding that the majority of American households owned at least one firearm. Edit: I found this [1], but the numbers seem a bit questionable. Even if you take them at face value, 44% doesn't seem to qualify as a vocal minority. https://news.gallup.com/poll/264932/percentage-americans-own-guns.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/264932/percentage-americans-own...
- paulie_a 6y agoHousehold is different than person Just because someones father has a gun doesnt make the kid a gunowner or say anything about their attitude towards 2A
- zepto 6y agoSure, so let’s stop counting those people as though they are against gun ownership.
- paulie_a 6y agoIm just saying that they are automatically being included as pro gun whereas the measurement should be individual gun ownership. Not the household stat which is obviously used to make it look more impressive. And remember it's not binary, a lot of people are indifferent and many want more gun restrictions and some want less Back to my original point is the average american does not own a gun
- zepto 6y ago> the average American does not own a gun Remember it’s not binary - the average American owns approximately 40% of a gun.
- minot 6y ago> Restricting access to guns is popular in this country. I think this is a problem with or feature of our democracy. If eighty percent of the voters want gun control but only half of them show up (forty percent) and vote for one of four different candidates but twenty percent of the population makes it their single issue and votes reliably for the same candidate, the candidate wins in first past the post.
- aksss 6y agoBe suspicious when you’re told 80% of the country agrees on any policy position. 80% of the people also probably want society to have less offensive speech, but does that translate to 80% of the people wanting to abridge freedom of speech (particularly theirs)? Probably not. Effective policy, especially when abridging rights, is a very nuanced discussion that most people don’t have the patience or interest to discuss, but everyone has sentiment. “If wishes were fishes, nobody would go hungry.”
- HideousKojima 6y agoSimilarly, you'll see crazy high numbers in support of things like universal background checks, but as soon as you ask questions like "Do you believe a background check should be required to loan your roommate your gun to take to the range/loan your nextdoor neighbor a gun when her ex finds out where she lives/etc." the percentages plummet.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThis is a common rhetorical technique in politics. There are a lot of policies that sound good at first glance but are basically useless or harmful on closer inspection. For example, there are two categories that dominate firearms deaths in the US. The first is gang violence; in this case background checks would have no real effect because gangs have the means to acquire firearms outside of legal channels. The second is suicides; in this case background checks do very little because the purchaser would generally pass the background check. So you have a policy that sounds good, but doesn't make a real dent in the problem and costs a lot in fees and inconvenience on innocent people. But it polls well so it's a rhetorically effective attack, because the opponents who have actually done the cost benefit analysis have to register their opposition to a "popular" proposal.
- Ancapistani 6y ago> Restricting access to guns is popular in this country. I would argue that it is popular in some parts of the country, and extremely unpopular in others.
- anewaccount2021 6y agoGun stores cannot keep inventory on their shelves. In 2020 America gained five million new gun owners. Restrictions have done nothing to curb demand. History tells us gun demand is proportional to threats of new restrictions...so oddly enough if you wanted to reduce demand, you would be better off reducing restrictions
- sky_rw 6y agoOver 4.3 million guns were sold in January 2021. We are on track for another record year. Hard to tell how many were from people exempt from background checks, likely a few hundred thousand more.
- aksss 6y agoThe advances in gun control have almost exclusively been through highly-funded ballot measures. Ballot measure outcomes can generally be predicted when one side has an outsized ad campaign. Look at the funding disparity where gun control measures have passed. And this doesn’t apply solely to gun control but really any target. Buying any legislative change through the ballot measure process works pretty well.
- sgpl 6y agoAs a non-American, I feel that, from whatever I've read, the NRA is finding itself increasingly diminished due to poor leadership that was/is lining its pockets and being a poor steward of their core objectives.
- mhh__ 6y agoPoor Steward -> Corruption
- rayiner 6y agoThere is support for restrictions at the edges. But support for a handgun ban is the lowest it’s been in 40 years: https://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/wluipu4hueiosnowvhjepg.png https://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Pro.... It used to be at over 50% in the 1960s. It’s just 25% today. Handguns are responsible for almost all gun homicides, and are also the main category of firearms used for self defense. And on that core issue, support for restricting access is more unpopular than its ever been.
- tptacek 6y agoYou used to call out that flaw in that logic yourself. We're not generally motivated by routine gun homicides, but by mass shootings, because, as you say, "the activity threatens social stability vastly out of proportion with the probability of any given person being victim to it." It can be rational for policy to target tactical rifles, which can be used to stand off police forces (as they have in several mass shootings) and to rain death down onto a crowded street from a high-rise window, while not addressing the more-common handgun fatalities, just like gun policy doesn't need address the still-more-common traffic fatalities.
- tengbretson 6y agoHandguns are involved in over 80 percent of mass shootings. https://www.statista.com/statistics/476409/mass-shootings-in-the-us-by-weapon-types-used/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/476409/mass-shootings-in...
- tptacek 6y agoThat would be more a mic drop if I hadn't also provided reasoning for heightened concern about tactical rifles, which your stat doesn't rebut.
- zepto 6y agoTechnically true, but extraordinarily misleading. Most people think of ‘mass shootings’ as indiscriminate public events like Parkland or Las Vegas. However the stats cover any event in which where 4 or more people died. The vast majority of these are drug deals gone wrong, gang violence, and other forms of organized crime. Almost none of what most people think of as mass shootings involve handguns. Most people do not think of a drug deal done wrong, which is very likely to involve handguns, as a mass shooting. So when used this way, the statistics are contributing to the spread of misleading bullshit.
- analog31 6y agoIt occurs to me that restricting access to guns is popular in a lot of countries. In a bigger perspective, I'm not sure that the US is unusual in this regard.
- zepto 6y agoRestricting gun access is less and less popular, and gun ownership is rising rapidly across demographics that were traditionally opposed to gun ownership - e.g. women and black women in particular. The NRA is simply a corrupt organization, and even within the pro-gun community has been under criticism for years.
- zepto 6y ago> Restricting access to guns is popular in this country. This is a very misleading statement. The only thing that is popular is keeping guns out of the hands of criminals - which has support across the board. That translates into general support for background checks. Almost no specific proposals other than improving background checks have broad support, and support goes down as more detail is provided. It is not true to say that there is some kind of general support for restricting gun ownership amongst anyone other than already convicted criminals (who don’t generally buy guns from stores anyway).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]